Behaviour Change Wheel

Prev Next
This content is currently unavailable in English (UK). You are viewing the default (English) version.

Implications for Delivery

Designing behaviour change interventions can be complex, but using behaviour change frameworks can support the development of evidence-based strategies.

This section introduces the Behaviour Change Wheel (BCW), developed by Michie et al., (2011) , as one such framework. However, it’s important to note that there are many other useful theories outlined in ‘The ABC of Behaviour Change Theories’ (Michie, West, et al., 2014).

Using a behaviour change theory does not guarantee successful outcomes or replace the need for evaluation. Every intervention should be evaluated to understand what works, what does not, and under what conditions.

The starting point for any behaviour change intervention is to perform a ‘behavioural diagnosis’ by answering these questions:

  • What specific behaviour(s) are you trying to change?

  • Where does the behaviour (s) take place? What is the context?

  • Who is the target group (s) for this behaviour (s)?

  • How often should the behaviour (s) occur?

  • What are the enablers and barriers to the behaviour (s)?

  • How does the behaviour (s) need to change to achieve your desired outcome?

  • Are there any wider systemic influences affecting the behaviour (s)?

Once you have addressed these questions, choose a behaviour change theory that best fits your context. Regardless of the theory selected, it is essential to include Behaviour Change Techniques (BCTs) in your intervention design. BCTs are the ‘active ingredients’ of an intervention. These include mechanisms such as providing feedback, offering social support, or setting goals that directly contribute to behaviour change. To learn more about BCT coding and how to apply it in practice, a free course is available through the Behaviour Change Taxonomy Project.

Background

Human behaviour is shaped by a range of factors, including beliefs, values, social norms, and broader systemic influences. This complexity can make it challenging to design effective behaviour change interventions.  

Road safety practitioners often rely on a well–known toolkit including the “3Es” — education, engineering, and enforcement — a framework first introduced by (Damon, 1958). Despite advances in our understanding of behaviour, these approaches continue to dominate (Campsall & Khatri, 2024).

Behaviour change frameworks offer more systematic, evidence-based ways to design and implement interventions. One such framework is the Behaviour Change Wheel, developed by Michie et al., (2011). This model helps simplify the complexity of behaviour by providing a structured and evidence-based approach to intervention design. At its heart is a behaviour change model which has become more popular in road safety in recent years: the COM-B model, which explores capability, opportunity, and motivation as influences on behaviour.

Ideally, every intervention should be guided by an appropriate behaviour change theory. Yet, Fosdick (2019)  found that only 32% of respondents from 78 road safety organisations reported using behaviour change theories in their work. Using a behaviour change theory can help in:

  1. Grounding your work in evidence-based methods.

  2. Managing the complexity of multiple behavioural influences.

It is important to dispel a common myth: using a theory removes the requirement for evaluation. Whether or not a theory is used, interventions should always be assessed to understand what works, what does not work, to what context, and in what context. Before selecting a theory or designing an intervention, it is important to clearly define the problem in behavioural terms. Consider the following questions:

  • What specific behaviour(s) are you aiming to change?

  • Where and in what context does the behaviour(s) occur?

  • Who is the target group(s)?

  • How often should the behaviour(s) take place?

  • What are the key barriers and enablers for the behaviour(s) to occur?

  • How does the behaviour(s) need to shift to achieve the desired outcome?

  • Are there any broader systemic influences affecting the behaviour(s)?

By carefully defining the problem and using behaviour change theories as tools (not shortcuts), we can design interventions that are more likely to support a Safe System and lead to sustained improvements in road safety.

What the Research Shows

The innermost layer of the Behaviour Change Wheel (BCW) comprises of the ‘sources of behaviour’ (Michie et al., 2011) with three distinct elements outlined as Capability (C), Opportunity (O) and Motivation (M) (Figure 1), known as COM-B. Capability refers to the physical or psychological capability of performing a behaviour. For example, a lack of physical capability would include not having the physical dexterity to balance on a bicycle. Not having the psychological capability might mean that the person doesn’t know how to ride a bicycle safely.

Opportunity refers to the physical or social opportunity to perform a behaviour. Thinking about our cyclists, it might be that no-one in a friendship group of young people choose to wear a cycling helmet when riding. This could influence the social opportunity of a young cyclist who wanted to use a helmet. The physical environment can influence opportunities: installing segregated cycle lanes will limit how closely motorised vehicles could get to cyclists.  

Motivation also has two influences: automatic and reflective. Automatic motivation could be a reflex action or it could be based on wants and beliefs. This could include habits, so thinking about our cyclist, it could be that they always take a certain route by habit, even though there could be a safer, easier, or faster alternative.

Reflective motivation involves conscious decision-making and reasoning. For example, someone might believe they want to be fit, but they only feel motivated to act after some reflection. As a result, they might decide to start cycling to work.

Figure 1: COM - 8 model by (Michie et al., 2011)

As evident in the earlier examples, the Capability, Opportunity, and Motivation (COM) elements can combine in different ways to influence whether a behaviour occurs. For instance, someone might initially lack both the motivation and the capability to perform a behaviour. However, after some reflection, they may find the motivation to act, gradually building the necessary capability, and eventually carrying out the desired behaviour.

It means that it is important to understand what the influences on behaviour are, before you can start to deliver interventions. There is no point devising an educational campaign to improve knowledge when psychological capability is already high, but someone is lacking the physical environment to be able to perform the behaviour. (Thinking about our cyclists, most people know that cycling will make them fitter, but they may live in a really hilly area with high-speed roads and so it doesn’t feel like an environment that they want to learn to cycle on). Therefore, there is some research to be done at this stage to understand what the influences on behaviour are.

At this point, you may find there are several behaviours that need to change to fully support your target outcome. Michie, Atkins, et al., (2014) recommend starting small in their detailed book on applying the BCW. Instead of trying to change too many behaviours at once, focus on a few key ones, observe the impact, and then adjust or expand your efforts based on that.

The COM - B model sits at the centre of two surrounding layers, forming the complete BCW (see Figure 2). While the COM - B model is considered the source of behaviour, the red ring around it represents nine 'intervention functions'. These represent mechanisms through which behaviour change can occur. See Table 1 for a full explanation of these functions.

Table 1: Explanation of intervention functions adapted from (Michie, Atkins, et al., 2014)

Intervening Function

Explanation

Education

Providing knowledge to increase understanding of how to perform a behaviour.

Example: Proving information on how to properly fasten a child seat in a car.

Persuasion

Using communication strategies to encourage people to adopt a behaviour or avoid an undesirable one.  

Example: Communication campaigns to persuade motorcycle riders to ride at safer speeds.  

Incentivisation

Offering rewards or creating the expectation of a reward to encourage behaviour change.  

Example: Giving a reward for completing a survey on workplace behaviour.

Coercion

Using punishment or expectation of punishment to discourage undesired behaviour. The undesired behaviour could also entail a cost for the individual.  

Example: Fining drivers who exceed the speed limit.

Training

While in the sector, training and education can often be synonymous, the BCW considers these as two separate intervention functions with training largely pertaining to skill development.  

Example: Teaching children how to cross a road safely.

Restriction

Increasing or reducing barriers for performing the desired behaviour.  

Example: Not allowing alcohol sales after 10 pm in Scotland to reduce drink driving or similar behaviours.

Environmental Restructuring

Changing the physical or social environment to enable behaviour change.

Example: Designing the road network with frequent rest areas so drivers can take regular breaks.

Modelling

Demonstrating the desired behaviour through role models or influential figures.

Example: A celebrity or peer group leader performing the desired behaviour, encouraging others to do the same

Enablement

Providing support or removing barriers (beyond education, training, or restructuring environment) to help people perform a behaviour.

Example: Offering social support from peers to help someone adopt a new habit.

Table 2 - Matrix of links between COM-B and intervention functions adapted from (Michie, Atkins, et al., 2014)

Intervention Functions

COM-B Components

Education

Persuasion

Incentivisation

Coercion

Training

Restriction

Environment

Modelling

Enabling

Physical capability

Psychological capability

Physical opportunity

Social opportunity

Automatic motivation

Reflective motivation

Finally, the outermost circle comprises of seven policy categories that can be targeted:

  1. Communication/ marketing: Using communication campaigns through various mediums to enable behaviour change.

  2. Guidelines: Creating documents that provide some guidelines for performing a behaviour such as a manual.

  3. Fiscal measures: Influencing behaviour by changing costs, such as through taxes, subsidies, or financial incentives.

  4. Regulation: Introducing regulations or agreements for supporting the behaviour. These can be voluntary agreements, not necessarily legally binding.

  5. Legislation: Creating laws for enabling behaviour change.

  6. Environment/ social planning: Designing physical or social environment in ways that make it easier for people to adopt the desired behaviour.

  7. Service provision: Offering services that help enable behaviour change such as support programmes.

As with the COM-B components and their relationships with different intervention functions, not all policy categories can be used to deliver all intervention functions. It means that it is important to follow the process through, in an evidence-led manner, to understand what tools are best to change the target behaviour.

Table 3 - Matrix of links between intervention functions and policy categories adapted from (Michie, Atkins, et al., 2014)

Intervention Functions

Policy Categories

Education

Persuasion

Incentivisation

Coercion

Training

Restriction

Environmental Restructuring

Modelling

Enablement

Communications/ marketing

Guidelines

Fiscal measures

Regulation

Legislation

Environmental/ social planning

Service provision

Whilst this might all sound a little complicated, the Behaviour Change Wheel is designed as a process, prompting you with questions at each stage of your discovery to understand the behaviour and design an appropriate intervention.

One of the essential final elements to consider when designing an intervention is the use of Behaviour Change Techniques (BCT) - these are considered the ‘active ingredients’ of an intervention (Michie et al., 2015). These are key mechanisms through which behaviour occurs. When we think about medicine, there are a number of questions the medical profession asks before prescribing a pill. We could ask the same questions of a behaviour change intervention?

  • What ingredients make it work?

  • Does it work the same for everyone?

  • What is the recommended dose?

  • Are there any potential side effects?

Some examples of BCTs are goal setting (behaviour/ outcome); action planning; and self–monitoring of behaviour. Your intervention could, and should, include more than one BCT. By identifying the BCTs in an intervention, it makes it easier to evaluate as you are clear on what you are measuring. It also makes the intervention more replicable as someone else can repeat it, knowing all of the elements it needs to contain in order to work. Finally, by working through the list of BCTs and identifying which ones you have used, it could inspire ideas of BCTs which you might not have previously considered. As we all behave differently as human beings, using a mixture of BCTs in one intervention increases the chances of it being successful for a wider slice of the population.

You can learn more about BCT coding by doing a free course developed as part of the Behaviour Change Taxonomy Project. There are a total of 93 BCTs as per the BCT taxonomy V1.

BCT coding has also been explained and adapted to the road safety sector with a variety of examples in an influential report by  Fylan, (2017). In addition to this, Sullman, (2017) has looked specifically at the BCTs which might be most appropriate for young driver interventions.

Sources

Damon, N. (1958). The Action Program for Highway Safety. The ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, 320(1), 15–26.
https://doi.org/10.1177/000271625832000104

Fosdick, T. (2019). Effectiveness of UK Road Safety Behaviour Change Interventions. RAC Foundation.
https://www.racfoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/Effectiveness_of_UK_Road_Safety_Interventions_Fosdick_November_2019.pdf

Fylan, D. F. (2017). Using Behaviour Change Techniques: Guidance for the road safety community. RAC Foundation. Using_behaviour_change_techniques_Guidance_for_the_road_safety_community.pdf

Michie, S., Atkins, L., & West, R. (2014). The Behaviour Change Wheel: A Guide to Designing Interventions. Silverback Publishing.
https://www.behaviourchangewheel.com/

Michie, S., van Stralen, M. M., & West, R. (2011). The behaviour change wheel: A new method for characterising and designing behaviour change interventions. Implementation Science, 6(1), 42. https://doi.org/10.1186/1748-5908-6-42

Michie, S., West, R., Campbell, R., Brown, J., & Gainforth, H. (2014). ABC of Behaviour Change Theories Book—An Essential Resource for Researchers, Policy Makers and Practitioners. Silverback Publishing. https://www.behaviourchangetheories.com/online-book#1

Michie, S., Wood, C. E., Johnston, M., Abraham, C., Francis, J. J., & Hardeman, W. (2015). Chapter 1 General Introduction. In Behaviour change techniques: The development and evaluation of a taxonomic method for reporting and describing behaviour change interventions (a suite of five studies involving consensus methods, randomised controlled trials and analysis of qualitative data): Vol. Health Technology Assessment (No. 19.99). NIHR Journals Library. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK327617/

Sullman, M. (2017). Young Driver Safety: A review of behaviour change techniques for future interventions. RAC Foundation.
https://www.racfoundation.org/assets/rac_foundation/content/downloadables/Young_driver_safety_a_review_of_behaviour_change_techniques_for_future_interventions_MSullman_March_2017.pdf