Implications for Delivery
When it comes to vulnerable road user protection in crashes, practitioners should:
Understand the limits of weight reduction: Even very lightweight vehicles are far heavier than pedestrians or cyclists, so weight incompatibility is a persistent issue - focus instead on reducing injury through other means.
Prioritise softer front-end design: Select or specify vehicles with front-end structures that are designed to cushion impacts with pedestrians and cyclists. Look for features such as deformable materials, pop-up bonnets, or external airbags, particularly in cars and vans.
Choose vehicle designs that minimise harm: Avoid vehicles with aggressive design features - for example, buses or trucks with low-mounted, protruding wiper arms. Opt for designs where hazards are mounted higher or recessed.
Pay attention to geometric design: Prefer vehicles with sloped front profiles over tall, vertical ones to reduce the likelihood of pedestrians being knocked down hard and quickly, increasing ground impact risk.
Don’t rely solely on Euro NCAP: While Euro NCAP ratings are helpful, they currently do not assess all aspects of geometric compatibility. Use them as a guide, but also assess overall vehicle shape and bonnet height.
Use technology to mitigate unavoidable risks: Equip high-risk vehicles with direct vision features and active safety systems like pedestrian-capable AEB (Autonomous Emergency Braking) to avoid collisions entirely.
Apply contractual leverage: As seen with TfL’s bus contracts, you can require pedestrian protection features beyond legal minimums when procuring fleets or services.
Background
Recognising there are challenges in crash compatibility between vehicles, when we consider the protection of pedestrians and cyclists, for all but perhaps lightweight car like quadricycles or cargo bikes, the weight incompatibility cannot be solved. Even a 450kg microcar will be 5 or 6 times the weight of a typical adult pedestrian. The lightest passenger cars will be more than 10 times the weight. At this level, the pedestrian already sees almost all of the change in velocity in a collision so reducing the weight of heavier vehicles to this level would have little effect.
For all vehicles, stiffness incompatibility between vehicle structures and pedestrians is large. It is also important to remember that the stiffness incompatibility between a person and the road surface is even larger. For passenger cars, the stiffness is controlled and moderated by regulations and Euro NCAP testing of vehicle front ends. These mean that dummy body parts are fired at crash speeds at the front end of cars and the forces and accelerations on them when they hit the vehicle must stay within set limits. This means that car makers must ‘soften’ the first few centimetres of the front ends to cushion the blow when hitting a vulnerable road user. Where doing this by only using crushable materials has proven difficult, manufacturers have innovated and produced pop up bonnets and external airbags to achieve good results.
Vans must now also comply with the regulations. However, heavier goods vehicles and buses are not subject to any of these requirements. Despite this, Transport for London (TfL) have implemented a simple version of those tests in contractual requirements for the buses they buy. It is also possible for any buyer, even without special qualification or equipment, to avoid some of the worst designs. For example, if a truck or a bus has windscreen wipers where the base is positioned at head height, then these could clearly be very hostile to vulnerable road users. Choosing a vehicle with wipers mounted at the top of the screen may be preferable.
Geometric incompatibility in the context of pedal cycle and pedestrian collisions can relate to where on the body the impact forces are imposed. If they are imposed in one focussed location, then they can be quite hostile in that specific area. If spread across more of the body, this may lessen the forces. However, where the forces are applied strongly affects the motion of the pedestrian after the impact. Traditional cars tend to strike adults on the legs, below their centre of gravity. This means they rotate towards the car and fall down onto the bonnet where the head hits and can be protected by soft structures. As the vehicle brakes, they fall to the ground from the relatively low height of the bonnet. Where either the bonnet height is much taller (e.g. larger SUVs) or the front end is near vertical (e.g. trucks and buses), the centre of the impact forces may be above the centre of gravity height of the pedestrian. This can force the pedestrian down towards the ground from a full standing height, creating a risk of a more severe impact with the ground, which is even stiffer than a vehicle and cannot easily be softened. They are also likely to hit the ground a shorter time after impact compared with traditional cars and as soon as they are on the ground they will start decelerating again due to friction. At that point, if the vehicle is still not braking hard, it can run them over with the wheels.
Geometric incompatibility is not accounted for in the performance-based tests for light vehicles undertaken in regulation or Euro NCAP. The concept is embodied as a geometric shape envelope in weights and dimensions regulations for HGVs, that allows normal length limits to be waived providing the vehicle can still meet manoeuvrability requirements, and it improves both aerodynamics and safety. There are proposals to introduce a geometric limit on bonnet height, but a simplistic approach like this places great reliance on the detailed wording of the regulation to define properties very carefully and then for industry to follow the spirit of the intention rather than finding creative designs to work around it. As a simple example, what is the bonnet height on a flat fronted HGV? A performance-based requirement could potentially be incorporated either in a full scale test, if a suitable dummy can be identified, or in simulation.
Euro NCAP is considering adding measures to address frontal crash compatibility with pedestrians and cyclists in 2031. At this stage, the potential for both stiffness and geometric compatibility assessments are under consideration.
In the case of heavy vehicles, there are additional geometric compatibility questions at the sides of vehicles. Sideguards are already required to stop cyclists (and occasionally pedestrians), that fall against the side of the vehicle as it passes from then getting into the path of the rear wheels and being run over. There is strong evidence these have had a significant effect, but improvements are still possible. Devices with lower ground clearance are likely to be more effective and basic designs use two horizontal rails. Smooth flat panels filling as much of the space between wheels as possible are also shown to be more effective.
What the Research Shows
A study of the effectiveness of Euro NCAP pedestrian testing found that, in Germany, each additional point gained in the pedestrian impact test was associated with about a 2.5% reduction in the probability of a pedestrian fatality.
Detailed evidence about the performance of crash protection systems can be found on Safety Cube DSS. Note that this gives evidence for each system in isolation. There is no evaluation of how the systems work together and interact as a package.
Understanding What Good Looks Like
Reliance solely on Euro NCAP ratings will not fully consider the effect of the geometric incompatibility with pedestrians. This problem is popularly associated with SUVs but is also applicable to both trucks and buses (and to some extent, vans). In theory, buyers can consider this themselves, avoiding cars with higher bonnet heights. However, this must be considered in conjunction with the Euro NCAP ratings because it is quite possible for a vehicle with a high bonnet (typically bad for geometric compatibility) to perform very well in terms of stiffness, and the opposite also to be true. In this case, the high bonnet vehicle could easily be better for safety than one with a low bonnet (but a poor Euro NCAP pedestrian score). This can be further complicated by shape. Some vehicles may rise near vertically to the bonnet leading edge, others may slope back somewhat. These will produce different outcomes, and it will be very hard for non-expert buyers to balance these effects. In practice, it will likely remain better to rely on Euro NCAP ratings for procurement.
For those buying HGVs, buying those with elongated cabins (e.g. DAF XG or Volvo FH Aero at the time of writing) might have some small benefits for pedestrian compatibility that is not currently assessed in their Euro NCAP rating. However, the elongated cab concept is not typically applied yet to urban trucks (it mainly targets long haul vehicles where significant aerodynamic benefits are found). This means that vehicles with this concept will tend to have a lower exposure to the risk of pedestrian crashes (which are mainly urban crashes). Vehicles with higher exposure, will tend not to have the cab design. Using long haul cabs in the city environment has other disadvantages, for example reduced direct vision. Therefore, collision avoidance through improved (including direct) vision and AEB systems that perform well for pedestrian detection are likely to be more beneficial.
Sources
Cookson, R., & Knight, I. (2010). Sideguards on heavy goods vehicles: assessing the effects on pedal cyclists injured by trucks overtaking or turning left (TRL Project Report No. PPR514). Transport Research Laboratory. https://www.trl.co.uk/uploads/trl/documents/PPR514_secure.pdf
Euro NCAP. (2023). Vulnerable road user (VRU) protection. https://www.euroncap.com/en/car-safety/the-ratings-explained/vulnerable-road-user-vru-protection/
Pastor, C. (2013). Correlation between pedestrian injury severity in real-life crashes and Euro NCAP pedestrian test results (Paper No. 13-0308). Federal Highway Research Institute (BASt), Germany. https://cdn.euroncap.com/media/1375/23esv-000308page1-0-3f5feddf-09ec-4066-ba89-064ea19356c7.pdf
SafetyCube DSS. (n.d.). Measure search. European Road Safety Decision Support System. https://www.roadsafety-dss.eu/#/measure-search
With thanks to Apollo Vehicle Safety for their contribution to this content.
