Implications for Delivery
Organisations seeking to incorporate Safety Performance Indicators (SPIs) into their road safety strategy can consider the following steps:
Identify Relevant Indicators: Start by reviewing the national SPIs and understanding where your organisation’s activity relates to these. There may then be more detailed indicators that reflect your operations and risks.
Establish Baselines and Set Targets: Gather baseline data to understand current performance. Set realistic, evidence-based targets that support national or organisational road safety goals.
Integrate Data Collection into Operations: Use existing systems where possible and consider how digital tools can improve data reliability and reduce manual effort. For example, technology to detect mobile phone use and seatbelt wearing rates, or vehicle telematics / driver monitoring data.
Analyse, Report and Act: Regularly review SPI data alongside crash or incident statistics. Use it to inform training, policy updates, or infrastructure investment. Share performance transparently within the organisation and with external partners.
A note of caution is that, whilst SPIs are powerful tools, they are not without challenges. Collecting consistent, high-quality data can be resource intensive. There may be resistance to monitoring in some cases, so privacy and data protection must be carefully managed (e.g. in observation studies). However, the opportunities far outweigh the obstacles. When well-designed and transparently applied, SPIs empower organisations to act with foresight. They enable better collaboration across partnerships by facilitating the sharing of anonymised data that can illuminate regional trends and support cross-sector solutions.
Background
In Scotland, the drive to reduce road casualties and move towards a Vision Zero future is underpinned not only by sound strategy but by the practical tools used to monitor and influence behaviour. Among these tools, Safety Performance Indicators (SPIs) are essential. SPIs are measurable data points that help assess risk-related behaviours and safety management practices, rather than only tracking final outcomes such as crashes, injuries, or deaths. This attitudinal shift is vital because by the time a crash occurs, it’s already too late to prevent it. Instead, SPIs enable a preventive approach by identifying risky trends early and targeting interventions effectively. SPIs help organisations transition from reactive to proactive road safety management and embed a culture where safety is not just a metric, but a shared value. SPIs don’t just measure behaviour, and other SPIs for the Safe System are discussed elsewhere.
Examples of behaviour-related SPIs include:
Seatbelt wearing rates
Speed compliance (observed or telematics-based)
Drink- and drug-driving behaviour
Driver distraction (e.g., mobile phone use)
Fatigue-related indicators
Vehicle safety ratings and maintenance compliance
Training completion rates for drivers
Telematics-based driving style indicators (e.g., harsh braking, cornering, idling)
Each of these speaks to a behavioural factor that influences crash risk and severity. Crucially, they are also areas where policy, training, technology, and leadership can have a direct influence.
This section explores how SPIs can support public sector organisations, partnerships, and private fleet operators in Scotland to monitor behaviour, shape policy, and deliver meaningful road safety outcomes. It also reflects on how these indicators are being aligned with the Road Safety Framework to 2030 and the Safe System approach, which puts human life and health at the core of transport decision-making.
What the Research Shows
A mature road safety culture within an organisation goes beyond compliance; it is a shared commitment to safety as a value. SPIs support this in several ways:
Promoting accountability and visibility
SPIs make the invisible visible. By tracking behaviours that lead to risk before incidents occur, managers can spot patterns and act. For example, an organisation monitoring seatbelt compliance among its fleet drivers may detect lower rates in certain departments. This insight creates a prompt for targeted engagement or training, rather than waiting for a serious incident to occur.
Fostering continuous improvement
In the same way that environmental indicators drive sustainability efforts, SPIs encourage incremental safety improvements. For instance, a community transport operator using telematics might set a target to reduce harsh braking events by 15% over a year. Achieving this requires ongoing analysis, feedback, and behavioural change, which are all hallmarks of a proactive culture.
Empowering leadership and engagement
When leaders use SPIs to guide decisions and communication, it sends a clear message: safety matters. For example, Police Scotland’s Road Safety & Operations unit regularly engages with road safety data to shape enforcement and education. Organisations can mirror this by embedding SPI discussions into team meetings, performance reviews, and annual reporting.
Aligning with Scottish and International Practice
Scotland’s Road Safety Framework to 2030 calls for a Safe System approach and identifies the need to “develop a suite of SPIs” as a priority. In 2021, Transport Scotland initiated work with partners to build a national SPI framework aligned with international standards (e.g. EU and UN recommendations). The intention is to create consistency while allowing local and organisational flexibility.
Figure 1 shows the SPIs in the Annual Delivery Plan, colour coded to show where in the Safe System the metrics focus. There are four SPIs which sit under Safe Road Use, but the Safe Speeds, and Safe Vehicles SPIs also have behavioural links.
There are some key elements that feature in all good SPIs. Firstly, they should be positively framed so that the goal is to reach 100% - 100% of drivers NOT distracted by a handheld mobile phone. Secondly, they should be directly linked to actions or risks which are known to increase crash risk. Thirdly, data sources used for monitoring SPIs should be able to be collected consistently over time and across different areas. Finally, it is really important to think about how the data collection methodology could influence the SPI outcome. For example, with illegal driving behaviours, it would seem to make sense to use enforcement data to monitor levels of compliance. The problem with this is that the levels of enforcement can influence the outcomes – more targeted enforcement could reduce the proportion of drivers monitored who were driving within the legal drink-drive limit because more drivers are stopped. Data sources not directly related to outcomes should be used.
.png?sv=2026-02-06&spr=https&st=2026-11-17T14%3A02%3A39Z&se=2026-11-17T14%3A17%3A39Z&sr=b&sp=r&sig=K5unYLu9mluNF8jlOdHujmjt81xrRnL8sL8Zm11xUSM%3D)
Figure 1 - Key Performance Indicators for Scotland's Road Safety Framework to 2030
Key areas of alignment include:
Behavioural monitoring: e.g., self-report and observational studies on mobile phone use or seatbelt wearing.
System-level indicators: e.g., road design compliance, safe vehicle use, and organisational road risk policies.
Technology integration: leveraging telematics, dashcams, and other digital tools to automate and improve data collection.
Scotland is also benefitting from research-led projects such as Project EDWARD and the Scottish Occupational Road Safety Alliance (ScORSA), which provide guidance and case studies on using SPIs within workplace settings.
In summary, SPIs are more than just performance metrics: they are catalysts for change. By tracking the behaviours that lead to harm, organisations across Scotland can influence their safety culture and support national ambitions to eliminate road deaths by 2050.
Whether you’re a service manager overseeing a mixed fleet; a policy advisor crafting transport strategy; or an analyst interpreting behavioural trends, SPIs provide a shared language for action. Their value lies not only in the numbers they produce, but in the conversations, decisions, and leadership they inspire.
Sources
Project EDWARD. (n.d.). Every Day Without A Road Death. Retrieved August 5, 2025, from https://projectedward.org/
Scottish Occupational Road Safety Alliance. (n.d.). ScORSA – Scottish Occupational Road Safety Alliance. Retrieved August 5, 2025, from https://www.scorsa.org.uk/
Transport Scotland. (2021). Scotland’s Road Safety Framework to 2030. Transport Scotland. https://www.transport.gov.scot/media/49893/scotlands-road-safety-framework-to-2030.pdf