Lane Support

Prev Next
This content is currently unavailable in English (UK). You are viewing the default (English) version.

Implications for Delivery

People buying vehicles and those running fleets should try to consider the real-world performance of Lane Support systems. Although it is difficult to test them, driver concerns should be listened to, and wherever possible, systems with both good Euro NCAP scores and high driver acceptance should be preferred. Training in how the systems work, and what the benefits are, may also help to avoid drivers simply switching off or ignoring systems.

Background

Many collisions involve vehicles leaving their lane. This can involve unintended departure into an adjacent or opposing lane, or off the carriageway altogether. Alternatively, it can involve a deliberate change of lane (e.g. for overtaking) where another road user was already present, resulting in a collision. Unintentional departures are often characterised by a lack of use of the direction indicators and a gradual drift out of a lane on a straight road, or progressing in a straight line where the road goes around a bend. Inattention (impairment or distraction) of the driver is usually the main contributory factor. Deliberate lane changes can also be due to inattention (changing lanes without looking) but vehicle blind spots, driver error of judgements, speed and conspicuity of other parties can also be contributory. Incidents are particularly serious if the vehicle collides with obstacles (such as trees) off the roadway or head-on with oncoming vehicles in the opposite lane.  

Lane Support Systems is a generic title given to a range of different functions, all relying on similar camera technologies to detect lane boundaries and/or road edge boundaries. Systems are primarily aimed at highway driving and will generally deactivate at speeds below around 40 mph, or if lane boundaries are not reliably detected. The following main functions will operate when the direction indicators are not activated, and a lane departure is occurring:

  • Lane departure warning (LDW) simply tries to warn the driver when a lane departure is detected. Warnings often include an acoustic element but can also be visual and/or haptic (e.g. seat or steering vibration). These systems have been mandatory for trucks and coaches since 2015.

  • Lane Keep Assist (LKA) systems aim to be more effective than warnings by trying to actively correct the course of a vehicle that is gradually veering out of its lane. These systems require electrically power assisted steering, which has been common on passenger cars for some time. It is available for trucks but not yet that common and is rarely seen on buses.

  • Emergency Lane Keep (ELK) systems combine lane detection with other crash prediction sensors such that they only act if both lane departure and a risk of collision is detected. In this case, they can apply a much stronger course correction (either through steering and/or braking at selective wheels).

Blind spot monitoring systems are very similar except they also use rearward looking sensors to monitor the blind spots at the sides of the vehicle, to the rear of the driver. These systems will identify if a lane change is deliberately initiated with direction indicators active. They take action if there is a vehicle present in the zone the equipped vehicle is moving into. Like the systems above, the actions can be warnings or interventions. In essence, an intervention system is an ELK system as described above that also functions when the direction indicators are activated.  

Lane Support Systems are an assistance system only, not automated driving; the driver remains fully in charge of the vehicle. If the driver gives a large input of steering or braking, the vehicle will deactivate lane support. It assumes the driver knows how best to handle the collision threat.

Some lane control systems have come in for considerable criticism in trade press for being annoying. Drivers are exposed to a wide range of information, warnings, and interventions from modern vehicles during driving. It is beneficial if each system is an integrated part of a strategy for the whole vehicle and ISO standards exist to guide this design. In general, tonal audible warnings are reserved for situations where drivers must take urgent action (within the next 2-3 seconds) to avoid a critical incident (i.e. collision).

Lane departure warning systems have long been considered a collision avoidance system because when real collisions are studied where lane departure occurred, the vehicle would typically not be a collision risk until they had left the lane and, at that time a collision would be imminent. That is, at that point, there is an urgent need for the driver to take action to avoid a collision. It is a collision avoidance tool, and the most urgent (and annoying) warnings are justified.

However, in the way lane departure warning is implemented, it responds with the same warning every time a lane boundary is crossed, or is close to being crossed, irrespective of context. For example, it may go off on a curvy country road where the driver takes the most efficient line through a bend. In the vast majority of cases where the warning is activated in the real world, the situation is not one where driver action to avoid collision is needed in 2-3 seconds. The driver feels the warning is unnecessary and if this happens frequently, they lose trust, become annoyed, and potentially switch systems off.

LKA systems can mitigate this to some extent, by replacing acoustic warnings with haptic warnings and interventions in more severe cases. This can reduce annoyance, but some drivers still find the interventions irritating and in some cases, they can be concerning if the system intervenes in a false positive sense, or where the context is unsuitable, e.g. steering sharply away from a centreline towards the road edge on a narrow road with a soft verge.

An argument could be made that LDW and LKA systems should be considered under ‘safe driving’ rather than collision avoidance and subject to the use of less urgent warnings.

ELK systems are intended to overcome this weakness. By working to detect actual collision threat rather than just lane departure, then it can allow some of the warnings that would occur with LDW to be suppressed, reducing driver annoyance, increasing acceptance and with it, effectiveness. This increased confidence that the situation is an urgent threat means stronger intervention can be taken, further increasing potential effectiveness.

What the Research Shows

LKA and ELK are generally more effective than LDW on its own because they actively intervene on behalf of the driver, rather than just proving a warning.  

A 53% reduction was reported for injurious head-on and single vehicle collisions of M1 vehicles (cars), based on Sternlund et al. (2017). This covers only LDW. LKA can be seen as an extension of LDW and therefore could be expected to be more effective.

A study in the USA (Scharber, 2024) found that LKA equipped vehicles were 24% less likely to be involved in fatal road departure crashes.

Detailed evidence about the performance of collision avoidance systems can be found on Safety Cube DSS. Note that this gives evidence for each system in isolation. There is no evaluation of how the systems work together and interact as a package.

Challenges in Real-World Use

Lane support systems of some kind are now commonplace on nearly all types of new vehicle, except city buses and motorcycles. Vehicle buyers can be reasonably confident in their fitment. However, performance and driver acceptance can vary widely, depending on type and implementation.

Requesting Euro NCAP 5 star ratings should ensure good true positive performance from systems, and the rating is designed to allow manufacturers to implement very good systems (usually involving ELK) that perform very well in true positive situations but also do so without annoying the driver in non-critical situations. There are clear examples of this good practice. However, the rating still offers partial points for simpler systems and relies on manufacturers’ commercial interest in designing systems that do not annoy their customers. There are also many examples of systems that do score points in EuroNCAP but are in fact quite annoying in the real world. These undermine the message that driver assistance systems like this are valuable and effective and risks drivers turning this system off, or more widely turning all such systems off.

There is clear potential for improvement in the standards applied in both regulation and Euro NCAP here, and Euro NCAP is now introducing more in the way of real-world robustness assessments in its 2026 protocol.  

In the meantime, those buying vehicles and those running fleets should try to consider the real-world performance of these systems. Although it is difficult to test them, driver concerns should be listened to, and wherever possible, systems with both good Euro NCAP scores and high driver acceptance should be preferred. Training in how the systems work, and what the benefits are, may also help to avoid drivers simply switching off or ignoring systems.

The sensors used in collision avoidance systems may be damaged if a collision does occur. This might increase the cost of repair. It can also be important to get sensors recalibrated after repairs to ensure the systems still work correctly. For example, cameras powering lane support systems are usually mounted to the inside of the windscreen and can require re-calibration after a windscreen replacement. A chip in the screen in front of the sensor, in an area not usually causing concern, may not be repairable such that a screen replacement is required. Self-calibrating sensors are increasingly common. As the systems become more common in the market, their cost will reduce too.

Global NCAP includes the following systems as ‘must have equipment’ (for immediate application as the minimum safety requirements:

  • Autonomous Emergency Braking (AEB)

  • Speed limitation systems (intelligent speed assistance)

  • Blind Spot Detection

  • Lane Support Systems

Sources

European New Car Assessment Programme (Euro NCAP). (n.d.). Lane support. In The Ratings Explained: Safety Assist. https://www.euroncap.com/en/car-safety/the-ratings-explained/safety-assist/lane-support/

Jänsch, M. (2017). Lane keeping systems. European Road Safety Decision Support System (SafetyCube), European Commission. https://www.roadsafety-dss.eu/assets/data/pdf/synopses/Lane_keeping_systems_28112017.pdf

Scharber, H. (2024). Estimating effectiveness of lane keeping assist systems in fatal road departure crashes (Report No. DOT HS 813 663). National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. https://crashstats.nhtsa.dot.gov/Api/Public/ViewPublication/813663


With thanks to Apollo Vehicle Safety for their contribution to this content.

Apollo Vehicle Safety logo