Using Design Standards

Prev Next
This content is currently unavailable in English (UK). You are viewing the default (English) version.

Implications for Delivery

Design standards have provided good safety benefits in the past and are a fundamental aspect towards building safe road infrastructure. But, it is important for practitioners to understand how the Safe System principles should be applied alongside standards and guidance.

Key areas for consideration are:

  • How designs tolerate human error

  • What design speeds are appropriate

  • How to accommodate vulnerable road users

  • Proactive risk assessment

  • How road designs interact with other Safe System elements

Background

The UK has a long history of developing and using design standards and these have underpinned some of the success in reducing road casualties in the past. The UK’s standards are also the basis for many other standards in countries worldwide.

There are a wide range of design standards and guidance available to practitioners, including:

Design of trunk roads

Designing Streets: A Policy Statement for Scotland

Traffic signs and road markings

Traffic signs manual

Inclusive Mobility. A Guide to Best Practice on Access to Pedestrian and Transport Infrastructure

Guidance on the use of tactile paving surfaces

National Roads Development Guide

Cycling by design

Roads for All good practice guide

Project PRIME - Installation Toolkit

These design standards and guidance documents are intended to support a wide range of design considerations, so the principles used in applying them are very important to the outcomes. The discussion below outlines a series of principles that will be helpful in implementing road infrastructure measures aligned to the Safe System.

The aim here is to support a mindset for designers, grounded in the Safe System, which supports the early project and design stages.

What the Research Shows

Tolerating human error

The Safe System accepts that people make mistakes and designs the system to prevent these from resulting in death or serious injury. It is often easy to place emphasis on driver compliance and road user behaviour, but designs need to make it easy to comply and also maintain a safe environment when people do make mistakes. This includes forgiving roadsides or protective barriers. For example, tackling head-on collision risks (which could result from a momentary lapse) by increasing median separation, introducing median barriers or reducing potential impact speeds.

Considering appropriate design speeds

The Safe System limits kinetic energy to survivable levels in crashes. This means choosing appropriate design speeds is essential in applying the design standards to prioritise safety. When considering the appropriate design speeds for roads, the types of conflict are a key consideration in addition to any alignment or layout constraints. Designs should then encourage drivers to adhere to the Safe Speed for the types of conflict. For example, 20mph in areas with lots of people walking and wheeling and design layouts that encourage vehicles to drive at slower speeds (e.g. tighter radii, planting and horizontal or vertical deflection).

Designing for vulnerable road users

The Safe System prioritises the safety of pedestrians, cyclists and other vulnerable road users through separation and protection. Crossings, cycle paths and footpaths are sometimes secondary in road schemes or do not consider adequate separation and protection for vulnerable road users, such as barriers between vulnerable road user spaces and high-speed roads. There are now a wide range of design guidance documents to support with the design of infrastructure suitable for vulnerable road users, but ultimately there will be a design decision as to where the priority should be. The function of the road is an important factor and can be considered using movement and place hierarchies. Appropriately accommodating vulnerable road users is, therefore, a key part of applying the Safe System in road design.

Being proactive

The Safe System uses proactive risk management to prevent severe outcomes before crashes happen. Historically, design considerations have assessed risk in relation to collision history and more modern practices like iRAP or other proactive road assessment methods are yet to be properly embedded. However, by proactively assessing risk alongside collision history the standards and guidance can be used to develop schemes that address these risks.

System-wide accountability

In the Safe System responsibility is shared across those who design and operate the system, not just users. This represents a shift in approach from historic thinking which leaned toward road user responsibility rather than engineering out risk or providing systemic safeguards. As discussed above, design standards and guidance make it easy to place emphasis on driver compliance and road user behaviour, but designs need to make it easy to comply and also maintain a safe environment when people do make mistakes. Understanding the impact of design choice on road user behaviour, vehicle behaviour (driver assistance systems etc.), speed choice and post-crash response and maximising the effectiveness of interventions across the system are important considerations in applying the standards.

Sources

SWOV Institute for Road Safety Research. (2023). Principles for a safe road network. SWOV. https://www.swov.nl/en/fact-sheet/principles-safe-road-network