Maintenance & Renewal

Prev Next
This content is currently unavailable in English (UK). You are viewing the default (English) version.

Implications for Delivery

  • Transport Scotland’s commitment to delivering a safe and resilient road network relies on robust maintenance and renewal practices embedded within a structured asset management framework.

  • Setting appropriate levels of service is fundamental for defining performance expectations for critical elements such as skid resistance, surface texture, drainage capacity, signage retro-reflectivity, and vegetation control. These standards enable consistent service delivery and ensure infrastructure supports safe user behaviour across diverse operating environments.

  • Renewals should be prioritised based on sound asset management principles, incorporating whole-of-life cost assessments, condition monitoring, and crash risk data. This ensures that investment decisions yield optimal safety benefits and align with Scotland’s long-term transport objectives.

  • Renewal strategies should target surface integrity, drainage functionality, visibility systems, and structural stability, with interventions scheduled to avoid deterioration-related failures.

  • Routine inspections are essential to monitor asset condition and inform work programming. These include scheduled patrols to assess pavement wear, crack development, obstruction risks, and sign clarity. Safety inspections must also be conducted during both day and night to capture variable hazards—day inspections focus on structural issues and roadside conditions, while night inspections assess visibility features such as reflectivity, lighting, and signage. Findings should feed into digital asset management systems and support proactive maintenance planning.

  • Collectively, these practices ensure road infrastructure performs as designed, supports the Safe System approach, and contributes to reduced crash risk across Scotland’s transport network.

Background

Maintaining and renewing road assets is a fundamental activity that supports the safe and effective operation of Scotland’s road network. It ensures infrastructure performs as designed and contributes directly to the delivery of safety objectives outlined in the Road Safety Framework.

Road surfacing is vital for maintaining adequate skid resistance, which allows vehicles to brake and manoeuvre safely in varying conditions. The interplay between micro-texture and macro-texture plays a crucial role in skid resistance and drainage performance. Effective surfacing also provides a waterproof membrane that protects underlying layers, reducing the need for costly rehabilitation.

Levels of service must be carefully managed to determine appropriate surfacing lengths, identify crack sealing requirements, and prioritise areas requiring early intervention.

Road rehabilitation addresses structural issues in pavements that exhibit end of life symptoms, such as cracking and deformation, or fail to sustain anticipated traffic loading. This activity restores roads to near-new condition and significantly improves ride quality and vehicle control. In doing so, it supports both safety and asset longevity.

Sight line management is another key component. Regular vegetation trimming and interventions to prevent visual obstructions - such as restricting vehicle parking near intersections - help maintain clear lines of sight, which is essential for decision-making and hazard recognition.

Signs and delineation systems guide motorists along safe paths and provide vital information about upcoming hazards and directional changes. Maintenance activities include routine cleaning, rotation, and repair to ensure legibility and reflectivity. When signs reach the end of their service life, timely renewal is necessary to meet visibility standards and maintain communication with road users.

Additional safety-critical assets include barriers, street lighting, pedestrian crossings, traffic signals, and intelligent transport systems. Each contributes to the overall performance and predictability of the road environment. These assets must be managed through routine inspection, renewal programs, and integration with broader safety strategies.

Whole-of-life cost assessments are central to effective asset management. By considering the long-term financial and safety impacts of maintenance decisions, Transport Scotland can prioritise investments that deliver optimal value and sustained risk reduction. Proactive renewal and preservation strategies reduce the likelihood of sudden infrastructure failure and improve road user outcomes across the network.

What the Research Shows

A range of studies and policy reviews underscore the importance of sustained investment in road maintenance and renewal as a fundamental contributor to improved safety outcomes.

Research commissioned by Transport Scotland, titled Economic, Environmental and Social Impact of Changes in Maintenance Spend on Roads in Scotland, found that poor surfacing leads to reduced skid resistance, significantly increasing crash risk - especially during wet conditions. Deterioration in street lighting was also associated with higher rates of night time crashes. The study’s economic modelling demonstrated that every pound saved by reducing maintenance spend resulted in a wider societal cost of £1.50, including costs linked to collisions and disruption. It concluded that consistent underfunding of maintenance leads to long-term disbenefits in road safety, reinforcing the principle that well-maintained roads are inherently safer.

Additional findings from the RAC Foundation and the UK Roads Leadership Group support this conclusion. Their work highlights an increase in skid-related crashes where surfaces are degraded or road markings have faded, resulting in compromised driver control and reduced hazard recognition. They also reported a rise in serious cyclist injuries linked directly to defective surfaces, with over 60 incidents per year attributed to poor road conditions. Maintenance delays affecting structures such as bridges have led to significant safety risks and operational failures, as demonstrated by the collapse of the Workington bridge. Crucially, these studies show that road maintenance delivers strong economic returns: every pound invested in timely interventions can produce benefits of up to £9.10, particularly through the reduction of injury and fatality crashes.

International evidence further reinforces this relationship. Analysis from NZ Transport Agency Waka Kotahi examined the effectiveness of New Zealand’s skid resistance policy. It revealed that increasing the SCRIM Coefficient (SC) by just 0.1 resulted in a 30% reduction in crash rates on wet roads and a 20% reduction on dry roads. The policy was also found to achieve a benefit-cost ratio of at least 13, with some sites achieving ratios as high as 35, positioning skid resistance upgrades as among the most cost-effective safety interventions.

This body of evidence confirms that regular maintenance and timely renewal of road assets are central to both risk reduction and long-term value. They form an essential component of Transport Scotland’s Safe System approach, helping to mitigate predictable hazards and deliver safer, more reliable journeys across the network.

Sources

Parkman, C. C., Abell, R., Bradbury, T., & Peeling, D. (2012). Economic, environmental and social impact of changes in maintenance spend on roads in Scotland: Summary report. Transport Research Laboratory for Transport Scotland. https://www.transport.gov.scot/media/29455/j235740.pdf

Audit Scotland. (2013). Maintaining Scotland’s roads: An audit update on councils’ progress. Accounts Commission. https://audit.scot/docs/local/2013/nr_130517_roads_maintenance.pdf

Gould, E., Parkman, C., & Buckland, T. (2013). The economics of road maintenance. RAC Foundation & ADEPT. https://www.racfoundation.org/research/safety

RAC Foundation. (2019). Effectiveness of UK road safety behaviour change interventions (T. Fosdick, Author). https://www.racfoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/Effectiveness_of_UK_Road_Safety_Interventions_Fosdick_November_2019.pdf

RAC Foundation. (2023). Safety publications and research archive. https://www.racfoundation.org/research/safety

NZ Transport Agency. (2011). High-risk rural roads guide. Waka Kotahi NZ Transport Agency. https://www.nzta.govt.nz/assets/resources/high-risk-rural-roads-guide/docs/high-risk-rural-roads-guide.pdf


With thanks to Safe System Solutions for their contribution to this content.

Logo of Safe System Solution, emphasizing security and system efficiency.