Progressive Licensing

Prev Next
This content is currently unavailable in English (UK). You are viewing the default (English) version.

Implications for Delivery

Introducing or supporting a progressive licensing system requires collaborative support and a clear understanding of its practical implications. While legislative change is outside the remit of many road safety authorities, there are still important roles we can play in supporting potential delivery.

Some key considerations include:

  • Partnership working: Coordinated efforts with national and regional stakeholders such as Transport Scotland, Road Safety Scotland, SCOTS, PACTS and local authorities can help build a shared case for change and ensure alignment with existing policy goals.

  • Public and stakeholder engagement: Early dialogue with young people, parents, educators, employers, and rural communities can help surface local concerns and identify where exemptions or mitigations might be needed. In addition to this, garnering local support can help in building a strong case.

  • Framing the case: Emphasising the safety and social equity benefits of progressive licensing, not just the restrictions, can make it easier to build wider public and political support. Highlighting the cost-benefit analysis and success stories from other countries helps ground advocacy in evidence. Read Helman et al., (2022) to develop evidence-based arguments to address some common concerns.

In summary, while legislative change may be complex, there are many steps that Scottish authorities can take to advocate for progressive licensing.

Background

The risk factors associated with young drivers are well-established. One in five people killed or seriously injured (KSI) in collisions involving cars were involved in a crash with a young driver (Department for Transport, 2024). In addition, young male drivers (17-24 years) are four times more likely to be killed or seriously injured than drivers aged 25 or over (Department for Transport, 2024).

Young drivers are a key focus group due to a combination of youth and inexperience (Helman et al., 2022). Young drivers and novice drivers are often used interchangeably in the progressive licensing context. While progressive licensing can benefit all novice drivers, most new drivers tend to be young (Helman et al., 2022). Several age-related factors increase this age group’s risk on the road, including being more influenced by peers, and socialising at night (Kinnear et al., 2014).

To help reduce these risks, many countries have introduced progressive licensing systems, also known as Graduated Driver Licensing (GDL). These systems introduce driving in phases, often including additional requirements or temporary restrictions during the early stages of driving. These may include limits on night-time driving, peer passengers above a certain age, or other risk-related conditions. Importantly, these systems are designed to support safer learning, giving new drivers the opportunity to build experience gradually in lower-risk environments.

There is no one-size-fits-all model for progressive licensing. Different countries have adapted their systems based on local needs, evidence, and road safety goals. Some countries that have implemented progressive licensing systems include Australia, New Zealand, United States, and Canada (Masten et al., 2013).

Introducing or adapting progressive licensing is about finding the right balance, protecting young drivers and other road users while supporting the safe development of driving skills. When well-designed, these systems can be an important part of our wider effort to achieve the world’s safest roads by 2030.

What the Research Shows

Young drivers face several well-documented risk factors that increase their chances of being involved in serious collisions (Pressley et al., 2017). These include:

  • Crash rates are higher for younger drivers but decline with age and experience.

  • Night-time driving is associated with a higher risk of collisions.

  • Driving with peers in the car can increase the likelihood of risky driving.

  • Other common risk factors include alcohol use, speeding, and mobile phone use.

One approach to reduce these risks is the use of progressive licensing systems. A study by Kinnear et al., (2014) estimated that a GDL system in Great Britain could prevent 4,478 casualties, including 433 people who would have been killed or seriously injured, based on STATS-19 data from 2008 to 2012.  Kinnear et al., (2014) also provided region-specific estimates for the potential economic benefits of a progressive licensing system in Scotland (2008-2012):

  • Lothian & Borders and Dumfries & Galloway: £3.6 million

  • Northern and Grampian: £4.9 million

  • Strathclyde: £6.2 million

  • Tayside, Fife and Central: £3.6 million

These figures help make the case not just from a safety perspective, but also a financial and organisational impact standpoint when advocating for change across regions.

Addressing common concerns

Advocating for legislative change can be challenging, especially at the local level. However, evidence-based responses to common concerns can help build support. Helman et al., (2022)  provide useful insights on this:

  • Access to education and employment: There is a concern that progressive licensing could limit access to education and employment, especially in rural areas. However, most affected journeys tend to be social (Helman et al., 2022). Other countries have included exemptions for education or work where needed; a similar approach can be adopted. Additionally, individuals adapt to new systems once implemented.

  • Enforcement challenges: There is often a concern that progressive licensing systems can be difficult to enforce. Helman et al., (2022) found that in countries where progressive licensing has been implemented, parents and guardians often take a leading role in ensuring compliance.

  • Youth support: While young drivers may see progressive licensing systems as inconvenient, Helman et al., (2022) found that participants were willing to adapt to restrictions.

  • Telematics technology as an alternative: Although telematics shows promise, there is insufficient evidence to confirm whether it improves safety outcomes for young drivers.

  • Progressive licensing will not work in the UK: The fact that the UK has relatively safer roads compared to other countries does not mean that progressive licensing will not work. There is no evidence that it would be ineffective in this context.

When looking to advocate for a legislative change, consider collaborating with some authorities such as:

  • Transport Scotland

  • Road Safety Scotland

  • Society of Chief Officers of Transportation in Scotland (SCOTS)

  • Parliamentary Advisory Council for Transport Safety (PACTS)

  • RoadPeace

  • Forget-me-not Families Uniting

  • Convention of Scottish Local Authorities (CoSLA)

Working together, these organisations can help develop an approach that fits the Scottish context and advocate for progressive licensing across Great Britain.

Sources

Department for Transport. (2024). Reported road casualties in Great Britain: Younger driver factsheet, 2023 [Accredited official statistics]. Department for Transport.
https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/reported-road-casualties-great-britain-older-and-younger-driver-factsheets-2023/reported-road-casualties-in-great-britain-younger-driver-factsheet-2023

Helman, D. S., Kinnear, D. N., Hitchings, J., & Jones, D. S. (2022). Supporting New Drivers in Great Britain. RAC Foundation.
https://www.racfoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/Supporting_new_drivers_in_GB_Helman_et_al_Oct_2022.pdf

Kinnear, D. N., Llyod, L., Scoons, J., & Helman, D. S. (2014). Graduated Driver Licensing (A Regional Analysis of Potential Casualty Savings in Great Britain). RAC Foundation.
https://www.racfoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/11/graduated_driver_licensing_regional_analysis_trl_270514.pdf

Masten, S. V., Foss, R. D., & Marshall, S. W. (2013). Graduated driver licensing program component calibrations and their association with fatal crash involvement. Accident Analysis & Prevention, 57, 105–113.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aap.2013.04.013

Pressley, A., Fernandez-Medina, K., Helman, S., McKenna, F. P., Stradling, S., & Husband, P. (2017). A review of interventions which seek to increase the safety of young and novice drivers (No. PPR 781).
https://trid.trb.org/View/1485093