Making the Case for Safety

Prev Next
This content is currently unavailable in English (UK). You are viewing the default (English) version.

Implications for Delivery

Making the case for safety, recognises that we are seeking to:

  • influence a range of stakeholders (public, partners, media, politicians etc.)

  • communicate that there is an urgent issue to be addressed

  • convey that this is achievable by measures that we already have evidence for

  • convey that it is desirable for the benefit of wider society without unduly restricting the freedoms of any particular groups

If that sounds like a challenge, it is!

However, in the post-war period it is one that we have successfully negotiated to make our roads considerably safer and framing our messages effectively can help us to make further progress.

To do so we must:

  • Identify the leaders who can help to build momentum and secure an agenda for action

  • Identify the key measures that will make a difference, based on robust evidence

  • Engage widely to build consensus and support for the identified measures

  • Consider how to convey a sense of urgency and avoid any complacency

  • Where possible frame the message positively, as something to be achieved not something to be lost.

  • Consider how messaging that promotes the rights of individuals or marginalised groups supports the call for action.

Background

Making the case for road safety has often been a challenging one, despite the obvious benefits that have been achieved over many decades. Road deaths in Britain reached a post war high in the mid-60’s with nearly 8,000 road deaths each year. At this time measure such as the ‘breathalyser bill’ which introduced an offence of drink-driving and establishing a maximum national speed limit on motorways were introduced. These policies were not universally popular and coordinated efforts by motoring groups were mobilised to try and undermine the legislation. Since then, the cumulative efforts to improve road safety have reduced deaths by more than three-quarters, saving well over 6,000 lives a year, but making the case for safety continues to be an uphill task.

In contrast to other parts of the UK, Scotland has maintained a high level of strategic focus on road safety, establishing a national framework and targets in 2010 – ‘Go Safe on Scotland’s Roads; it’s everyone’s responsibility’, whilst the UK government decided to move away from quantitative targets and a national strategy.

The last six decades of action on road safety make clear that progress requires several important components to align in order to make real progress:

Strong leadership and political commitment

Many of the most significant changes we have seen have been associated with determined leadership (Barbara Castle, drink-drive; Barry Sheerman and Sir Peter Bottomly; seatbelts; Lee Waters and Mark Drakeford, Wales 20mph). Leadership does not always need to come from elected officials either – think about the impact of people like Doddy Weir (MND research), Greta Thunberg (climate), Marcus Rashford (school meals) or Malala Yousafzai (education for girls). Political commitment should also manifest in sufficient funding and resource allocation. The continuity of political focus, rather than frequent changes in leadership, also positively impacts policy action

Scalable policy measures that are evidence based

Policy interventions must be designed with a strong theoretical basis and evidence, as well as addressing a large enough issue to have an impact at scale. This requires robust data collection, including in-depth crash investigations, and continuous monitoring and evaluation of progress.

Public and stakeholder engagement

Gaining public support and acceptance for policy changes is crucial, as is the active involvement of a wide range of stakeholders, including policy entrepreneurs, NGOs, and the private sector. Reframing the problem in a way that resonates with the public and ensures their demand for safety can act as a significant driving force.

What the Research Shows

Framing plays a critical and influential role in moving road safety up the agenda. How road safety measures are portrayed or "framed" significantly impacts the level of public, media, and government attention they will receive, and whether action develops or stagnates over time. Importantly it is related to the questions of leadership and evidence, because these will provide the momentum and intellectual integrity to demonstrate that the measures being proposed are worthwhile and command public attention. Here are some of the reasons that framing is of such vital importance:

Influencing attention

Road Safety is constantly competing for attention. The way road safety is framed can determine if it gains sufficient attention to be recognised as a problem in need of action. Persuading the public or policymakers to reframe an issue to one they can relate to can create fresh momentum and attract additional attention. For instance, reframing road safety differently played a significant role in Sweden's adoption of Vision Zero, a radical new approach.

Shifting perceptions and overcoming complacency

Historically, road safety was effectively framed as an urgent problem, leading to strong political commitment and successful interventions. The high number of deaths and serious injuries during this time contributed to framing the problem as urgent. It could be argued that a powerful ‘counter-framing’ has emerged in recent years, suggesting that Britain's roads are among the safest in the world, creating the impression that the problem had largely been ‘resolved’. The example of climate action is worthy of note here – recent efforts to reframe climate change as a ‘climate emergency’ or ‘climate crisis’ has helped to overcome complacency and create momentum.

Aligning goals and values

The dominance of a ‘mobility framing’ over a ‘safety framing’, influenced by the central role of the private motor car in society, has sometimes crowded out the demand for change. When road safety measures are perceived to be restricting or limiting freedom, then a higher level of pushback is to be expected. If the framing of safety can be more successfully aligned with goals of mobility, independence, wellbeing and freedom (something that is constrained by congestion, pollution, and injury) then we stand a better chance of success.

Rights based advocacy

We can make a more compelling case for road safety measures when reframing the issue from being about statistics, infrastructure, or individual behaviour to being about fundamental human rights - specifically, the right to life, health, mobility, and equity. Rather than treating road deaths and injuries as unfortunate but inevitable by-products of transport systems, a rights-based approach insists they are preventable violations of people’s rights, especially when caused by unsafe road conditions, poor planning, or inaction by authorities. For example, if children cannot safely walk to school due to dangerous roads, that might be regarded as a failure to uphold their right to education and protection. By grounding road safety in human rights, advocates can mobilise stronger public support, demand policy change with greater moral force, and highlight the disproportionate impact on vulnerable groups - such as pedestrians, cyclists, children, and people in low-income areas.

Sources

Edvardsson Björnberg, K., Hansson, S. O., Belin, M.-Å., & Tingvall, C. (Eds.). (2023). The Vision Zero Handbook: Theory, Technology and Management for a Zero Casualty Policy. Springer. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-76505-7

Greenwood, I., Jamson, S., & Marsden, G. (2024). The changing politics of road death in Britain: from policy action to kicking the can down the road. Transport Policy, 158, 255-268. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tranpol.2024.09.011