Implications for Delivery
Targets are proven to support road casualty reduction. Their selection and use require careful consideration. Practitioners need to:
Embed targets as part of the transport vision and strategy
Make sure you set SMART targets that relate to road safety outcomes and include indicators if possible
Support longer term targets with interim or intermediate targets
Have a clear plan for monitoring targets: How can you measure success and what data do you need?
Ensure targets have stakeholder buy-in across the road safety partnership and are supported by an achievable action plan
Background
Targets are a crucial part of performance management. They demonstrate commitment from key stakeholders, promote accountability and keep the focus on delivering outcomes.
The Safe System states that death and serious injury are not acceptable. As such, Scotland has an ambition for zero fatalities and serious injuries by 2050. Scotland also has ambitious interim targets to 2030, including a 50% reduction in fatalities. These interim targets are further supported by intermediate outcome targets.
Targets should be monitored regularly by organisational leaders such as directors and service managers. Whilst important, targets alone do not guarantee progress and should be supported by a clear vision and implementation strategy.
What the Research Shows
The importance of targets
The ultimate goal of the Safe System is zero fatal and serious injuries on the road network. Setting challenging but achievable targets towards this goal is recognised as international best practice by the OECD and other international organisations. There is significant evidence that countries with targets perform better than those without them.
There are many reasons for setting targets. For example, targets provide:
Increased political will
Stakeholder accountability
Focus for strategies and programmes, leading to better use of public funds
Impetus and motivation to deliver action
Setting targets
Road safety targets can be decided in several ways. Target setting can be ‘top-down’ or ‘bottom-up’. Top-down targets typically form part of a wider vision. For example, the UN second decade of action for road safety 2021-2030 aims to reduce global deaths and serious injuries by 50% by 2030. Bottom-up targets are derived empirically. This could be based on interventions and capacity to deliver them. Best practice involves a combination of the two approaches, with a longer-term goal supported by interim or intermediate targets.
Targets represent the progress a jurisdiction wants to achieve over a given time frame. They need to be SMART:
Specific – typically quantitative
Measurable – so that you can track progress and see whether the goal has been achieved
Achievable – considering resources and capability
Relevant – aligned with any wider vision and strategy
Time-bound – for example ‘by 2040’
Targets should be set related to ultimate road safety outcomes. For example, a target of zero fatalities and serious injuries might be accompanied by a target to reduce these by 50% in a shorter time frame.
These targets could be for all road users or individual groups or locations. A combination of targets can help to focus action on key areas aligned with the wider transport strategy.
Targets relating to safety performance indicators should also be implemented where feasible. These aim to reduce risk on the network and target the causal factors relating to collisions. They can be tracked more frequently and support proactive intervention, accelerating progress towards casualty targets.
Monitoring targets
Targets should be monitored to assess progress being made. Beyond just monitoring progress in the numbers, understanding what has worked and what hasn’t is crucial. This allows for redirection of funds or resources towards things that are working well or need more attention. It also informs the need to adjust any targets based on factors not previously considered.
A clear plan for monitoring targets should consider the following:
Monitoring targets requires good data relating to the outcomes and indicators being measured
Monitoring should be frequent enough that corrective action can be applied
When evaluating what has or hasn’t worked, a robust evaluation approach should be used
Challenges with targets
There are several pitfalls to consider when setting targets:
Targets should be supported by a realistic and evidence-based action plan to achieve them. A target on its own can be purely symbolic.
Targets need to balance being achievable and challenging. If too challenging, the target can be easily ignored as an unrealistic aspiration. If too easy to achieve, potential progress will be missed.
Targets need to have buy-in from across the road safety partnership. This includes having appropriate funding to deliver interventions and accountability for producing results.
Sources
Elvik, R. (2007). Prospects for improving road safety in Norway (TØI report 897/2007). Institute of Transport Economics (TØI). https://www.toi.no/getfile.php?mmfileid=9040
European Commission, Directorate-General for Mobility and Transport. (2018). Quantitative road safety targets. European Road Safety Observatory. https://road-safety.transport.ec.europa.eu/system/files/2021-07/ersosynthesis2018-quantitativetargets.pdf
International Transport Forum, & OECD. (2008). Towards Zero: Ambitious road safety targets and the Safe System approach—Executive summary. OECD/ITF. https://www.itf-oecd.org/sites/default/files/docs/08targetssummary.pdf
Parliamentary Advisory Council for Transport Safety (PACTS). (2010). Road safety performance beyond 2010. https://www.pacts.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/docs/pdf-bank/POLICY%20BRIEFING%20-%20Road%20Safety%20Performance%20Beyond%202010%20v3.pdf
World Road Association (PIARC). (2025). Road safety targets, investment strategies, plans and projects. In Road safety manual: A guide for practitioners. https://roadsafety.piarc.org/en/road-safety-management/6-target-and-strategic-plans