Historical Developments in Crash Avoidance Technology

Prev Next
This content is currently unavailable in English (UK). You are viewing the default (English) version.

Implications for Delivery

This page provides an overview of the historical developments in crash avoidance technology, particularly focussed on braking systems and their development and adoption. Anti-lock Braking Systems (ABS), traction control, Electronic Stability Control (ESC) and Brake Assist Systems (BAS) provide the background for modern Advanced Emergency Braking (AEB) and Lane Support systems.

This knowledge is important when considering vehicle maintenance, fleet management and how drivers might react to newer systems.

Background

The first collision avoidance technology in vehicles was the brake. From the earliest days of motoring, brakes helped drivers slow down - but early versions offered minimal stopping power. In fact, brakes on all four wheels weren’t introduced until 1909.

By the mid-20th century, braking performance improved significantly. In the 1960s and 70s, brakes became powerful enough to lock the wheels, introducing new challenges. Vehicle dynamics - especially under heavy braking - started to play a major role, particularly for taller or heavily loaded vehicles. Locked wheels can lead to instability:

  • Front wheel lock: eliminates steering control as the tyres can no longer generate sideways force.

  • Rear wheel lock: often causes rigid vehicles to spin and articulated vehicles to jackknife.

  • Trailer wheel lock: leads to trailer swing, where the trailer ‘steps out’, pivoting around the coupling.

The evolution of active systems

To counter these issues, the 1970s saw the introduction of sensor-based systems that adapted braking based on conditions - starting with Anti-lock Braking Systems (ABS). ABS used wheel speed sensors to detect imminent lock-up and modulate brake pressure automatically.

ABS sparked debate over risk compensation - would safer systems simply lead to riskier driving? Over time, evidence supported ABS, and it became mandatory for commercial vehicles in the 1990s and early 2000s. While not mandatory for passenger cars, it is a prerequisite for many newer technologies.

Further developments

The wheel speed sensors used for ABS enabled systems like traction control, which prevents wheelspin by reducing engine power or applying brakes. Adding active braking opened up further possibilities to manage loss of control during cornering or swerving - especially important in preventing high-speed rollovers in taller vehicles.

With new sensors (e.g. steering angle, yaw, lateral acceleration), systems could compare intended and actual paths. By applying brakes to specific wheels, they could:

  • Correct oversteer or understeer.

  • Prevent rollovers in high-sided vehicles.

  • Stabilise articulated vehicles

These systems became known as Electronic Stability Control (ESC) - including both yaw and roll stability functions.

Driver behaviour and brake assist

Despite improved braking systems, research shows most drivers fail to brake at full capacity in emergencies. Many drivers will react fast and apply the brakes quickly but not with maximum force. They will stay at this level for a short while until they get closer to the hazard and realise they are likely to crash. At this point, they then press harder and get to maximum much later than they could have done.

Brake Assist Systems (BAS) were developed to address this, using various methods, including:

  • Non-linear pedal response (more deceleration above certain thresholds).

  • Detection of emergency braking via pedal speed, force, and vehicle speed.

  • Automatic application of full ABS braking when a collision is likely.

This evolved into Brake Assist Plus, which combined brake assist with forward looking sensors so that if the brake was pressed at all by the driver, when the sensors detected an imminent collision, then full ABS braking was applied. This quickly evolved into Advanced Emergency Braking (AEB) where the driver input is no longer required.

AEB has now evolved into one of the building blocks of assisted and automated driving.

Adoption and exceptions

Today, these technologies are standard in most vehicles. Exceptions include:

  • Motorcycles under 125cc, where ABS is not mandatory.

  • Agricultural tractors: although regulations were proposed for tractors able to travel over 50 km/h, before being implemented, they were withdrawn after a more detailed cost benefit analysis.

What the Research Shows

ABS was controversial for a period of time because statistical evidence attempting to measure its casualty reduction effectiveness inconclusive, with early US studies initially showing no significant casualty reduction. This led to discussions around risk compensation. Later, more detailed studies found ABS reduced multi-vehicle collisions but increased single-vehicle run-off-road crashes. This suggested ABS helped avoid one crash type, but drivers were unable to regain control, leading to another.

For motorcycles, the evidence is clearer: ABS significantly improves safety, even though some riders prefer full manual control.

ESC, in contrast, has been widely accepted. It has been very extensively studied both in a track environment and in real world studies and it has been found to be highly effective, preventing approximately 25-75% of fatalities from incidents involving loss of control (depending on study, geographical region and vehicle type). The proportion of articulated HGV rollover incidents declined steadily from 6.4% in 2009 to 3.9% in 2019, consistent with expectations from the implementation of ESC. However, rates have increased again post-COVID for unknown reasons.

Brake Assist evidence is limited, partly because it quickly evolved into AEB, which has a strong evidence base for reducing collisions.

What Next?

In most cases, actions on these technologies are no longer required, other than ensuring they continue to work in-service and managing older vehicles without the technologies out of the fleet. Further information is available on newer Advanced Emergency Braking (AEB) and Lane Support systems.

For motorcycles, and by extension also some new forms of micromobility, further actions may well be justified to ensure these well proven technologies can be fully adopted.

In a Vision Zero context, these technologies are also important for agricultural vehicles. However, overall the casualty numbers affected are much smaller, the specific functions and designs of traditional tractors can create very significant opposition and costs much higher than expected for technology that is relatively cheap and established on other vehicle types.


With thanks to Apollo Vehicle Safety for their contribution to this content.

Apollo Vehicle Safety logo