Enabling Environments for Change

Prev Next
This content is currently unavailable in English (UK). You are viewing the default (English) version.

Implications for Delivery

We may all feel different about change – some of us love it and some of us prefer things to remain the way they are. However, the status quo is a road transport system that still generates thousands of injuries each year, so we must conclude that there is a need for change. Change can be hard to bring about but there is much we can do to create an enabling environment for change:

  • Question current practice – be willing to step back and question whether our current ways are delivering the best outcomes; be willing to engage with meaningful debate about how we might be able to achieve more.

  • Lean into the vision – spend time thinking about the implications of a vision for a road transport system where no-one is killed or seriously injured. How does that vision change our priorities?

  • Connect widely – big projects will necessitate lots of support from colleagues and stakeholders across multiple sectors. The answers for some of the challenges we face in delivering a Safe System probably requires skills and expertise that we haven’t identified yet.

  • Facilitate innovation – creating opportunities for new ideas and fresh practice to emerge might be about finding ways to let others get involved. Can we create the environment that will enable others to bring about change?

Background

The Safe System assumes that change is necessary. The current way our road network operates is continuing to cause an unacceptable level of harm, which has further negative impacts in terms of people choosing to avoid walking and cycling, or even going out at all because of safety fears. Recognising that change is necessary is an important step, but we must follow this up by creating the kind of environment in which change can happen.

Scotland’s road safety framework is clear that the status quo is both ‘unacceptable’ and ‘unethical’ as it makes the case for a long-term goal of zero deaths and serious injuries. Recent studies (such as Truong et al. 2022) have made the case for considering an idealised end state (an ‘Ultimate Safe System’) and then then asking, ‘what will we need to do to get there?’

The good news is that we do not need to wait for fully autonomous vehicles, the range of technical and policy measures we already have, will allow us to get close to zero road fatalities. The challenge is that delivering these may not be universally popular and we are likely to experience significant pushback against some of the measures required. This means that we will need fresh thinking!

Innovation has long been seen as an important element of the Safe System, helping to deliver breakthrough technologies in vehicles, such as seatbelts and airbags, as well as transformational infrastructure like roadside barriers, segregated cycle paths and puffin crossings.

So, achieving our ambitious goal, will not only require widespread acceptance that road traffic injury is avoidable, but it will also demand new technologies and ways of working that will move us towards Vision Zero.

What the Research Shows

Challenge the status quo

In their fascinating work on Motonormativity, Ian Walker, Alan Tapp & Adrian Davies demonstrate that our attitudes towards the place of the private motor vehicle have become so normalised in society that we often don’t question whether we could do things differently. We tolerate levels of harm and disruption from cars that we wouldn’t permit from anything else, because we are biased towards accepting things being the way we know: the stats quo.

This bias towards maintaining the status quo is often a significant barrier to change. It might explain why we get such strong resistance to 20mph limits, electric vehicles or congestion charging.

Recognising this bias is key to challenging it. Organisations need to be willing to embrace different perspectives, ask challenging questions and accept that our current practice is probably not the best that we could achieve.

Create an ambitious atmosphere

We should never underestimate the change that can be brought about by a compelling vision. When US President, John F. Kennedy declared ‘We choose to go to the moon’, he redefined the ambition for whole sectors of industry and the expectations of the American people. And this was also a SMART objective, because the ambition was to achieve this ‘by the end of the decade’.

This ambition creates momentum, bringing stakeholders together with a shared vision for a different future, but it also reveals the scale of change that will be required.

Collaborate for shared strategy

Big ideas like going to the moon or the Safe System, cannot be delivered in isolation. When the Swedish Government first embraced the idea of Vision Zero, the recognised that they would need significant help from others to make progress. The concept of the triple-helix – three strands of government, academia and industry would be required to provide sufficient expertise, innovation and scale of delivery to match their ambition. It would only be right to extend the second strand to include other civil society organisations that advocate for change, produce valuable research and invest in policy development which make a great contribution. We often make the mistake of regarding the private sector as being too competitive to collaborate, but examples abound of where industrial competitors will willingly cooperate on something as critical as safety.

Public sector bodies and their partner charities are uniquely placed to support this collaborative effort because of their convening power. Bringing organisations together, laying out the challenge and creating the context for collaboration will mobilise many to participate and contribute to workshops, roundtables, hackathons and funded innovation programmes.

Craft the meaningful market

Renowned economist Mariana Mazzucato points to the key role that public sector actors have played in driving radical innovations in their early stages. Perhaps even more important is creating the market conditions that will allow private enterprise to innovate because there is a valuable market to be addressed. This doesn’t necessarily mean acting as the end consumer for goods or services, but ensuring that opportunities to experiment, develop and scale solutions will be supported.

Access to public data, partnering for on-road trials, deregulating to facilitate emerging technology or regulating for better safety outcomes leveraging public procurement or funding innovation competitions are all ways in which market conditions can be tweaked so that great ideas can flourish.

Sources

Björnberg, K. E., Belin, M. Å., Hansson, S. O., & Tingvall, C. (2019). The vision zero handbook (pp. 1–1240). Cham, Switzerland: Springer International Publishing. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-76505-7

Campsall, D. (2022) The Enabling Environment. https://agilysis.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/sites/25/2022/08/The-Enabling-Environment.pdf

Campsall, D., Khatri, D., Fosdick, T., & Scott, S. (2024) The Safe System Cultural Maturity Playbook, Banbury: Agilysis Ltd. https://framework.roadsafety.scot/wp-content/uploads/2024/09/Culture-Playbook-v1.1-3.pdf

Mazzucato, M. (2011). The entrepreneurial state. Soundings, 49(49), 131–142. https://doi.org/10.3898/136266211798411183

Truong, J., Strandroth, J., Logan, D. B., Job, R. S., & Newstead, S. (2022). Utilising human crash tolerance to design an Interim and Ultimate Safe System for road safety. Sustainability, 14(6), 3491. https://doi.org/10.3390/su14063491

Walker, I., Tapp, A., & Davis, A. (2023). Motonormativity: How social norms hide a major public health hazard. International Journal of Environment and Health, 11(1), 21-33. https://doi.org/10.1504/IJENVH.2023.135446