Implications for Delivery
The effectiveness of road safety campaigns is complex and often questioned. Critics argue that these sort of ‘education interventions’ are frequently designed without sufficient theoretical basis, potentially leading to ineffectiveness and even increasing exposure to risk.
Attempts to increase knowledge often fails to translate into actual behaviour change or reduce serious outcomes like death and injury, but this doesn’t mean that there is no place for effective, coordinated use of PR activity to support Safe System goals:
Beware – some road safety professionals will talk about the value of ‘education’ by which they mean a wide range of types of behavioural intervention. It is important to understand what behaviour you are trying to address or whether you are seeking to change attitudes regarding road safety interventions.
Be clear - being clear on what you are trying to achieve will help you to select appropriate models of behaviour or a theory of change for your campaign. In turn, this will help you to design a more effective evaluation. Build your campaign around your audience, a compelling narrative and targeted messaging that will reach them.
Be evidence-based – ensure that you have drawn on a range of evidence to help design your campaign. Road users can be more receptive to messages at times when they are engaged with these behaviours, and warnings about enforcement can strengthen the impact of the enforcement activity.
Be critical – whether in testing your messaging before launch or evaluating your intervention once delivery has started, ensure that you are measuring how effective this campaign is at achieving the objectives you set.
Background
Communications, encompassing education, campaigns and PR activity, have historically been a major focus in efforts to improve road safety, driven by the belief that addressing user behaviour is key. They are often seen as a plausible, politically uncontroversial means for authorities to address public concerns, without the requirement for additional regulation or huge investments in infrastructure. The purpose of these communications is to inform, persuade, and motivate the population to change attitudes and behaviours to enhance road safety.
Across Scotland, there is a strong heritage of working effectively with the media, supporting messages about the importance of road safety alongside broader campaigning or in response to major incidents.
The main focus of public relations is designed to shape public perceptions, change attitudes, and promote safer behaviour. Rather than merely informing, PR in road safety aims to:
Influence cultural norms – Competing voices in the media can create the impression that public opinion is either clearly in favour of or vehemently opposed to certain road safety policies. Effective PR campaigns can help to rebalance the reporting of opinions as well as communicating normal expectations for road user behaviour.
Build emotional engagement – In their daily lives, many people might not give much consideration to road safety issues or think about how safety could be improved. PR campaigns can help to ‘cut through’ with messages that connect with the audience and get them to think more deeply about the importance of road safety.
Generate public and political support – To be effective, any interventions will be best delivered with a high degree of support. Explaining the rationale for any new measures and the anticipated benefit that people will get from their implementation is an important aspect of delivery.
What the Research Shows
Evidence suggests that road safety campaigns can indeed have a positive impact. A meta-analysis of 67 studies evaluating the effect of road safety campaigns on crashes found a 9% reduction in collisions. This reduction can be even greater when campaigns involve well-directed personalised communication or roadside media focussed on specific driving behaviours. Campaigns with shorter durations (less than one month) and accompanied by enforcement activities also show beneficial associations with fewer crashes.
Some key points to consider in developing effective PR campaigns:
Purpose – practitioners should be realistic about what the campaign is trying to achieve. Some studies indicate that using campaigns to change behaviour are likely to have limited effect, however, they can be highly effective at raising the importance of road safety or improving public acceptance of other measures.
Narrative – what is the story that you are trying to tell? As humans we connect with storytelling and campaigns that draw us into a story which engages us can be highly effective. Stories may be positively framed or explore negative consequences, they can be constructed around the impact of road traffic on a person or community, but they must be relatable, something which the audience can connect with.
Testing – Even as professionals, what we think makes a compelling campaign can fail to land with our selected audience. We may use the wrong language or cultural cues, they might find our approach too cheesy or technical. It is therefore sensible to test your messaging on the target audience, ensuring that it communicates effectively.
Evidence – for the campaign to be authoritative and compelling, there will need to be a robust evidence base to underpin it. Whilst your audience might find the narrative highly compelling, the campaign will stand up to scrutiny based on its alignment to good quality evidence.
Data – whilst many people struggle to digest data unless it has been simplified and presented clearly, for some the data will help to make your message more concrete. Data should be carefully chosen, presented clearly and explained well so as not to undermine the overall message. Consider making full access available to any data tables or analytical methodology, this transparency can reduce challenges to stats having been ‘cherrypicked’ to help the story.
Localisation – many media outlets are looking for a message that will resonate with their audience or local community. Data broken down by smaller geographic areas might help here, or finding ways to communicate the relevance of the story to these particular localities.
Media Channels – sharing your message with a large audience used to be quite straightforward when we had a limited number of television channels, radio stations or newspapers. The highly fragmented media landscape requires much more consideration about which audiences to target and, therefore, which media channels would be the best to prioritise. Specialist PR planning agencies might be the best way to develop your approach.
Social Media – in addition to traditional media, the digital landscape of social media channels increases both choice and complexity. Paid for promotion on social media channels can be a highly focussed way of getting your message out, but choosing the most appropriate platforms will require care. The average UK adult uses more than 6 different platforms and they will likely consume different sorts of information on each.
Evaluate – any attempt to bring about change should include an attempt to measure whether you have been successful, but this also requires a good understanding of what you might reasonably be able to measure. You will almost certainly not be able to measure the effect of a PR campaign on the number of crashes, the causal link is generally too tenuous to stand up to any serious scrutiny, but that doesn’t mean you cannot have robust measurement. Questions about attitudes, self-reported behaviour, the perceived norms of others, acceptance of policies or new technology can all demonstrate meaningful outcomes from your campaign.
Sources
McKenna, F. (2010). Education in road safety: Are we getting it right? (Report No. 10/1130). RAC Foundation. https://www.racfoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/11/education-in-road-safety-mckenna-080910-report.pdf
Phillips, R. O., Ulleberg, P., & Vaa, T. (2011). Meta-analysis of the effect of road safety campaigns on accidents. Accident Analysis & Prevention, 43(3), 1204-1218. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aap.2011.01.002
We Are Social. (2025). Digital 2025. https://wearesocial.com/uk/blog/2025/02/digital-2025/