Immersive Environments (VR)

Prev Next
This content is currently unavailable in English (UK). You are viewing the default (English) version.

Implications for Delivery

There are multiple implications for how VR can be applied to improve road safety outcomes:

  • School and Community Engagement: VR road safety headsets (already used in several Scottish local authority areas) offer a powerful alternative to traditional talks or videos. Scenarios can include urban driving, pedestrian near-misses, or rural road risks, tailored to local contexts and issues. Combined with facilitated debriefing, these tools promote personal reflection and open discussion, especially among young people.

  • Behavioural Interventions for Repeat Offenders: Simulation can be used with individuals attending driver behaviour courses or following fixed penalty enforcement. Police and safety teams can reinforce learning by showing real-world consequences and prompting empathy (e.g., for victims of dangerous driving).

  • Training for Emergency Response Staff: Fire and rescue personnel responding to road collisions can benefit from VR-based training in incident scene management, risk assessment, or vehicle extrication under evolving conditions. Police forces can train for pursuit management, collision investigation, or public engagement scenarios using simulation to build muscle memory and critical thinking.

While immersive environments offer real promise, some practical and ethical factors must be addressed:

  • Cost and access: VR kits and simulators can be expensive, but shared regional resources or mobile delivery units can improve access.

  • Facilitation: These tools are most effective when paired with trained facilitators who can guide reflection, address emotions, and link scenarios to real-world consequences.

  • Simulator/VR sickness: Some people can develop adverse effects such as disorientation, nausea and loss of balance when using simulators or VR headsets, similar to motion sickness. Equipment will also be provided with a minimum age for its use.

  • Emotional trauma: The immersive nature of VR and similar interventions will increase the risks of emotional trauma if the content is of a traumatic nature. There is evidence fear-based interventions don’t work well anyway, which is discussed in our ‘What works…’ section.

  • Evaluation: Monitoring behavioural outcomes, not just satisfaction, is essential. Partnerships with academics or analysts can help measure long-term impact.

Background

In Scotland’s journey toward Vision Zero, the effectiveness of training and testing approaches is critical. There is an increasing need to move beyond traditional classroom or on-road instruction. Instead, immersive environments, particularly virtual reality (VR), simulation, and other interactive digital tools, offer new ways to engage, educate, and influence road user behaviour, especially among high-risk and novice groups. This section explores the growing use of immersive technology in road safety, drawing on leading evidence to highlight practical applications for frontline professionals and public safety campaigns in Scotland.

What the Research Shows

Immersive environments place individuals in realistic, high-risk scenarios without exposing them to actual danger. These tools help participants:

  • Experience the consequences of risky driving (e.g., distraction, speeding, impaired driving)

  • Practice decision-making in complex, emotionally charged environments

  • Retain information more effectively through experiential learning

For emergency services and road safety teams, immersive tools can be used in community engagement, schools’ education, driver training, and behaviour change campaigns, especially where standard materials fail to connect with high-risk audiences.

In a study by Kinnear et al. (2013), interventions aimed at novice drivers were evaluated. A key insight was that knowledge-based pre-driver education alone is not sufficient to reduce crash risk. Instead, they argue that effective training must target attitudes, motivations, and behavioural tendencies, particularly around overconfidence and sensation-seeking. This finding aligns with the benefits of immersive environments, which can simulate hazardous scenarios in a way that challenges perceptions of risk and fosters emotional engagement. Importantly, immersive tools allow individuals to "fail safely" and reflect on their decisions in real-time, which is an essential element in building safer driving habits before poor behaviours become ingrained.

In another study by Cutello et al. (2020), a VR-based intervention to reduce risky driving behaviours among young drivers was assessed. Their findings showed that VR increased emotional engagement and led to reduced acceptance of risky behaviours, such as speeding or phone use while driving. The study found that participants responded positively when the VR experience was realistic but not overwhelming. In fact, many participants reported that they felt more aware and more in control, suggesting that immersive experiences can build confidence as well as caution.

These insights are highly relevant for police and fire officers involved in school education or youth engagement, especially when working with young drivers or those most at risk. For government communications and road safety teams, immersive tools can strengthen public messaging and amplify campaign impact. For instance:

  • VR clips or 360-degree video can be used on social media platforms to increase reach and engagement, especially among younger, high-risk audiences.

  • Campaigns that include immersive components (e.g. during Road Safety Week or school leaver events) offer a memorable experience that can be promoted across local and national networks.

  • Partnering with police and fire services in joint events can increase credibility and coverage.

Immersive environments offer a powerful way to connect road safety messages with real emotion and real decision-making. For police officers, fire officers, road safety professionals, and communications teams, these tools represent more than a technical innovation. Instead, they are an opportunity to shift how people feel about risk, not just what they know. However, it is important the content and messaging used in immersive environments is developed using good Principles of Intervention Design.

As Scotland works to embed the Safe System approach, immersive training can play a central role in equipping both the public and professionals with the mindset, awareness, and confidence to prevent harm before it happens. By combining evidence-based practice with creative engagement, immersive tools can help ensure that road safety messages are not just delivered, but truly experienced.

Sources

Cutello, C.A., Gummerum, M., Hanoch, Y., Hellier, E. (2020). Evaluating an Intervention to Reduce Risky Driving Behaviors: Taking the Fear Out of Virtual Reality. Risk Analysis, 41 (9), 1662-1673. https://doi.org/10.1111/risa.13643

Kinnear, N., Lloyd, S., Helman, L., Husband, P., Scoons, J., Jones, S., & Broughton, J. (2013). Novice drivers: Evidence Review and Evaluation Pre-driver training, Graduated Driver Licensing. TRL