Implications for Delivery
Getting road safety included as part of the Value Chain depends on three key things:
Engaging with management to illustrate the benefits to their organisation of road safety in terms of both reputation and business effectiveness
Encouraging a longer term, more collaborative approach to working with supply chain
Establishing achievable but stretching standards, ideally developed in partnership with suppliers
The first step is for public sector organisations to review their own arrangements for managing work related road safety, put in place effective controls, and then to look at the whole supply chain to work out what level of control or influence they have over each organisation. The next step is to work together with supply chain to help them to see the enhanced value in implementing higher road safety standards.
Background
The value chain is a model developed by economist Michael Porter that helps to identify competitive advantages in business strategies. Put simply, it’s the activities that add value to a product or service, giving an organisation a competitive advantage over its rivals. That can include using road safety as a unique selling point (USP) as well as for operational effectiveness.
Organisations have a range of ways in which they can influence road safety:
Directly – Internal. The standards and policies which an organisation can apply within their own organisation, over which they have full control.
Directly – Contractors. Specific standards and policies which an organisation can require of a contractor undertaking work on their behalf, over which they have significant control, and can audit compliance against a contractual requirement.
Indirectly – Suppliers. The general standards and policies (or equivalents) which an organisation can specify during procurement as being required to do business with them
Indirectly – Sphere of Influence. The way in which setting a good example leverages influence on partners up, down and across the supply chain to clients/customers, contractors/sub contractors and competitors.
The recommendations of the Academic Expert Group for the 3rd Global Ministerial Conference on Road Safety state:
“Corporations from every sector and public authorities with a wide range of direct responsibilities can be engaged in road safety activities. These organizations will be motivated to look beyond their core tasks for efficient and effective strategies to contribute to the SDGs. If these organizations are educated concerning the need and opportunities, road safety actions could be a widespread priority.
The means for contributing to road safety by these new partners could include policies regarding vehicle fleet purchase and the manner in which these vehicles are scheduled, routed and driven. In addition, these organizations can use their contractual and procurement power to affect road safety policies and practices of all those upstream organizations from which they purchase services and supplies and all those downstream to whom they distribute their services.”
What the Research Shows
The Institution of Occupational Safety and Health (IOSH) commissioned research by Cardiff and Oxford Brookes Universities on ‘Understanding the role of supply chains in influencing health and safety at work’. The research found that:
The attention paid to health and safety-related issues by supply chain buyers varies considerably.
This variation in attention is likely to reflect differences in:
the extent to which suppliers’ health and safety management affects the effective supply of goods and services to buyers
legislative and regulatory pressures.
Health and safety in supply chains is influenced both directly and indirectly by buyers and can be both positive and negative.
Attempts by buyers to influence their suppliers’ health and safety management will be more effective where:
they are supported by adequate monitoring and penalty arrangements
the relationship is relatively collaborative and trust-based.
Collaborative and trust-based relationships are more likely to exist where:
buyers and suppliers have worked well together for a relatively long time
there is a supportive environment
there is regulatory scrutiny or pressure.
Attempts by buyers to influence suppliers’ health and safety management will be less successful where:
they clash with the suppliers’ business interests
suppliers view the risks associated with failing to comply with them as low.
Regulation of the supply chain can take various forms, but in all cases there are implications for inspection and auditing of compliance.
The benefits of having a safe and healthy supply chain are considerable:
Reduction to costs associated with collisions, injuries, illnesses, and other problems caused by a lack of safety measures;
Improved productivity and morale in the supply chain;
Reduced insurance premiums; and
Increased brand reputation and customer trust.
Sources
Chartered Institute of Logistics and Transport UK. (2016). RISC: Reducing road risk in supply chains. FORS. https://www.fors-online.org.uk/cms/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/RISC-REDUCING-ROAD-RISK-IN-SUPPLY-CHAIN-1.pdf
Considerate Constructors Scheme. (n.d.). CLOCS – Construction Logistics and Community Safety. Best Practice Hub. https://ccsbestpractice.org.uk/clocs-standard/
Harvard Business School. (n.d.). The value chain. Harvard Business School – Institute for Strategy and Competitiveness. https://www.isc.hbs.edu/strategy/business-strategy/Pages/the-value-chain.aspx
Highways Safety Hub. (2024). Occupational Road Risk. https://www.highwayssafetyhub.com/occupational-road-risk.html
Swedish Transport Administration. (2019). Saving Lives Beyond 2020: The next steps — Recommendations of the Academic Expert Group for the 3rd Global Ministerial Conference on Road Safety. https://www.roadsafetysweden.com/contentassets/c65bb9192abb44d5b26b633e70e0be2c/200113_final-report-single.pdf
Walters, D., & James, P. (2009). Understanding the role of supply chains in influencing health and safety at work. Institution of Occupational Safety and Health. https://iosh.com/media/1hwpq5mn/iosh-research-understanding-the-role-of-supply-chains-full-report.pdf
With thanks to The Transafe Network for their contribution to this content.
