Implications for Delivery
Make services more reliable, frequent, and timely to better meet people's everyday needs.
Improve safety and ease of access at stations and stops, especially for vulnerable users.
Combine ticketing and travel information across transport options to make journeys simpler.
Support new housing near public transport to encourage more people to use it.
Offer long-term, flexible funding to local authorities so they can plan and deliver better services.
Introduce policies that make car use less attractive, such as charging for workplace parking or driving in congested areas.
Background
Low levels of public transport use present a significant barrier to build safer road systems. When more people rely on private motor vehicles, the result is higher traffic volumes. This situation leads to more congestion, higher emissions, and more crashes. It also creates risks for pedestrians and cyclists and limits access to safe and affordable travel options.
Since the pandemic, public transport in the UK has faced new challenges. In many urban areas across the UK, public transport passenger numbers are still below pre-pandemic levels. In contrast, car use has returned to previous levels. Buses, in particular, have struggled to attract people back. A similar trend can be observed in Scotland as well. According to a report published by Transport Scotland in 2024, car traffic has shown a slight increase compared to 2020 figures. However, the volume of train and bus travel has remained below pre-pandemic levels.
A safe and effective transport strategy should prioritise modal shift from private cars to public transit. However, this shift is held back by various structural, operational, and behavioural barriers. These include unreliable schedules, poor connections, and limited access for rural areas.
Reducing car dependency supports Scotland’s goals for climate, access, and public wellbeing. Increasing public transport use — by addressing service quality and affordability — can reduce overall traffic volumes and help promote more inclusive, low-impact travel.
What the Research Shows
Across the UK, most people tend to see the car as more reliable, quicker and more flexible than the bus. Buses are perceived to underperform on these dimensions, especially outside urban centres. To encourage bus use, both practical barriers and negative perceptions must be addressed. People also value simple ticketing, environmental impact, and the ease of combining transport modes (DfT, 2023).
Public attitudes play a big role in transport choices. For example, national segmentation research has identified six key user groups, each with differing attitudes and barriers. Across all segments, the buses were perceived to underperform in three areas: reliability, journey time, and flexibility — core aspects that drive modal choice (DfT, 2023). A UK House of Lords report confirms that public transport often fails to meet these basic user needs. Disconnected services and limited access to real-time information make journeys harder and discourages people from switching modes (House of Lords, 2022).
Safety is another major concern. Many users, particularly women and older passengers say they avoid public transport due to fears about antisocial behaviour, poor lighting, and lack of staff presence at stations. Personal security and predictability are especially important for these groups. Well-lit stops, safe interchanges, and a sense of security are key to encouraging regular use.
Beyond these personal concerns, bigger structural problems also affect uptake. Services are often poorly connected; timetables are unreliable; and different modes of transport are not well integrated. Smaller local authorities also face challenges because they often have less funding and fewer resources for long-term planning (DfT, 2023; House of Lords, 2022).
Some key learnings from other cities
Compared to many European cities, the UK falls behind in public transport use. For example, in Lyon and Munich, 33% and 44% of workers respectively commute by public transport. In contrast, cities like Manchester and Birmingham hover around 16% (Rollison and Coombes, 2023). This is not just about geography—it reflects long-term investment in infrastructure, joined-up planning, and strong local governance.
Successful cities show that it is possible to boost ridership by increasing housing near transport hubs; integrating ticketing; improving reliability; and making car use less convenient through measures like congestion charges. London’s relative success is built on Transport for London’s integrated authority over bus, rail, and road networks —a governance model that empowers local delivery.
Sources
Department for Transport (2023) Increasing bus patronage through an audience strategy. Yonder Consulting
https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/increasing-bus-patronage-through-an-audience-strategy/increasing-bus-patronage-through-an-audience-strategy
House of Lords (2022) Public transport in towns and cities. HL Paper 89.
https://committees.parliament.uk/publications/31499/documents/176997/default/
Rollison & Coombes (2023) Gear Shift: International lessons for increasing public transport ridership in UK cities.
https://www.centreforcities.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/Gear-shift-November-2023.pdf
Transport Scotland (2024) Fair Fares Review: Supporting paper 1 – Public transport system analysis.
https://www.transport.gov.scot/publication/public-transport-system-analysis-supporting-paper-one-fair-fares-review/