Deployment of Effective Technologies

Prev Next
This content is currently unavailable in English (UK). You are viewing the default (English) version.

Implications for Delivery

The effective deployment of speed enforcement is considered to be poorly understood, certainly within the context of a defined strategy. There has been no evaluation of different deployment strategies, although there is good evidence of the impact of different technologies.

There are clear and obvious advantages of different technologies, as well as different costs of operation. It would therefore seem reasonable that any national programme or strategy would include a mix of different technologies according to the requirements at specific locations.

First of all it is worth noting that there is little evidence on the effectiveness of covert enforcement. It would have a part to play in the detection of offences and subsequent penalties and endorsements, which itself is known to deter offending rates, but there is no evidence on the metrics relating to casualty reduction or vehicle speeds.

Mobile enforcement demonstrates variable impacts on speeds and casualties but has other benefits when undertaken in a conspicuous manner. Community assurance and acting as a reminder to motorists that enforcement may take place away from fixed sites is considered beneficial, even if there is no evidence on how this is impacted in terms of casualties and speeds across a wider area. The evidence on the short-term impact of mobile enforcement is the clearest evidence as to its effectiveness in reducing speeds and therefore casualties. This does not mean that there is no impact, but that consideration should be given to further research in this areas.

Finally it is clear that fixed cameras are the most powerful solution available to reduce speed and collisions, especially those that influence speeds over longer stretches of road (e.g. average speed cameras). Interestingly, there is evidence that suggests that these cameras do not need to be operational for significant periods of time, merely their presence is enough to change behaviour.

Background

There are a variety of ways in which manual and automated speed-detection technologies can be used to measure speeds and support education and enforcement programmes. How these technologies are deployed in an enforcement programme is the key focus of this element, rather than the description of the technologies themselves.

Manual enforcement technologies are those that require the operator, which should be a trained individual (usually a police officer), to measure the speed of a vehicle and issue a warning or notice at the roadside. The operator would select a vehicle, and following the appropriate guidelines, use the equipment to create an observation which will then be used to justify the stopping of the vehicle with a decision made at the time as to further action. This may be a warning, notice of intended prosecution, or summons to court. These are known as 'roadside checks'.

Automated technologies do not require the vehicle to be stopped, with data passed to a back-office system for viewing and a further decision on action to be taken.

Both manual and automated methods can play a part in a speed management programme and their impacts on speed management and casualty reduction will vary. The critical questions are therefore likely to arise around the effectiveness of various methods in achieving specified objectives, together with the costs associated with the detection and processing of offences.

The deployment of enforcement technologies can be undertaken through national programmes with specified rules, or more local schemes managed by individual police forces or areas. Presently, Local Authorities have no powers to undertake speed enforcement themselves.

The evidence suggests that permanent speed camera installations have the greatest impact on vehicles speeds and casualty reduction. It would therefore be expected that these technologies, which often incur the greatest costs to deploy, would be strategically used on roads where there are already high-casualty rates, or where high speeds are present which indicate elevated risk.

Temporary enforcement solutions have a number of potential uses. Firstly to deter and detect speeding on roads that may only require enforcement associated with specific events, or at times of elevated risk. This could include seasonal deployment as well as one-off deployments associated with car cruises for example. Mobile cameras can also help to increase the spatial deployment across larger road networks with many locations being served by a single piece of equipment. Mobile enforcement is also suitable in places where fixed cameras can’t be installed for logistical reasons including lack of power or space.

The temporal activation of both fixed and mobile technologies can also become part of an effective strategy. Fixed cameras, when appearing to be operative, have a permanent impact on vehicle speeds. This indicates that the physical presence of the equipment is deterrent enough without the need for it to be operationally activated. Mobile units are likely to have the greatest influence on speeds when they are in-situ, and this means that their presence should be aligned with times of greatest non-compliance.

Covert, or unmarked enforcement using automated technologies is used infrequently in Scotland, and indeed elsewhere in Great Britain. Northamptonshire Police in England have deployed a small number of ‘grey’ vans in recent years although there is little evidence on how this fits within a specific action plan, nor whether there is any analysis of their effectiveness at specific locations or across the county.

Ad-hoc enforcement by police officers from roads policing or local units may take place at any time or at any location. This may not form part of a specific plan or strategy and reflects the police’s duty to enforcement crime and support communities.

What the Research Shows

As discussed in ‘Enforcement Programmes’, “The national safety camera programme Four-year evaluation report” showed that:

  • Vehicle speeds were down by around 7% following the introduction of cameras.

  • At new sites, there was a 32% reduction in vehicles breaking the speed limit.

  • At fixed sites, there was a 71% reduction

  • At mobile sites there was a 21% reduction.

  • There was a 33% reduction in personal injury collisions (PICs) at sites where cameras were introduced.

  • For those killed or seriously injured, there was a 40% reduction.

However, there is limited evidence on the effectiveness of specific deployment strategies or the efficacy relating to individual technologies.

The paper “Speed cameras to reduce speeding traffic and road traffic injuries” by Rebecca Steinbach et al in 2016 reviewed international research into the impacts of speed enforcement. This compared different technologies including fixed vs mobile, overt vs covert, and rural vs urban. There were various categories of analysis including changes in average speeds, those exceeding the speed limit, all collisions, injury collisions, and higher severity collisions. Many sets of results were produced and in summary the following observations were made:

Covert enforcement has limited impact, although one study in Australia did note a reduction in collisions.

There were mixed results on the effectiveness of mobile speed cameras. In the largest comparison group, which used evidence on changes in the percentage of vehicles exceeding the limit, there were some studies illustrating a significant change, and other where none was observed. Casualty reduction at these locations does appear to be effective, although with varying results.

Fixed camera enforcement frequently and consistently demonstrates speed and casualty reduction, although there are no significant differences in casualty reduction between fixed and mobile cameras.

The report also considered urban and rural setting which showed that speed enforcement is equally successful in reducing speeds in both settings.

The paper then investigated the ‘halo’ effect of fixed cameras showing that there is a diminishing impact on speeds and casualties away from the location of the enforcement technology.

A paper commissioned by the Thames Valley Safer Roads Partnership in 2005, written by Damian Poulter and Prof Frank McKenna (University of Reading) investigated temporal and spatial impacts of technology deployment. It demonstrated that the halo effect is present for fixed and mobile speed cameras, even at a relatively short distance of 300m. This analysis was the same for feedback devices (roadside signs). This report further investigated the impact of temporary measures on speeds in the days after deployment. The report showed that there was no long-term impact on vehicle speeds once the technology was no longer in place by the roadside. The report also demonstrated that even when not in use, a fixed speed camera will still have an impact on vehicles speeds a long time after it was last used.

Finally, the paper “Effectiveness of a fixed speed camera traffic enforcement system in a developing country” by Shaaban et al. in 2023 found that there is no clear effect on speeds along road corridors where enforcement is widely-spaced.

Sources

Job, S., Cliff, D, Fleiter, J.J., Flieger, M., & Harman, B. (2020). Guide for Determining Readiness for Speed Cameras and Other Automated Enforcement. Global Road Safety Facility and the Global Road Safety Partnership, Geneva, Switzerland. https://www.globalroadsafetyfacility.org/sites/default/files/2023-10/Guide%20for%20Determining%20Readiness%20for%20Speed%20Cameras%20and%20Other%20Automated%20Enforcement.pdf

Poulter, D. & McKenna, F. (2005) Thames Valley Safer Roads Partnership Research Report into Effects of Enforcement on Vehicle Speeds. https://www.roadsafetyknowledgecentre.org.uk/thames-valley-safer-roads-partnership-research-report-into-effects-of-enforcement-on-vehicle-speeds/

Shaaban, K., Mohammad, A., & Eleimat, A. (2023). Effectiveness of a fixed speed camera traffic enforcement system in a developing country. Ain Shams engineering journal, 14(10), 102154. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.asej.2023.102154

Steinbach, R., Perkins, C., Edwards, P., Beecher, D., & Roberts, I. (2016). Speed Cameras to Reduce Speeding Traffic and Road Traffic Injuries.(What Works: Crime reduction systematic review series No 8). https://library.college.police.uk/docs/what-works/SR8-Speed-Cameras-2017.pdf