Analysing Risk and Danger

Prev Next
This content is currently unavailable in English (UK). You are viewing the default (English) version.

Implications for Delivery

The ability to convert data into insight about danger is key to understanding network risk. To do this, practitioners need to:

  • Build network risk analysis into the performance management process to support a proactive approach.

  • Consider the activities, data sources and indicators required for analysing risk and danger.

  • Understand the relationship between speeds and injury risk for different conflict and vehicle types. Use this information to inform road design based on human tolerance in accordance with the Safe System.

  • Assess network infrastructure risk regularly, using tools such as the iRAP Star Rating methodology or the Network Wide Assessment tool as appropriate.

Background

Assessment of risk goes beyond counting the number of casualties on the roads. It is proactive, evidence-led and fundamentally centred on the vulnerabilities of human beings, which is core to the Safe System. It involves understanding the potential for harm according to the design of the roads and the interactions between vehicles.  

A good understanding of network risk relies on a wide range of safety data sources and crucially the ability to convert data into insight about danger. It also relies on the implementation of safety performance indicators which measure and track risk.  

Organisational directors and service managers should be monitoring network risk as part of performance management. This involves considering the activities needed to do this (for example infrastructure assessments), together with the data required and indicators to track.  

What the Research Shows

The Safe System acknowledges the vulnerability of humans. From a biomechanical perspective, humans can only withstand a certain amount of force and hence exposure to dangerous forces should be prevented.  

The potential for harm to an individual on a road depends on several factors. In particular:

  • Conflict types present (for example, whether head-on crashes can happen)

  • Vehicles present

  • Speeds of vehicles

  • Infrastructure layout and condition

Considering these factors together facilitates design of a road system where humans are not subjected to forces that might lead to serious injury.

There is a wealth of evidence concerning the relationship between impact speeds and injury risk for different conflict types and vehicle types. This evidence can be used to analyse the risk of different roads and ‘injury risk curves’ should inform the implementation of safe speed limits. If higher speeds are present on roads, better infrastructure is needed to protect road users. For example, roads with the potential for a head-on crash are inherently higher-risk and should have a much lower speed limit than those with a median barrier. Further, the possibility for side-impacts makes junctions more dangerous and this might inform road layout and traffic signalling.  

By assessing conflict types, vehicles and speeds holistically, practitioners can apply best practice evidence to build a Safe System. For instance, the ‘Guide for Safe Speeds’ (GRSF) provides guidance on setting speed limits for different road and conflict types according to impact speeds survivable by humans.

There are several tools for assessing network risk focussed on the infrastructure present. The iRAP star rating methodology is well established internationally and assesses the road network according to road features, grading each section of road as 1 to 5 stars. This analysis can be split by different road user types and can be used to inform interventions at higher risk sites. The Network Wide Assessment methodology (NWA) also evaluates the design characteristics of roads proactively. Key inputs to both tools include objects on the roadside, the presence of barriers or medians and facilities for vulnerable road users such as pedestrians.

SPIs (see Safety Performance Indicators) are critical to risk analysis and should be implemented to track key risk factors over time. For example, infrastructure SPIs can be implemented linked to iRAP star ratings or NWA scores. Speed SPIs can also be implemented based on Safe System speeds, utilising speed data sources to monitor performance. Targets (see Targets) for SPIs can help to bring focus and inform areas for action.

Sources

International Road Assessment Programme (iRAP). (n.d.). Star Ratings. iRAP. https://irap.org/rap-tools/infrastructure-ratings/star-ratings/

Lubbe, N., Jeppsson, H., Sternlund, S., & Morando, A. (2024). Injury risk curves to guide safe speed limits on Swedish roads using German crash data supplemented with estimated non‑injury crashes. Accident Analysis & Prevention, 202, 107586. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aap.2024.107586

National Technical University of Athens, University of Zagreb Faculty of Transport and Traffic Sciences, & FRED Engineering s.r.l. (2023). Network‑Wide Road Safety Assessment – Methodology and Implementation Handbook. European Commission, Directorate‑General for Mobility and Transport; Publications Office of the European Union. https://road-safety.transport.ec.europa.eu/system/files/2023-11/NWA-Handbook8.pdf

Truong, J., Strandroth, J., Logan, D. B., Soames Job, R. F., & Newstead, S. (2022). Utilising human crash tolerance to design an interim and ultimate Safe System for road safety. Sustainability, 14(6), 3491. https://doi.org/10.3390/su14063491

Turner, B. M., Eichinger-Vill, E.-M., Burlacu, A. F., El-Samra, S., & Adriazola-Steil, C. (2024). Guide for safe speeds: Managing traffic speeds to save lives and improve livability. Washington, DC: World Bank Group. http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/099032224020526401