Crash Compatibility: Vehicle to Vehicle

Prev Next
This content is currently unavailable in English (UK). You are viewing the default (English) version.

Implications for Delivery

When it comes to crash compatibility it is important for practitioners to:

  • Be aware of vehicle incompatibilities when assessing or specifying fleets or road safety strategies — crashes between mismatched vehicles (in weight, stiffness, or structure height) can lead to severe injuries, especially for occupants of smaller vehicles.

  • Encourage or specify vehicles that perform well in Euro NCAP compatibility tests, especially when procuring heavier passenger vehicles. This promotes wider energy distribution in crashes and better protection for all road users.

  • Support or advocate for front underrun protection on HGVs, buses, and coaches — even where not mandatory — to help reduce severity in head-on crashes with smaller vehicles.

  • Review the suitability of fleet vehicles, especially for local authorities or service providers. Consider how well they protect both their own occupants and those in other vehicles during a collision.

  • Promote data sharing and evaluation of real-world crash outcomes involving different vehicle types to help build the case for improved regulations and manufacturer practices.

  • Engage with evolving standards: Follow developments from Euro NCAP and similar bodies to stay ahead of changes in crash compatibility testing and apply them in purchasing, regulation, or planning decisions.

  • Consider vehicle interactions in infrastructure design — ensure that roads, junctions, and barriers account for the wide range of vehicle sizes and crash behaviours to reduce risk where mismatches are most likely.

  • Collaborate across disciplines (fleet operators, road designers, safety regulators) to ensure a whole-system approach to vehicle compatibility and occupant protection.

Background

For some time, most vehicle types have been designed to protect their occupants in a collision. For passenger cars, this was driven by both regulatory and consumer (e.g. Euro NCAP) crash tests against rigid or uniform energy absorbing barriers. In effect, this simulated a collision with an identical vehicle. In order to make progress in these tests, manufacturers:

  • installed stiff deformable elements in the front of vehicles to absorb energy (crumple zones)

  • made a very stiff passenger cell in order to maintain a ‘survival space’ for the occupants

  • then designed restraint systems (e.g. seat belts and airbags) that controlled the deceleration of occupants along with the car to make the impact as ‘soft’ as possible for the occupant

However, in the real-world, vehicles come in all shapes and sizes from the smallest city car to the biggest truck and when these meet there are a number of possible incompatibilities:

Weight incompatibility

When two vehicles of equal weight collide, they each experience the same change in velocity (e.g. 30 mph forward to a complete stop). When a heavy vehicle collides with a lighter vehicle, the lighter vehicle will see a much larger change in velocity and the occupants will therefore be at higher risk of injury (and vice versa for the heavier vehicle). In an extreme example of a car colliding with a fully laden HGV, both travelling at 30 mph in opposing directions, the HGV might slow from 30 to 28 mph but the car might go from 30 mph forward to 28 mph backward, an overall change of 58 mph

Stiffness incompatibility

Clearly a 44 tonne truck requires an extremely stiff chassis just to support the loads. This may be considerably stiffer than the crumple zone of a car that it may hit, such that the truck deforms very little and all the crash energy must be dissipated by the car. In passenger cars, barrier tests encouraged stiff longitudinals (structural elements running the length of the vehicle) that crumpled. However, heavier cars needed much stiffer longitudinals than lighter cars did, so heavier cars also tended to be stiffer than lighter cars

Geometric compatibility

For the crashworthy parts of vehicles to do their job properly, deform, and make survival space, they have to interact with each other in a crash. In an extreme example of an HGV, the very stiff chassis could be 80-100cm from the ground, whereas the crash element in the front of the car may only be 40cm from the ground. The car passes underneath the front of the truck until the stiff truck chassis contacts with the engine or the A-pillars, (which are not designed to take load in that way). The car crumple zones cannot do their job - the deceleration the vehicle experiences is different and this can also adversely affect the timing of airbags. The same can be true in collisions between cars, if all the energy absorption is controlled through just two crash structures (longitudinals)

Testing and application

For passenger cars, Euro NCAP recently adopted a new test aimed at promoting improved crash compatibility of cars, particularly those that are heavier. Instead of a collision with a fixed barrier, the vehicle collides with a mobile trolley (a substitute car) with a weight representing a more average or small size car. The trolley is equipped with a crushable barrier face. The acceleration of the trolley and the deformation of this barrier is measured. Weight incompatibility is discouraged in this because it will cause more acceleration and general deformation in the trolley. Excessively stiff front ends are discouraged because they will increase deformation in the barrier. Vehicle front end designs that spread the load across a wide area of the front are encouraged because this minimises the maximum depth of crush on the barrier and, in the real world increases the chance of proper interaction of structures.

For trucks, the weight incompatibility cannot realistically be solved - the nature of the vehicle is to carry heavy loads and replacing them with lighter vehicles would simply increase exposure to risk (because many more journeys would be required). They have been required to address the geometric incompatibility through the mandatory application of rear and front underrun protection. This ensures that a stiff structure is placed across the width of the vehicle at a height which will prevent complete underrun of passenger cars. A range of research has suggested that this has been beneficial. However, it has also highlighted weaknesses and areas for further improvement in both structural interaction and energy absorption (setting stiffness levels to allow appropriate deformation).

While front underrun protection is available on some buses and coaches, it is not mandatory and it is not known how commonly it is actually fitted.

Euro NCAP is considering adding measures to HGV assessments from 2031 to address frontal crash compatibility with vehicles.

There are also similar crash compatibility questions when cars collide with the side of HGVs. Current sideguards are designed only to be effective for vulnerable road users. The frequency of collisions with the sides of HGVs are typically lower and protection may be needed on both sides, which doubles costs and weight penalties from additional structures. These have held back progress in this area in the past.

What the Research Shows

Crash compatibility measures for partner vehicle protection taken by Euro NCAP remain relatively new and it has been too soon to allow any assessment of the casualty effects of performing well in the test versus performing poorly. The underlying problem of shifting fatalities from larger heavier vehicles to the smaller lighter vehicles is well documented and there is some evidence that the total combined number of fatalities increases slightly with increasing total combined weight of the two vehicles involved.

There is some evidence on the effectiveness of underrun protection on HGVs, but the lower numbers involved also make that difficult and some analyses are more of a sequence of case studies. Predictions before implementation have shown substantial reductions for rear underrun, where relative speeds tend to be lower (both vehicles travelling in the same direction). For front underrun, predictions are a more modest proportion because impact speeds tend to be very high where each vehicle is travelling in opposite directions. However, it is a smaller proportion of a larger group of fatalities.

Understanding What Good Looks Like

Vehicle buyers for passenger cars can rely on Euro NCAP test results to choose vehicles, which will place pressure on the manufacturers to improve crash compatibility with other vehicles and to improve the stiffness incompatibility problem with pedestrians (as well as a wide range of other factors).

Actions to better understand the effectiveness of these new performance tests for frontal compatibility with vehicles will help to improve those tests in the future.

Similarly, supporting initiatives to assess the effectiveness of front underrun protection on HGVs and the feasibility of improvements would help to lead progress in that area, with Euro NCAP’s scheme available as a delivery mechanism. Consideration of whether there is a need to extend this approach more widely to the sides of HGVs, and to all sides of buses and coaches, may also have potential benefits.

Sources

Cookson, R., & Knight, I. (2010). Sideguards on heavy goods vehicles: assessing the effects on pedal cyclists injured by trucks overtaking or turning left (TRL Project Report No. PPR514). Transport Research Laboratory. https://www.trl.co.uk/uploads/trl/documents/PPR514_secure.pdf

Global NCAP. (2025). Fleet safety guide & safer vehicle purchasing policy 2025-2026. Global NCAP. https://www.globalncap.org/news/fleetsafe-global-ncap-fleet-safety-guide-amp-safer-purchasing-policy-2025-2026

Knight, I. (2016). HGV safety & aerodynamics (Project Report No. RR2016_005). Transport & Environment, Brussels. https://www.transportenvironment.org/uploads/files/FUP20report202016.pdf

SafetyCube DSS. (n.d.). Measure search. European Road Safety Decision Support System. https://www.roadsafety-dss.eu/#/measure-search


With thanks to Apollo Vehicle Safety for their contribution to this content.

Apollo Vehicle Safety logo