Advanced Emergency Braking (AEB)

Prev Next
This content is currently unavailable in English (UK). You are viewing the default (English) version.

Implications for Delivery

AEB is a proven safety technology that reduces the frequency and severity of road collisions, but its effectiveness depends on correct specification, understanding of limitations, and appropriate use. During procurement, safety teams should prioritise models with AEB as standard or consider optional fitment, especially in large fleets where reduced collision costs can justify the investment. Euro NCAP ratings can support informed decisions. However, identifying AEB in used vehicles can be challenging, and retrofitting is generally not feasible.

Professionals must understand AEB's role as a driver-assistance system - not a replacement for driver responsibility. Its effectiveness declines at higher speeds or in complex alignment scenarios, and it may not prevent all crashes. System interfaces must be well-designed to avoid driver annoyance and disengagement. Training, including use of telematics or dashcam footage, can help drivers appreciate the system’s value and reduce the risk of it being turned off.

AEB reduces insurance claim frequency, but increases the average cost of remaining claims due to sensor damage. This may create conflicting incentives across departments, so holistic understanding is crucial.

Background

Advanced Emergency Braking (AEB) is also referred to as automated or autonomous emergency braking. It uses forward facing sensors to monitor the road ahead and identify imminent collision threats. AEB will issue a warning to the driver (typically a visual symbol with an audible beep) to try and get them to respond. If the driver is unresponsive, the vehicle will automatically apply braking to try and prevent the collision, or if it is unavoidable, to lessen the severity of injuries.

AEB can work in different categories of collision and fitment, or performance can vary in different vehicle categories:

  • Vehicle to vehicle front to rear shunt

  • Pedestrian collisions

    • Pedestrian crossing in front of moving vehicle

    • Pedestrian walking along in road

  • Cyclist collisions

    • Crossing path at junctions

    • Front to rear when travelling in same lane/direction

  • Rear AEB that acts to prevent collisions where a vehicle reverses into another vehicle, object, or person

  • Side protection AEB that acts to stop the vehicle in low-speed parking situations, where sharp turning might cause the side of the vehicle to make contact with adjacent parked vehicles, poles, walls etc.

  • Vehicle to Vehicle at junctions

    • Right turn (EU) across path of oncoming vehicle

    • Crossroads

It is an assistance system only; the driver remains fully in charge of the vehicle at all times. If the driver gives a large input of steering or braking, the vehicle will deactivate AEB. It assumes the driver knows best how to handle the collision threat.  

There are important limitations to the technology. In general, as an assistance-only system, the general philosophy is ‘first do no harm’. So, a lot of effort is put into avoiding false positive interventions, though this is never perfect and false positives do still occur. The higher the vehicle speed, the less likely it is that collisions are avoided. Performance is generally good where the centres of vehicles are aligned, but it can degrade as the alignment gets closer to being between the edges of the vehicles because it is harder for sensors to be sure an impact will occur.

What the Research Shows

AEB was first introduced to the market in about 2006. Evidence has been clear that it is an effective system for casualty reduction but not a silver bullet.  

Fildes, et al., 2015 evaluated the effectiveness of low speed AEB on passenger vehicles. Using data from a number of countries they found a 38% overall reduction in rear-end crashes for passenger cars fitted with AEB compared to a comparison sample of similar vehicles. There was no statistical evidence of any difference in effect between urban (≤60km/h) and rural (>60km/h) speed zones. An IIHS Study (Teoh, 2021) in the US and a BASt study in Germany (Sander, 2021) found similar results for systems fitted to HGVs.

Ciccinho (2022) found that in the US, cars equipped with pedestrian AEB were associated with a 30% reduction in injury collision risk for pedestrians. However, there was no evidence of a reduction at nighttime.

The EU made front-to-rear AEB (Inter-urban) mandatory for most trucks and coaches (not city buses) in 2015, with further regulations coming to make it mandatory for cars and vans to fit front-to-rear AEB and pedestrian crossing AEB in 2024 and 2026 respectively.  

Note that the regulations cover the EU, and since Brexit, these have not been adopted by the UK. Vehicle manufacturers are very unlikely to make different vehicles just for the UK, and Euro NCAP data shows that the majority of vehicles were fitting them in any case, before the regulation was introduced. We can expect AEB fitted vehicles in the UK, but it is worth checking carefully during procurement.  

Note that buses that have standing passengers are exempt from the AEB regulations, due to a concern about passengers falling under braking. Transport for London has researched the risks, and now buses with AEB fitted are entering London on trial.  

Detailed evidence about the performance of collision avoidance systems can be found on Safety Cube DSS. Note that this gives evidence for each system in isolation. There is no evaluation of how the systems work together and interact as a package.

Encouraging Take-Up

During procurement, it is important to consider the fitment as standard and optional carefully to ensure the safety system is correctly specified. Optional fitment generally incurs an additional cost, which, in a large fleet, is often justified due to reduced collision costs. However, this can be harder to prove in smaller fleets and for individual buyers, so additional mechanisms to help encourage the right choices can be beneficial. Identifying fitment in the used-vehicle market can be harder. Whilst retrofit of forward collision warning systems is feasible, retrofit of AEB is generally not possible.

Euro NCAP ratings can be used as a performance reference. This can inform procurement decisions about which models will be safer.  

Challenges in Real-World Use

The interface of warnings is important to consider, because some can be annoying. If drivers are too annoyed, they may turn the system off, which removes the safety potential. Even if it is not possible to turn a system off, excessively frequent audible warnings can become ‘background noise’ such that drivers no longer respond to them. Some progressive fleet operators have identified using telematics and dashcams instances where AEB has been effective in avoiding collisions and have used footage from these to help train and educate drivers as to why they should not turn the system off.

AEB is proven to prevent a proportion of incidents, but it cannot prevent all. In those collisions that remain, there is a risk of damaging the sophisticated sensors that the system relies on. The evidence suggests that there is strong reduction in insurance claims frequency with fitment of AEB, but the average cost of remaining claims does increase. The net outcome remains a reduction in insurance costs overall, but this can create difficulties in larger organisations where responsibilities are divided. It is important for everyone to understand the effects to avoid a situation where a department incentivised only on the average cost of repairs, begins to campaign for stopping the use of AEB based on only seeing part of the story.

There can also be restrictions on the type of repairs that may be undertaken in structures (e.g. bumper covers) close to sensors. Some also require recalibration after repairs (e.g. windscreen replacement) to ensure the systems still work correctly. Calibration can also add to repair cost. However, self-calibrating sensors are increasingly common. As the systems become more common in the market, their cost will reduce too.

Global NCAP includes AEB on their list of ‘must have equipment’ (for immediate application).

Sources

Cicchino, J. B. (2022). Effects of automatic emergency braking systems on pedestrian crash risk. Accident Analysis & Prevention, 172, 106686. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aap.2022.106686

Dodd, M., Knight, I., Edwards, A., Edwards, M., Ball, P., Appleby, J., & Radcliffe, J. (2022). Bus safety standard: Bus braking data analysis (Published Project Report No. PPR1013). Transport Research Laboratory for Transport for London. https://content.tfl.gov.uk/bus-safety-standard-bus-braking-data-analysis.pdf

Euro NCAP. (2023). AEB car-to-car. https://www.euroncap.com/en/car-safety/the-ratings-explained/safety-assist/aeb-car-to-car/

Euro NCAP. (2023). AEB cyclist. https://www.euroncap.com/en/car-safety/the-ratings-explained/vulnerable-road-user-vru-protection/aeb-cyclist/

Euro NCAP. (2023). AEB lane support motorcyclist. https://www.euroncap.com/en/car-safety/the-ratings-explained/vulnerable-road-user-vru-protection/aeb-lane-support-motorcyclist/

Euro NCAP. (2023). AEB pedestrian. https://www.euroncap.com/en/car-safety/the-ratings-explained/vulnerable-road-user-vru-protection/aeb-pedestrian/

Fildes, B., Keall, M., Bos, N., Lie, A., Page, Y., Pastor, C., Pennisi, L., Rizzi, M., Thomas, P., & Tingvall, C. (2015). Effectiveness of low speed autonomous emergency braking in real-world rear-end crashes. Accident Analysis & Prevention, 81, 24–29. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aap.2015.03.029

Highway Loss Data Institute. (2018). Compendium of HLDI collision avoidance research (HLDI Bulletin Vol. 35, No. 34). Insurance Institute for Highway Safety. https://www.iihs.org/media/7560e1bf-fcc5-4540-aa16-07444f17d240/Io54Pw/HLDI%20Research/Collisions%20avoidance%20features/35.34-compendium.pdf

National Windscreens. (2019). Fleet news: The business of ADAS calibration. National Windscreens. https://www.nationalwindscreens.co.uk/news/company-news/fleet-news-the-business-of-adas-calibration

Sander, D. (2021). Accident analysis (IWG AEBS HDV SP-02). United Nations Economic Commission for Europe. https://wiki.unece.org/display/trans/AEBS-HDV-SP-02

Saadé, J. (2017), Autonomous Emergency Braking AEB (city, inter-urban), European Road Safety Decision Support System, developed by the H2020 project SafetyCube. https://www.roadsafety-dss.eu/assets/data/pdf/synopses/Autonomous_Emergency_Braking_AEB_city_interurban_27092017.pdf

Saadé, J. (2017), Autonomous Emergency Braking AEB (pedestrians & cyclists), European Road Safety Decision Support System, developed by the H2020 project SafetyCube. https://www.roadsafety-dss.eu/assets/data/pdf/synopses/Autonomous_Emergency_Braking_AEB_pedestrians_cyclists_20112017.pdf

Teoh, E. R. (2021). Effectiveness of front crash prevention systems in reducing large truck real-world crash rates. Traffic Injury Prevention, 22(4), 284-289. https://doi.org/10.1080/15389588.2021.1893700


With thanks to Apollo Vehicle Safety for their contribution to this content.

Apollo Vehicle Safety logo