Forgiving Roadside Protection

Prev Next
This content is currently unavailable in English (UK). You are viewing the default (English) version.

Implications for Delivery

Forgiving roadsides entail designing roads where when a road user makes an error, the system ensures that the driver is given an opportunity to recover. Fixed objects such as trees and poles can lead to fatal and serious outcomes for drivers in the event of a crash. Forgiving roadsides entail designing roadside barriers in a manner that they will not cause further harm to drivers when a collision occurs, they are forgiving. Some examples of interventions that can make our roadsides more forgiving involve:  

  • Designing barrier terminals in a way that the edge of the barrier does not harm the road user.

  • Deploying medians, barriers at the edge of the road, and clear zones for helping road users to recover.

  • Creating 2+1 roads where there is a mixture of high speeds and low speeds and help vehicles to safely overtake using these roads.  

  • Incorporating subtle indicative infrastructure such as chevron signs, rumble strips and motorcycle PRIME markings.

Forgiving roadsides should be designed based on your local context including considering aspects such as average speed of road users, use of the road, type of vehicles, geography of the area, resource constraints, among others. There are various toolkits available for incorporating these interventions along with relevant road design principles such as (iRAP, 2022a; Mitra et al., 2021).

Background

Single vehicles that are involved in run-off-road crashes account for a considerable number of fatalities globally (Albuquerque & Awadalla, 2020). Roadside barriers are one of the most popular countermeasures however, traffic barriers have been reported as the third most common cause of fixed-object fatalities after trees and utility poles (Mehrara Molan et al., 2020). Road users are prone to make mistakes that result in crashes on the network that could be fatal or serious. Across Scotland, we aspire to have the world’s safest roads by 2030. Ensuring that we recognise that humans make mistakes and developing a system where we can mitigate any fatal and serious outcomes from these mistakes is vital to embed the Safe System.  

Developing forgiving roadsides is one way of ensuring that we mitigate fatal and serious outcomes. When road users crash into barriers such as trees or rigid barriers on the road, it can lead to higher severity crashes or unforgiving outcomes. Forgiving roadsides is a road design concept that refers to providing adequate protection to road users in the event of a collision that helps road users recover with preventing serious outcomes. These can include aspects such as ensuring adequate barriers to ensure adequate protection especially for vulnerable road users.

The main aim of forgiving roadside protection is to ensure that when a vehicle swerves out of control, it has adequate opportunity to recover from the collision with the help of these roadside protection measures. The type of barriers selected will be dependent on the local context including the function of the road, speed limit, type of vehicles travelling on the network, among others.

What the Research Shows

There are several ways to make our roadsides more forgiving some of which include:  

Barrier terminals  

  • Safety barriers are designed to protect road users, but poorly designed barrier terminals can cause serious harm during a crash. To prevent this, it is considered best practice to anchor the ends of the barrier or ramp them down to the ground (La Torre et al., 2012).

  • Some barriers are also designed to absorb energy from a crash, thus reducing the severe outcomes (Hall, 2014). These energy absorbing barriers, sometimes referred to as passively safe infrastructure can help prevent vehicles rolling down embankments, hitting other vehicles, among others.

Medians and barriers at the edge of the road

  • Barriers placed along the edge of the road are effective at preventing vehicles from leaving the road, especially where there are steep drops or ditches (Turner et al., 2022). Barriers should be selected based on your local context with considering factors such as the speed limit and traffic type. Central barriers (medians) are equally important as they segregate the lane of the incoming traffic and help reduce the risk of head-on collisions (Turner et al., 2022).  

Clear zones  

  • Mitra et al. (2021) explain clear zones as the area beside a road that needs to be kept clear in the event of a road user crashing. Clear zones help in giving a chance to recover control of the vehicle. The width of clear zones can be calculated using various road design guidelines such as from Mitra et al. (2021).  

  • Where clear zones are not practical due to the terrain or the cost, continuous roadside barriers are recommended (iRAP, 2022a). iRAP’s Star Rating Demonstrator, available via their ViDA platform is a free tool that can help estimate the safety benefits of these treatments.

2+1 roads

  • A 2+1 road has two lanes in one direction and one lane in the opposite direction, separated by a median. These roads help manage differences in vehicle speeds such as between cars and heavy goods vehicles by providing some space for safe overtaking. However, there are several road design related considerations that need to be taken before implementing these roads, such as a bigger clear zone and appropriate median (iRAP, 2022b). Overall, iRAP found that implementing these roads can lead to a potential casualty reduction of 25-40%.

Subtle indicative infrastructure  

  • There are several subtle indicative furniture that we can use on roads to cue desired behaviour and prevent fatal and serious outcomes. Some of these include chevron signs, rumble strips and motorcycle PRIME markings.

  • Rumble strips can help in alerting inattentive drivers. These strips can be used at the edge of the road to prevent vehicles from going off-road and the centre of the road alongside median lines to prevent vehicles going into the opposing traffic lane (Mitra et al., 2021). The placement of such strips should be carefully considered depending on the local context. Chevron signs can be used for several aspects such as alerting drivers of an upcoming bend and narrowing of the road (Turner et al., 2022).

Additionally, motorcycle PRIME markings which have shown overwhelming success in ensuring safety of motorcyclists in a recent trail conducted in the west of Scotland (Transport Scotland, 2023) can be incorporated.  These signs provide cues for riders to tweak their behaviour on bends.

Further information is available on these and other Safe Roads Interventions.

Sources

Albuquerque, F. D. B. de, & Awadalla, D. M. (2020). Roadside Fixed-Object Collisions, Barrier Performance, and Fatal Injuries in Single-Vehicle, Run-Off-Road Crashes. Safety, 6(2), Article 2. https://doi.org/10.3390/safety6020027

Hall, S. (2014, September 5). Preventing accidents with the help of motorway barriers. Cenpart Ltd. https://cenpart.co.uk/barriers-essential-motorways/

iRAP. (2022a). Forgiving Roads Concept – Road Safety Toolkit. Forgiving Roads Concept. https://toolkit.irap.org/safer-road-treatments/forgiving-roads-concept/

iRAP. (2022b). Overtaking Lane and 2+1 Road – Road Safety Toolkit [Safer Roads Treatment Toolkit]. https://toolkit.irap.org/safer-road-treatments/overtaking-lane-and-2-plus-1-road/

La Torre, F., Saleh, P., Cesolini, E., & Goyat, Y. (2012). Improving Roadside Design to Forgive Human Errors. Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences, 53, 235–244. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.sbspro.2012.09.876

Mehrara Molan, A., Rezapour, M., & Ksaibati, K. (2020). Investigating the relationship between crash severity, traffic barrier type, and vehicle type in crashes involving traffic barrier. Journal of Traffic and Transportation Engineering (English Edition), 7(1), 125–136. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jtte.2019.03.004

Mitra, S., Turner, B. M., Mbugua, L. W., Neki, K., Barrell, J., Wambulwa, W. M., & Job, S. (2021). Guide to Integrating Safety into Road Design (No. 173358). World Bank. https://documents.worldbank.org/en/publication/documents-reports/documentdetail/099630106302230817/p1713760ca29c50650ba52044bbadbc084a

Transport Scotland. (2023, July 3). New road markings transform behaviour of motorcyclists on bends | Transport Scotland. Www.Transport.Gov.Scot.
https://www.transport.gov.scot/news/new-road-markings-transform-behaviour-of-motorcyclists-on-bends/

Turner, B. M., Job, S., & Mitra, S. (2022). Guide for Road Safety Interventions: Evidence of What Works and What Does Not Work | GRSF. World Bank. https://www.globalroadsafetyfacility.org/publications/guide-road-safety-interventions-evidence-what-works-and-what-does-not-work