Approaches to Road Assessment

Prev Next
This content is currently unavailable in English (UK). You are viewing the default (English) version.

Implications for Delivery

Road assessments are key to identifying the highest-risk roads/streets and prioritising treatments given limited resources. Practitioners need to consider:

  • Types of assessment:

    • Reactive – based on past crash data (e.g. blackspot analysis, cycle route crashes). Limited by underreporting and statistical variation.

    • Proactive – predictive tools (e.g. iRAP star ratings, Scotland’s Route Risk Scoring System) to identify and treat risks before crashes occur.

    • Themed programmes – targeted to specific risks (e.g. rural curves, level crossings, barriers, schools, cycle routes).

  • Why proactive matters – most fatal crashes don’t repeat at the same site; focusing only on hotspots misses wider risks. Larger datasets and predictive models give more accurate results.

  • Applying assessments – combine desktop analysis, site visits, and Safe System frameworks to define treatments, including staged “step towards” measures.

  • Prioritisation – compare treatments by cost per fatal/serious injury reduced to build action plans and guide funding.

  • Integration – use network assessments to inform speed management, enforcement, skid resistance, barrier strategies, and ensure new projects align with Safe System End States.

Background

In February 2021, the Scottish Government introduced its Road Safety Framework to 2030, outlining an ambitious goal to position Scotland as a global leader in road safety by that year. The framework also embraces the Vision Zero initiative, aiming to eliminate all road-related deaths and serious injuries by 2050.

To achieve the 2050 goal, it is important to understand what the network would need to look like. This is understanding the ‘Vision Zero end state’. Vision Zero planning relies on a strategic road and street framework, such as Movement and Place or a road use hierarchy, to guide infrastructure decisions. This approach allows Safe System aligned infrastructure to be shaped around the movement and place functions of each road or street, rather than retrofitting safety onto existing classifications. In this way, the Safe System serves to support and enable broader strategic transport and place outcomes. With the End States and Safe System treatments established, the next step is to identify the highest-risk roads and streets. This is where road assessment plays a key role.

Road Assessments are primarily used to understand risk and prioritise treatments. This is important because of finite resources available for road safety treatments. There are three key types of road assessment used globally including:

  1. Reactive

  2. Proactive

  3. Other themed programmes

Reactive

Reactive risk assessments are the method traditionally used to analyse the risk of a road section or intersection based on the historical reported crashes. When we are reviewing Fatal and Serious crashes, reactive risk is usually split into Collective and Personal Risks.

Collective Risk is based on the total fatal and serious crashes at a given location / per km. Personal Risk considers the total fatal and serious crashes but accounts for the vehicle exposure at that site / route.

Other reactive road assessments review sites of serious of fatal crashes, such as black spot analysis, or certain types of crashes, such as cycle route crashes.

Care must be taken when utilising reactive risk assessments as it assumes that historical crashes are a good indicator of future crashes. However, research has shown that underreporting of crashes and statistical variation can mean that this approach is not always an accurate predictor of future risk.

Proactive

Proactive tools analyse the road network to help determine risk and inform investment decisions. Proactive tools can be utilised to help improve the current network or understand the risk of developments or changes to the network.

There are multiple forms of proactive network assessment. Globally the most widely used assessment is the International Road Assessment Programme (iRAP), which is developed by a global charity registered in the UK. This system develops a star rating system for roads from 50 road attributes to determine risk to road users and estimate Fatal and Serious injuries. There are also network specific proactive risk assessments. For example, Transport Scotland utilises Route Risk Scoring System (RRS), which is applied on Scotland’s 4,703 km of the Trunk Road Network to assess the risk of equal-length sections.

Other themed programmes

There are also proactive assessments for specific road users or road sections. These themes can warrant specific risk assessments to aid in the overall prioritisation of risk and funding of treatments. These themed programmes include:

  • Rural Out of Context Curve Assessments

  • Rail Level Crossing Assessments

  • Roadside Risk / Barrier Prioritisation

  • School Star Ratings

  • Cycle Star Ratings

Proactive assessments utilise predictive methods to prevent crashes. Care must be taken to ensure the risk calculation and assessments accurately predict crashes and risk. For example, the iRAP assessment records the presence of a roadside barrier and its offset from the traffic lane. However, it does not evaluate the suitability or appropriateness of the barrier type in relation to site-specific conditions.

Safe System Assessments

The Safe System Assessment Framework has been developed by Austroads and provides a structured way to evaluate how well road projects align with Safe System principles - the idea that no one should be killed or seriously injured on the road, even when mistakes occur. It enables practitioners to assess and compare road designs using a consistent scoring system that considers exposure, crash likelihood, and crash severity across key crash types. This helps identify where designs fall short of Safe System alignment and where targeted improvements can reduce fatal and serious injury risk.

Practitioners are encouraged to apply the framework early in the project lifecycle, when design modifications are still practical and cost-effective. Assessments compare three scenarios - the existing condition, the proposed design, and a hypothetical “fully aligned” Safe System case - to highlight potential safety gains and guide investment decisions.

The process is intended to complement, not replace, traditional road safety audits. While audits focus on compliance and specific hazards, the Safe System Assessment takes a strategic, outcome-focused view, helping ensure projects contribute meaningfully toward Vision Zero goals.

Embedding this framework into planning and design processes supports a proactive safety culture, encourages multi-disciplinary collaboration, and ensures that decisions are guided by how effectively they reduce the risk of death and serious injury - rather than simply by compliance or cost.

Why Proactive Assessment is Important

The proportion of fatal crashes happening repeatedly at the very same site in the UK is relatively low, with the majority of fatal crashes occurring at numerous different locations across the road network.

Assessing small road sections or sites can mean those sites may fluctuate abnormally high or low in number. Regression to the mean shows that as we take larger data pools, e.g. longer routes or more years of data, the crash rate will more closely align with the true mean. We can prevent this by having multiple years of data, comparing to control groups and employing statistical modelling.

Using Network Assessments

The network assessment should form part of the overall Vision Zero programme for Transport Scotland. Once the highest-risk roads, intersections and sites are identified, a combination of desktop analysis and targeted site visits should be undertaken to determine the appropriate treatments to achieve the End State for each location. This assessment would consider the road hierarchy, Movement and Place values, site constraints, and strategic considerations relevant to each part of the network. Where appropriate, 'Step Towards' treatments are also identified to provide staged, practical solutions.

Finally, the cost per fatal or serious injury reduced is calculated for each proposed treatment across the highest-risk lengths and intersections. This allows a prioritised list of treatments to be developed, forming the initial action plan within the Vision Zero Plan. The process can be repeated periodically as new programmes and funding opportunities arise for infrastructure improvements.

Network assessments can be utilised to determine key network wide programmes, such as speed management, enforcement, skid management, level of service, and barrier prioritisation.

Network assessment, e.g. Star Rating, can be incorporated on a project-by-project basis. Understanding how each project aligns to the Safe System End State for the site can be achieved through qualitative risk assessments, such as, Safe System Assessment Framework. Road Safety Audits can also include Star Rating to ensure new projects are contributing towards the overall network goals.

Sources

Austroads (2016) Safe System Assessment Framework. https://austroads.gov.au/publications/road-safety/ap-r509-16

Department for Transport. (2011). Strategic Framework for Road Safety. GOV.UK. Retrieved July 26, 2025, from https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/strategic-framework-for-road-safety

International Road Assessment Programme (iRAP). (2025). A world free of high-risk roads. Retrieved July 26, 2025, from https://irap.org

Department for Transport. (2025). Road Safety Data. data.gov.uk. Retrieved July 26, 2025, from https://www.data.gov.uk/dataset/cb7ae6f0-4be6-4935-9277-47e5ce24a11f/road-accidents-safety-data

Strandroth, J., Truong, J., Beer, K., & Shelton, D. (2024). 290 Vision Zero planning – a back-casting approach to achieve global road safety targets and zero road trauma. Injury Prevention, 30(Suppl 1), A62.1. https://doi.org/10.1136/injuryprev-2024-SAFETY.148[1](https://injuryprevention.bmj.com/content/30/Suppl_1/A62.1)

Department for Transport. (2024). Road safety statistics: interactive data tools. GOV.UK. Retrieved July 26, 2025, from https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/road-safety-statistics-data-tool


With thanks to Safe System Solutions for their contribution to this content.

Logo of Safe System Solution, emphasizing security and system efficiency.