Implications for Delivery
The benefits of speed reduction achieved through enforcement are clear and undisputable. Any country or region wishing to progress towards a Safe System would therefore need to adopt a proportional, evidence-led programme to achieve high levels of compliance with speed limits. Enforcement is not the only means of achieving compliance with speed limits however and the public should be supportive of any scheme.
Key points:
Permanent safety cameras, and especially average speed cameras offer the greatest long-term casualty reductions.
Highlight visible enforcement together with warning signs and published locations clearly signal schemes as being casualty-led.
Appropriate funding mechanisms and rules to management of a programme offer clear guidelines for those delivering the scheme, as well as transparency for the public.
Enforcement should be considered within the wider speed management programme with a toolbox of measures available to road authorities and the police to achieve compliance and support communities.
It is worth a final note to say that enforcement programmes have been in place for several decades, backed by technology advances, and there may need to be ongoing analysis and evaluation of effectiveness both in terms of casualty reduction and value for money.
Background
A speed enforcement programme is a part of a wider speed management programme which will be backed by legislation, guidance, education and awareness schemes, engineering measures and other elements of a systematic response. We therefore first need to consider the wider elements before focussing on enforcement activities specifically.
The relevant legislation allowing the enforcement of speed limits is The Road Traffic Regulation Act 1984. It makes it illegal to drive a motor vehicle on a road at a speed exceeding a legally imposed limit. The treatment of offences (sometimes referred to as disposals) including licence endorsements and speed thresholds are covered by sentencing guidelines from The Scottish Sentencing Council. There are further parts of legislation that refer to the legal processes for drivers to respond to notices of intended prosecution, the approvals process for enforcement equipment, and indeed the whole driver licencing and endorsement system but these do not warrant specific discussion here; other than to note that legislation is a key enabler of an enforcement programme.
The next enabler of an enforcement programme are policies, guidelines and advice notes on how activities and programmes may be managed. In Scotland the key reference is the Scottish Safety Camera Programme Handbook of Rules and Guidance, last published in 2022. This Handbook sets out the rules and guidance to enable the Scottish Safety Camera Programme to contribute to Scotland’s road safety targets, and to which the Programme must operate. This does not constitute legislation and is not enforceable but clearly sets out, for the primary benefit of those working within the scheme, the intentions and operational procedures that must be followed. This level of public transparency is important in delivering a programme that has the support of the public as well as leaders.
Within the current Programme Handbook there are sections relating to governance, accountability, management and operational plans which give clear instructions to those working within the scheme. There are other sections covering the guidelines and rules on where cameras can be placed, what site selection criteria are used, plus how well-signed end visible enforcement cameras must be. This level of oversight and transparency is again essential when carrying out a programme that is specifically targeting casualty reduction.
None of these guidelines impact the ability of the police to carry out non-programme related enforcement. This may be ad-hoc enforcement related to a specific event or situation, enforcement carried out as a part of routine police patrols, or even covert operations. Where a casualty-led programme is highly-visible and a key policy measure, the separation of these two types of enforcement activity should be made very clear.
It is worth noting that in England there are no rules or handbook for casualty-led enforcement operations, although Road Circular 01/2007, “Use of speed and redlight cameras for traffic enforcement : Guidance on deployment, visibility and signing”, does cover elements that are included within the Scottish Handbook.
The Handbook for Scotland is important because it clearly delineates the activities covered under the scheme, and for which funding is provided through the hypothecation of fine income. This means that it is not the only mechanism by which enforcement or other speed management can be managed. A wider speed management framework will include an enforcement programme but may also consider other measures. Examples of this would include Community Speedwatch, an unofficial scheme that is nevertheless supported by several police forces, which empowers local communities to detect speeding drivers, and typically results in a warning letter being issued to the registered keeper. Other examples of ‘softer’ measures would include vehicle activated signs to simply warn drivers of their speed and encourage a change in behaviour. A further step down are poster schemes and static signs or notices. Understanding what treatment is required for different severities of speeding problem should be clear to road authorities, the police, public, and elected officials.
What the Research Shows
There has been significant evidence undertaken globally on the value of reducing vehicle speeds, which is not considered here. The evaluation of enforcement programmes was subject to significant scrutiny in Great Britain following the launch of the National Safety Camera Programme in 2001, leading to the publication of, “The national safety camera programme Four-year evaluation report” in 2005. Headline figures from this report showed that:
Vehicle speeds were down by around 7% following the introduction of cameras.
At new sites, there was a 32% reduction in vehicles breaking the speed limit.
At fixed sites, there was a 71% reduction
At mobile sites there was a 21% reduction.
There was a 33% reduction in personal injury collisions (PICs) at sites where cameras were introduced.
For those killed or seriously injured, there was a 40% reduction.
There have also been separate evaluations of specific camera technologies that are associated with enforcement programmes. Two notable publications were released by the RAC Foundation in 2010 and 2016; the former estimated that around 1,000 fewer people had been killed or seriously injured in 2004 due to the presence of speed cameras which were largely introduced as a result of the Programme; and in 2016 a report reviewing the long-term impact of average speed cameras showed up to a 46% reduction in fatal and serious collisions.
A Cochrane systematic review of international evidence in 2010 found that, “in the vicinity of camera sites, the pre/post reductions ranged from 8% to 49% for all crashes and 11% to 44% for fatal and serious injury crashes. Compared with controls, the relative improvement in pre/post injury crash proportions ranged from 8% to 50%.”
Although an annual report is published each year reviewing the operations of the Scottish Safety Camera Programme, information is not included on casualty or speed reduction associated with the scheme so it is not possible to say what specific casualty benefits have been associated with this specific programme.
Sources
Allsop, R. (2010). The effectiveness of speed cameras: A review of evidence [PDF]. RAC Foundation. Retrieved from https://www.racfoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/efficacy_of_speed_cameras_allsop_181110.pdf
Department for Transport. (2007). Use of speed and red-light cameras for traffic enforcement: Guidance on deployment, visibility and signing. https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/use-of-speed-and-red-light-cameras-for-traffic-enforcement-guidance-on-deployment-visibility-and-signing
Gains, A., Heydecker, B. G., Nordstrom, M., Shrewsbury, J., & Robertson, S. (2004). The national safety camera programme: Three-year evaluation report [Open access version]. UCL Discovery. https://discovery.ucl.ac.uk/id/eprint/1338/.
Owen, R., Ursachi, G. & Allsop, R. (2016) The Effectiveness of Average Speed Cameras in Great Britain. London: RAC Foundation. https://www.racfoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/11/Average_speed_camera_effectiveness_Owen_Ursachi_Allsop_September_2016.pdf
Transport Scotland. (2022). Scottish Safety Camera Programme: Handbook of rules and guidance. https://www.transport.gov.scot/media/51339/scottish-safety-camera-programme-handbook.pdf
UK Parliament. (1984). Road Traffic Regulation Act 1984, c. 27. https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1984/27/contents
Wilson, C., Willis, C., Hendrikz, J. K., Le Brocque, R., & Bellamy, N. (2010). Speed cameras for the prevention of road traffic injuries and deaths. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, (10), Article CD004607. https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD004607.pub3