Implications for Delivery
Monitoring technology, such as seat belt reminders, child presence detection and driver status monitoring (e.g. fatigue or distraction), offers considerable safety benefits. While practitioners are unlikely to be able to influence the development of this technology, there are opportunities to:
Support and monitor rollout of driver monitoring systems: With driver inattention a major crash factor and EU regulations requiring driver monitoring in all new vehicles by 2026, practitioners should prepare for widespread adoption. They should promote integration with fleet management systems to enable early, non-punitive interventions and track behavioural trends (e.g. fatigue or distraction).
Enhance public and fleet engagement with seat belt and child detection technology: Seat belt reminders are highly effective in increasing usage rates, especially when compliant with Euro NCAP standards. Practitioners should also raise awareness about child presence detection technology and support adoption in high-risk environments, despite low current market penetration.
Advocate for integration of occupant monitoring with other safety systems: Driver status information can enhance ADAS (e.g. enabling earlier AEB intervention if a driver is inattentive), improving both safety outcomes and user acceptance. Practitioners should encourage ongoing research and industry collaboration to maximise this integration.
Background
There are a variety of in-vehicle systems which monitor the behaviour of occupants.
Seat Belt Reminders
Seat belts are widely acknowledged as the single biggest step forward in road safety history. Belt wearing rates are high but those that don’t wear belts are much more likely to appear in fatality statistics. Seat belt reminders are the simplest form of occupant monitoring; they identify if users are present by measuring weight on a seat, and warn the driver if they move the vehicle without the belt being fastened. They are mandatory on all new vehicles where seat belts are fitted.
Child Presence Detection
Children can become seriously ill or even die if left unattended in hot vehicles. Leaving a window a little open does little to help, and temperatures can become dangerously high in as little as 15 minutes, especially if in the sun. Children cannot exit the vehicle on their own and have a low tolerance for high temperatures. There are new technologies entering the market to detect the presence of an unattended child and alert their carer or emergency services.
There are different types of system: indirect sensing systems and direct systems. The former use logic based on door opening switches and pressure sensing in seats to identify that there is ‘potentially’ a person still in the car. Direct systems use cameras and/or radar, ultrasonic, or lidar sensors in the interior to try to identify movement, respiration, or heartbeat inside the vehicle to more confidently identify presence.
Depending on confidence in the assessment of presence, the system may use escalating warnings from messages to the driver’s mobile phone, to externally audible alarms, through to automatically calling the emergency services.
Driver status monitoring
The inattention of drivers is one of the major factors contributing to the causes of collisions. It may be caused by impairment (e.g. fatigue, medical problems, alcohol, drugs) or distraction (e.g. infotainment system, mobile phones, passengers, people or objects outside the vehicles, or even just internal thoughts and preoccupation). For more information on road user behaviour see Safe Road Use.
Driver status monitoring can take different forms. Some systems (often described as ‘indirect’), and typically used to detect fatigue, involve the measurement of driving behaviours like pedal or steering input and road position to identify that you might be tired. More sophisticated systems are intended to identify a wider range of inattention, covering impairment and distraction. These use driver-facing cameras, in combination with indirect measurements, to identify issues. They are often described as an advanced driver distraction warning (ADDW), or direct driver monitoring.
As with many advanced driver assistance systems (ADAS), there are technical challenges with driver monitoring around false positives and also false negatives (e.g. systems may find it harder to detect fatigue if drivers wear dark glasses and detection rates are not always the same for every demographic of driver).
Once the system detects a driver is inattentive then there are more options around what is done with the information:
In-vehicle warnings to driver – may be visual to begin with but escalating with continuing inattention.
Fleet management information to operator – monitoring patterns over time and enabling ‘soft’ interventions with drivers (identifying health issues or personal problems outside work, for example)
‘Safe stop’ – specifically for medical emergencies in the moment, this brings the vehicle to a progressive safe stop in the lane when drivers are completely unresponsive.
Integration with ADAS: For example, one of the biggest factors limiting the effectiveness of autonomous emergency braking (AEB) is that the system can’t intervene at a time when the driver may still comfortably steer around a hazard. However, if you know the driver is inattentive and is unlikely to respond, then you can intervene earlier. This makes high speed collisions much more avoidable, but it also means some lower speed collisions that are avoidable with standard AEB, can be avoided with more gentle braking. This is particularly attractive in buses where passengers either stand or are seated without restraints.
Indirect driver monitoring has been in some vehicles for many years and became mandatory in all new vehicles in the EU from 2024. Euro NCAP started incentivising direct driver monitoring (impairment and distraction) in passenger cars from 2024 and it will become mandatory for all new vehicles in 2026. Systems covered by those interventions are only required to produce in-vehicle driver warnings. In 2026, Euro NCAP will start incentivising systems that will also improve AEB performance if an imminent collision is detected while the driver is inattentive.
What the Research Shows
Both US and Swedish studies have found seat belt reminders to be effective for drivers who sometimes don’t wear a belt. However, there were considered less likely to be effective for ‘hard core’ users who actively object to wearing a belt. The Swedish study found that without belt reminders, belt usage rate was around 82% - this increased to 93% with a ‘mild’ reminder system and to 99% where reminders were in compliance with Euro NCAP criteria.
Euro NCAP is assessing the performance of vehicles fitted with Child Presence Detection. The total number of casualties in this circumstance is low and not tracked explicitly in Europe. In the USA, there were 40 deaths in 2024 (for comparison, in 2023, there were 40,901 fatalities from road collisions in the USA). There was also considerable annual variation. Although fitment on new vehicles has recently increased a lot thanks to Euro NCAP, penetration of those new vehicles into the fleet as a whole remains low. As a result, it is very difficult to assess effectiveness at this time.
For driver monitoring systems, some simulator studies in Italy have suggested that in-cab warnings are effective at reducing the impact of distraction for passenger car drivers in motorway contexts (but not in urban environments). Transport for London are trialling direct driver monitoring, primarily as a measure aimed at addressing fatigue. Emerging evidence from that trial suggests there are benefits in the urban environment from both in-cab warnings and from soft interventions enabled by the analysis of data and individual events transmitted via telematics to fleet managers.
Systems remain too new for statistical measures of casualty reduction effectiveness. However, although estimates vary widely, inattention is widely acknowledged as a contributory factor in a significant proportion of all death and serious injury, so the potential benefit in the long term, and with more sophisticated interventions, is high.
Market Availability
For passenger cars, Regulations and Euro NCAP combine to ensure that all vehicles will have seat belt reminders and driver monitoring available. Most systems will be fitted as standard and be of higher than minimum standard, particularly if buyers favour vehicles with at least 4 stars (ideally 5). Child presence detection will also be captured in requirements for high Euro NCAP scores.
For commercial vehicles, progress is lagging cars by a few years. Availability of advanced direct driver monitoring remains limited on new vehicles but will ramp up quickly as the mandatory deadline approaches in 2026. Aftermarket systems are available and are considered by many fleets to be highly effective, though no independent quality rating is available, so buyers need to be careful to ensure good implementation in their vehicles.
For fleets of any vehicles, the emphasis shouldn’t be purely on in-cab warnings. Fleet management should include fatigue management plans and driver welfare support. Not all manufacturers may be willing to provide data via telematics due to privacy concerns and the system itself is not permitted by law to identify drivers through facial recognition. This requires commitment from operators to implement parallel systems and invest time in analysing data and designing suitable interventions and management.
Research is required to monitor the effectiveness of the systems as they increase market penetration and to seek continuous improvement.
The potential for driver status information to be incorporated into all ADAS and assist driving systems is large. It could improve both effectiveness, and very importantly, driver acceptance of those other systems, reducing the extent to which warnings are ignored or systems switched off. Actions to help quantify the benefits, safely develop the technology, and incentivise it should be a high priority.
Sources
Bassani, M., Catani, L., Hazoor, A., Hoxha, A., Lioi, A., Portera, A., & Tefa, L. (2023). Do driver monitoring technologies improve the driving behaviour of distracted drivers? A simulation study to assess the impact of an auditory driver distraction warning device on driving performance. Transportation Research Part F: Traffic Psychology and Behaviour, 95, 239-250. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.trf.2023.04.013
Child Presence Detection. (n.d.). Global harmonized surrogate child dummies for evaluating and verifying child presence detection systems. https://www.child-presence-detection.org/
European Commission. (n.d.). Seat belt reminders. European Road Safety Observatory. https://road-safety.transport.ec.europa.eu/european-road-safety-observatory/statistics-and-analysis-archive/esafety/seat-belt-reminders_en
Euro NCAP. (n.d.). Child occupant protection. https://www.euroncap.com/en/car-safety/the-ratings-explained/child-occupant-protection/
Kids and Car Safety. (2025). U.S. child hot car deaths data analysis (1990-2024). https://www.kidsandcars.org/document_center/download/hot-cars/Child-Hot-Car-Deaths-Data-Analysis.pdf
ResearchAndMarkets. (2024). Child presence detection system market – global industry report 2019-2029 featuring Continental, Robert Bosch, Denso, ZF Friedrichshafen, Magna International, Valeo, IEE, and Visteon. GlobeNewswire. https://www.globenewswire.com/news-release/2024/09/03/2939853/28124/en/Child-Presence-Detection-System-Market-Global-Industry-Report-2019-2029-Featuring-Continental-Robert-Bosch-Denso-ZF-Friedrichshafen-Magna-International-Valeo-IEE-and-Visteon.html
With thanks to Apollo Vehicle Safety for their contribution to this content.
