Implications for Delivery
A safe system approach accepts that humans make mistakes. Vehicles, therefore, should be designed, maintained, and repaired in ways that forgive those mistakes rather than amplify them. By combining smart procurement, robust maintenance, and cross-departmental coordination, practitioners can help ensure vehicles remain not just legally roadworthy, but optimised for safety throughout their operational life. To do this there is a need to:
Move beyond compliance – Maintain safety systems to original performance levels, not just to legal minimums.
Integrate teams – Align safety, maintenance, and insurance functions to support a shared collision-prevention goal.
Anticipate ADAS needs – Invest in training, tools, and partnerships for calibration and repair.
Choose serviceable safety tech – Factor maintainability into procurement.
Work with manufacturers – Advocate for designs that support lifetime functionality of safety systems.
Document and monitor – Keep detailed maintenance records and use them to spot patterns in defects or repairs.
Background
For decades, collision analysis has shown that human behaviour is the dominant sharp-end contributory factor in crashes, followed by environmental and vehicle-related factors. Some studies assign percentages to these - human factors contributing in around 90% of cases, environmental in 20%, and vehicle-related in 10% - recognising that many crashes involve more than one contributory element.
When researchers identify a single “critical reason” for a collision - the last failure in the chain leading to the crash - vehicle technical defects appear rarely. In a major US study, they accounted for just 2% of collisions. However, this statistic hides important limitations:
In-depth investigations that could reveal technical defects are often only carried out for fatal collisions.
Collision damage can destroy the evidence of a defect.
Data recording has historically focused on blame, meaning design issues that amplify risks (such as poor handling characteristics) often go unrecorded.
Modern technology adds further complexity. If a driver fails to spot a hazard and the vehicle’s advanced driver assistance systems (ADAS) also fail, the crash is still often recorded as a driver error - even if a functioning system could have prevented it.
Why This Matters Now
The growing integration of safety technology such as Intelligent Speed Assistance (ISA) and Autonomous Emergency Braking (AEB) changes the balance of responsibility between driver and vehicle. It also changes how roadworthiness must be thought about in practice.
Fleets, manufacturers, and repairers need to ensure these systems work effectively throughout the life of the vehicle—not just when it’s new. A focus solely on legal compliance is no longer enough; the aim should be to maintain the vehicle’s designed safety performance for as long as it is in service.
Good Practice Foundations
The UK’s DVSA Guide to Maintaining Roadworthiness remains a strong reference point, covering established practices such as:
First-use inspections for new, hired, or stored vehicles.
Daily walkaround checks carried out by drivers.
Periodic technical inspections by qualified technicians.
Management systems to ensure timely, high-standard servicing.
Prompt repairs when problems are found.
Quality checks before vehicles return to service.
Detailed record keeping of all inspections, repairs, and services.
Role-specific training for drivers, mechanics, and managers.
A well-documented, systematic maintenance programme is more important than which exact guidance document you follow.
Specific Challenges with ADAS
Advanced driver assistance systems bring additional maintenance and repair requirements that fleets and repairers must anticipate:
Sensor calibration may be required after windscreen replacements, minor collisions, or even certain bumper repairs.
Specialist glazing may be needed for systems with cameras or head-up displays.
Restrictions on repairs near sensor locations can increase costs.
Hidden faults – Diagnostic scans can reveal trouble codes not shown on dashboard warning lights, such as temporary sensor misalignment.
Limited MOT checks – Annual tests may only confirm that dashboard warning lights function, not that systems are performing optimally.
These requirements demand:
Skilled technicians with specialist training.
Access to appropriate diagnostic tools.
Coordination between bodyshops, glass repairers, and fleet managers to maintain ADAS functionality.
Cost and Organisational Implications
ADAS can reduce crash frequency, but it often increases repair costs when crashes do occur. For large fleets, responsibilities for safety, maintenance, and insurance are often split between departments with different KPIs. This can lead to:
Safety teams valuing ADAS for reducing incidents.
Maintenance teams concerned about rising repair costs.
Insurance teams weighing reduced frequency against increased claim severity.
A safe system approach requires breaking down these silos. Purchasing, maintenance, and operational decision-making should be aligned so that:
Maintenance teams are equipped and resourced to look after new technology.
Safety teams understand the maintenance requirements of the systems they rely on.
Purchasing decisions factor in both safety performance and maintainability over the vehicle’s lifecycle.
Linking Design, Maintenance and Manufacturer Engagement
Preventing collisions isn’t just about maintaining vehicles well - it’s also about choosing and influencing vehicle design:
Select vehicles where critical safety systems are robust, easy to maintain, and tolerant to minor repairs.
Engage with manufacturers to improve serviceability, for example by developing self-calibrating sensors or designs that allow minor repairs without affecting safety systems.
Include maintainability as a formal criterion in vehicle procurement alongside safety ratings such as Euro NCAP.
Evidence and Data Gaps
The link between maintenance regimes and collision prevention is widely accepted but not strongly evidenced in published research. Challenges include:
Inconsistent or limited crash investigation data.
Few large-scale studies directly comparing maintenance regimes.
Commercial reluctance to share fleet collision and maintenance data.
While the statistical case may be incomplete, the practical case is strong - defects do cause collisions, and robust maintenance does reduce defects.
Sources
Cuerden, R. W., Edwards, M. J., & Pittman, M. B. (2011). Effect of vehicle defects in road accidents (Project Report No. PPR565). Transport Research Laboratory. https://www.trl.co.uk/uploads/trl/documents/PPR565.pdf
Driver and Vehicle Standards Agency. (2025). Guide to maintaining roadworthiness: Commercial goods and passenger carrying vehicles. GOV.UK. https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/guide-to-maintaining-roadworthiness/guide-to-maintaining-roadworthiness-commercial-goods-and-passenger-carrying-vehicles
Insurance Institute for Highway Safety & Highway Loss Data Institute. (2025). Crash avoidance technologies: Real-world benefits. https://www.iihs.org/media/290e24fd-a8ab-4f07-9d92-737b909a4b5e/_mTwzA/Topics/ADVANCED%20DRIVER%20ASSISTANCE/IIHS-HLDI-CA-benefits.pdf
Knight, I., & Avery, M. (2015). Autonomous emergency braking (AEB): Fitment, performance and implications for accident investigation. In Proceedings of the 24th EVU Conference (Edinburgh, Scotland). European Association for Accident Research and Analysis (EVU). https://www.evu-online.org/autonomous-emergency-braking-aeb-fitment-performanceand-implications-for-accident-investigation
Rechnitzer, G., Haworth, N., & Kowadlo, N. (2000). The effect of vehicle roadworthiness on crash incidence and severity (Report No. 164). Monash University Accident Research Centre. https://www.monash.edu/__data/assets/pdf_file/0017/216710/The-effect-of-vehicle-roadworthiness-on-crash-incidence-and-severity.pdf
Singh, S. (2015). Critical reasons for crashes investigated in the National Motor Vehicle Crash Causation Survey (Traffic Safety Facts: Crash•Stats Report No. DOT HS 812 115). Washington, DC: National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. https://crashstats.nhtsa.dot.gov/Api/Public/ViewPublication/812115
With thanks to Apollo Vehicle Safety for their contribution to this content.
