Implications for Delivery
All involved in road safety audits needs to have a good understanding of the Safe System and what it means to think systemically.
In the absence of updated UK guidance for Road Safety Audits to incorporate Safe System elements, practitioners can use international guidance to support application of Safe System principles during audits.
Background
The objective of the road safety audit process is to provide an effective, independent review of the road safety implications of engineering interventions for all road users.
However, the traditional road safety audit process does not produce a definitive “pass” or “fail” outcome for engineering interventions. The Design team have the option to reject safety recommendations and not make any improvements to a scheme design.
As a result design, standards and audits have been identified as one of three barriers and challenges to implementing the Safe System in the UK. (CIHT, 2024)
Greater value can be secured by using audit processes not just to check for compliance or identify isolated hazards, but to systematically maximize safety outcomes and investment impacts by aligning every stage of the infrastructure project with Safe System principles.
What the Research Shows
Audits conducted with a Safe System mindset focus on three critical elements:
Crash Severity: Identifying elements that could cause fatal or serious injury, and prioritising remediation of these.
Crash Exposure: Assessing how often road users are exposed to risk at a site.
Crash Likelihood: Evaluating factors that make crashes more or less probable.
The Austroads Safe System Assessment Framework (Turner et al., 2016) recommends the use of a matrix to assess these three elements against crash types that are most likely to result in death or serious injury, including;
run-off-road (also referred to as ‘loss of control’)
head-on
intersection
other (this incorporates all same direction, manoeuvring, overtaking, on path and miscellaneous crashes)
pedestrian
cyclist
motorcyclist
This methodology aligns with the updated Guide to Road Safety Part 6: Road Safety Audit documentation reissued in 2022. (Hillier, 2022)
Proactive road assessment tools including iRAP (International Road Assessment Programme) also support improved safety outcomes by providing an objective measure of risk.
Using known relationships between the characteristics and layout of roads, their operation, and fatal and serious crash risk, iRAP estimate where fatal and serious injuries are likely in the future allowing road authorities to deliver countermeasures to reduce high risk areas.
Sources
DMRB (2025) GG 119 Road safety audit . National Highways. https://www.standardsforhighways.co.uk/search/html/69517ebd-ed8d-4558-b101-c1e80611000a?standard=DMRB
CIHT. (2024). Progressing the UK towards Safe System implementation. Chartered Institution of Highways & Transportation. https://assets.nationbuilder.com/20splentyforus/pages/1024/attachments/original/1734691472/progressing-the-uk-towards-safe-system-full-report.pdf?1734691472
Hillier, P. (2022). Guide to Road Safety Part 6: Road Safety Audit. In 978-1-922700-22-3 (Australia and New Zealand). Austroads. https://austroads.gov.au/publications/road-safety/agrs06
Turner, B., Jurewicz, C., Pratt, K., Corben, B., & Woodley, J. (2016). Safe System Assessment Framework. Austroads, 68. https://austroads.gov.au/publications/road-safety/ap-r509-16