Implications for Delivery
Practitioners should understand the following challenges relating to occupant protection and where they can focus their efforts in this area or other, supporting elements of the Safe System:
Occupant protection in cars is highly effective and mature, particularly in frontal impacts, thanks to crumple zones, strong passenger cells, and advanced restraint systems like seat belts and airbags. However, side impacts and rear-end whiplash injuries still pose challenges, and continued attention is needed to design improvements, especially for vulnerable groups like children and older adults.
Other vehicle types, such as vans, HGVs, buses, and micromobility modes, vary significantly in protection standards. Practitioners should advocate for enhanced transparency and testing (e.g. through Euro NCAP or equivalent schemes) to improve protection in these vehicles, especially where large numbers of occupants are involved or crash compatibility is poor.
Real-world implementation must consider system-wide trade-offs. In city buses, for example, occupant safety is balanced with operational constraints like passenger capacity and boarding times. Practitioners should take a whole-system perspective—balancing crash protection with prevention, usability, and cost—when shaping policy or vehicle procurement strategies.
Background
Basic Principles. Occupant protection in vehicles can, at a simplistic level, be divided into three parts:
Manage vehicle acceleration: In practice, this means crumple zones. Imagine a car hitting a wall at 30 mph. If the car front is very stiff, it might come to a stop with little damage in a distance of maybe 10 cm. If the car has a long bonnet that is much less stiff, it might come to a stop in a distance of 100 cm. The stiff design is good for preventing damage and minimising the repair bill but implies an average deceleration of 90 times the force of gravity (very bad for occupants). The soft design will suffer much more damage, but the average deceleration will only be 9 times the force of gravity (much better for occupants).
Provide a survival space: If the crumple zone is so long that the car crushes around the occupant, then this could also crush the occupants and/or cause penetration injuries. So, after a ‘soft’ crumple zone, a very stiff passenger compartment is required to maintain a safe space around the occupants and prevent intrusion.
Restrain the occupants: When the vehicle decelerates suddenly, the occupants will remain moving at their original speed until something slows them down. If they are not restrained in the example of the 30 mph crash into a brick wall, that means their head will hit windscreen; their chest will hit the steering wheel; and their legs hit the lower fascia, all at something close to 30 mph, with relatively small crush distances. The outcome can still be very bad despite the crumple zone and the stiff passenger cell. Seat belts tether the occupant to the vehicle, so they also benefit from the soft ‘ride down’ provided by the comfort zone. They prevent some, but not all, of the contacts with the interior. Heads may now still hit steering wheels. This is where airbags come in, detecting the collision and inflating soft structures to cushion those residual impacts. Seat belts have also advanced so that they automatically tighten in the early phases of a crash to take up any slack due to bulky clothes etc. In severe crashes, (where the loads from the seat belt itself could cause injury), load limiters will allow small extensions of the belt to reduce the forces.
In passenger cars, adult occupant protection is already extremely well designed. Frontal collision was once the biggest problem, but the principles above have been well applied. Side impacts have a more fundamental limitation – there is much less space available in the width of a vehicle for crumple zones. There has been a trend for passenger cars to get wider - that is likely driven by comfort and style considerations and has a number of disadvantages, but it does have the safety benefit of placing the occupants further away from the doors.
Rear impact less often causes serious injury so has had less attention. However, rear impacts can often lead to whiplash injury. This tends to be a less severe injury but is very frequent. It is associated with rapid and excessive distortion of the spine. Here the occupant restraint is provided by the seat (it’s a head restraint, not a head rest!).
Good design will help prevent an offset between the head and torso, and provide effective support to the head and neck and reduce the probability of whiplash.
Child occupant protection is a specialist subset of occupant protection. The use of correctly sized and fitted child restraint systems is essential for their protection. There are two aspects of the performance of these systems. One is how well the vehicle can secure the child restraint within it and control its motion and forces. Testing, such as that from Euro NCAP, assess the performance of a manufacturer’s preferred child restraints in the crash testing. It also tests how easily a wide range of different child restraints can be fitted within the vehicle. The second aspect is how good the child restraint itself is at restraining the child within the seat and protecting it from contacts with other interior structures. The German motoring organisation ADAC runs a scheme rating the performance of child seats to enable consumers to choose the safest.
Occupant protection is also relevant in other vehicle types:
Vans: from 2024, the basic front and side impact tests for cars will be extended to the larger vans that were previously exempt. In 2027, Euro NCAP will begin applying their new ‘frontal test with a moving barrier’ in the van rating to promote both occupant protection and crash compatibility.
HGVs: The mass of HGVs helps to protect HGV occupants because in many collisions, the truck does not decelerate much. As such, only around 11% of fatalities from collisions involving HGVs are the occupants, but protecting them remains important. Regulatory requirements are quite different. Seat belts are mandatory. Regulation controls the occupant compartment integrity through the use of pendulum tests swinging heavy impactors into the front and rear of the cab, as well as a quasi-static load test to represent rollover. There are fundamental limitations in the length available for crumple zones and the quantity of energy that must be absorbed in collisions. However, manufacturers seem to go much further than required by regulation, undertaking full scale impact tests more like the car ones but tailored for HGVs, installing driver airbags and for some manufacturers even curtain airbags for rollovers. Euro NCAP are considering adding occupant protection requirements to their rating for HGVs
Buses & Coaches: also benefit from high mass relative to other vehicles, helping protect occupants via lower deceleration. However, they usually contain many occupants (passengers) such that when a collision occurs there can be many more casualties. Euro NCAP are considering developing a safety rating for buses and coaches that could include occupant protection measures
City buses have very little occupant protection. As well as high mass, they are seen as ‘low speed’ although they are sometimes used on higher speed roads. No seat belts are required for any occupant (though if fitted, they must be worn). A wide range of factors contribute to why seatbelts are not required - permitting standee passengers greatly increases capacity; seat belts might increase the time needed to load and unload passengers at bus stops (affecting congestion); there may be difficulties enforcing belt use; as well as costs and risks associated with belts degrading due to lack of use and/or vandalism. A variety of poles and structures are needed to help passengers hold on and avoid falls in motion but can be quite hostile objects to hit in collisions. When all casualty severities are considered, then injuries to occupants are the most frequent in collisions involving city buses. However, if only fatalities are considered, occupants are a very small proportion of the total (pedestrians are the dominant group). Transport for London (TfL) have implemented measures to try to ensure poles and fixtures are not in areas likely to be hit by occupants, as well as a range of measures to try to prevent slips, trips, and falls on the bus.
Coaches: Coaches do not permit standees and do require seat belts to be fitted and worn. However, enforcement of belt use in coaches is difficult and belt wearing rates among passengers are thought to be low. Rollovers are the biggest cause of coach occupant fatalities, though frontal collisions with other heavy vehicles can also be relevant. Coaches are subject to a mandatory rollover test aimed at ensuring an adequate survival space is maintained in the passenger compartment. However, further measures such as laminated side glass to prevent ejection and other methods of restraint are often discussed as having potential.
Microcars / quadricycles / micromobility: A range of small lightweight vehicles are becoming more common on our roads for efficiency and sustainability aims. These tend to have few regulatory requirements for occupant protection as well as relatively little published information on their safety performance. Where tests have been done on ‘car-like’ quadricycles they have typically not performed well, even in tests of reduced speed compared with passenger cars.
What the Research Shows
In passenger, cars occupant protection is very mature. Regulations prescribe vehicle performance requirements for crash protection. Considerable research proves effectiveness. For example, in early developments, a TRL study (Broughton, 2003) estimated that by 1998, improvements in occupant protection had prevented at least 19% of killed and serious injuries, and that if only the most modern cars (at the time) were considered, this increased to around 33%. A more recent study in Sweden (Kullgren et al 2019) found that car models launched between 2015 and 2018 had a risk of serious injury to occupants in the event of a collision that was 67% of models launched in 1980-1984. Considering more contemporary vehicles they found that a 5 star rating was associated with a 34% lower risk of serious occupant injury than a 2 star rated car.
TRL studied the potential to improve occupant protection on buses and predicted modest benefits from introducing a scheme to encourage better positioning of poles.
Market Availability
Crash protection systems are generally built into new vehicles by the Original Equipment Manufacturer (OEM). They involve the shape and structural design of the vehicle, so retrofit is not possible. For buyers of cars, there is little need to look beyond Euro NCAP for consideration of occupant protection – a 5 star rating ensures state of the art performance.
The picture is not so clear for other vehicle types, with a mixed standard of protection that is generally lower than for passenger cars. The high mass of some vehicle types (e.g. trucks) acts as some form of protection, which makes it a lower priority than other crash safety measures. However, improvements are possible, so it is likely that there are better and worse vehicles on the market. These are very hard for buyers to identify and, in some cases, there are competing safety, operational, and economic reasons for reduced occupant protection. Analysis of the whole Safe System is particularly important in those areas to ensure that actions on vehicle standards on occupant protection are the most appropriate way to prevent those casualties, or whether other elements of the Safe System may be better.
Actions to improve the transparency and understanding of current performance in vehicles other than cars would be very beneficial. Building on that, investigation of the wide range of potential measures needs to consider realistic operational and economic constraints and the interaction of the whole system.
Sources
Edwards, M., Appleby, J., Venkateswaran, K., Robinson, B., Edwards, A., Martin, P., & McCarthy, M. (2022). The Transport for London (TfL) Bus Safety Standard: Occupant friendly interiors (Published Project Report No. PPR992). TRL Limited for Transport for London. https://content.tfl.gov.uk/bus-safety-standard-occupant-friendly-interiors.pdf
Euro NCAP. (2023). Adult occupant protection. https://www.euroncap.com/en/car-safety/the-ratings-explained/adult-occupant-protection/
Euro NCAP. (2023). Child occupant protection. https://www.euroncap.com/en/car-safety/the-ratings-explained/child-occupant-protection/
Euro NCAP. (2025). Quadricycle ratings. Quadricycles & Microcars. https://www.euroncap.com/en/ratings-rewards/quadricycle-ratings/
Euro NCAP. (2023). Vulnerable road user (VRU) protection. https://www.euroncap.com/en/car-safety/the-ratings-explained/vulnerable-road-user-vru-protection/
Global NCAP. (2025). Fleet safety guide & safer vehicle purchasing policy 2025-2026. Global NCAP. https://www.globalncap.org/news/fleetsafe-global-ncap-fleet-safety-guide-amp-safer-purchasing-policy-2025-2026
SafetyCube DSS. (n.d.). Measure search. European Road Safety Decision Support System. https://www.roadsafety-dss.eu/#/measure-search
Scania UK. (n.d.). Safety attributes. Scania. https://www.scania.com/uk/en/home/products/attributes/safety.html
With thanks to Apollo Vehicle Safety for their contribution to this content.
