Enforcement Strategy

Prev Next
This content is currently unavailable in English (UK). You are viewing the default (English) version.

Implications for Delivery

There are many factors which influence enforcement strategies. The type of enforcement which takes place is dependent on the type of issue which is being targeted: if there is a specific casualty problem or high level of offending at a particular location, then visible automated enforcement is likely to be most appropriate. If there is a more widespread non-compliance issue, roadside checks (either covert or visible) can take place.

It is therefore important to consider factors related to the enforcement methods, visibility, site selection, and equipment type when building an enforcement strategy.

Communications are an important part of all enforcement strategies. Communicating with the public and explaining why enforcement is taking place helps to increase acceptability amongst road users and also increases feelings amongst offenders that they are likely to be caught if they are breaking traffic law.

Background

There are several factors which influence roads policing enforcement strategies:

  • Enforcement method: Roadside checks (where a police officer stops an offender at the time of the offence) or safety cameras (where a mobile or fixed camera is used to detect an offence, is processed and then a fine and Fixed Penalty Notice is sent by post).

  • Visibility: Safety cameras are usually visible in the UK, either as fixed yellow camera housings or in liveried vans or other vehicles. Roadside checks are often conducted by specialist roads policing or traffic officers and they usually operate from marked police vehicles, but can also conduct covert operations, using a variety of vehicles.

  • Site selection: Safety camera sites are usually pre-selected, based on set criteria related to casualty and speed history. These sites are often published and signed so the public know where this type of enforcement is taking place. Roadside checks can be conducted at locations across the road network, without signage or prior warning. Selecting where to enforce from will be based on intelligence of where offences occur; officer and offender safety (having somewhere safe to stop); and a location where the officer will be able to have clear sight of offending vehicles.

  • Deployment: There are a variety of approaches to deployment. For fixed safety cameras, some forces will have cameras in all housings whereas others will operate by rotating cameras. The ratio of cameras to housings will depend on local policy, as will the frequency of rotation, and which sites are prioritised. Some housings may have dummy cameras, where a flash is used when a driver speeds through the site, but there is no record of the office. For average speed cameras, not all housings may be live and detecting offences. For both fixed and average speed cameras, the housings themselves act as a deterrent to speeding. For mobile safety cameras, forces often have an enforcement strategy where they set out which sites are visited when (based on priority, and frequency of previous visits). Some forces operate a ‘random road watch approach’, where mobile enforcement can happen at any time and location across the network. This is also the approach adopted for roadside checks.

  • Communications: The threat of enforcement can change behaviour. This is why fixed and average speed cameras can have an effect, even if they are not active. Similarly, publicising that mobile enforcement or roadside checks are happening also increase the perceived risk of detection. Communicating why enforcement is happening can increase its acceptability amongst road users.

What the Research Shows

There are advantages and disadvantages to physical roadside checks, where offenders are stopped at the roadside at the time of their offence:

  • The offender receives immediate feedback

  • The police officer can take the opportunity to explain why they are undertaking enforcement

  • If the offender is stopped at a spot where other motorists can see them, it can positively influence the behaviour of others

The main disadvantage of physical roadside checks is that it is far more labour-intensive than using safety cameras so the perceived risk of being caught is smaller. There is evidence that adopting a network-wide random enforcement (or Random Road Watch (RRW) can be highly effective. This is a technique that randomly schedules levels of police enforcement, spread widely across the road network, where offenders are stopped by the police. A RRW programme in Queensland, Australia identified a 31% reduction in fatal collisions on the roads included in the programme (European Commission, 2018).

Safety camera enforcement is most appropriate if collisions are concentrated on specific sections of roads or areas and are related to excess speed. In October 2010, the Cochrane Review of 35 studies into the effectiveness of speed cameras worldwide reported that:

“…the consistency of reported reductions in speed and crash outcomes across all studies show that speed cameras are a worthwhile intervention for reducing the number of road traffic injuries and deaths” (Allsop, 2010).

Studies have demonstrated greater safety effects for fixed speed cameras than for mobile cameras. A possible explanation for this is that fixed cameras are often in locations inside built-up areas and with higher concentrations of collisions. “If the baseline lack of safety is greater, the effect of the camera can be expected to be greater” (European Commission, 2018).

However, an overview of Australasian enforcement projects found that hidden mobile cameras had an effect over larger geographical areas, while fixed cameras have a larger safety effect per location (European Commission, 2018).

There are different reasons for using overt and covert enforcement. Visible enforcement is important when there is a need to encourage compliance with traffic rules at certain locations (for example, reducing speed at a specific site where there are a high number of collisions). Covert, or hidden cameras, can make roadside checks less predictable and therefore can influence behaviour because there is a possibility of being caught. This is especially true when there is a warning sign, indicating that enforcement may be being carried out.

There are a variety of measures which can be used to support traffic enforcement (particularly speed enforcement). For road users to obey speed limits, they need to be safe and credible (credible meaning that the limit appears logical to the road user) (European Commission, 2018).

Traffic enforcement is more effective if it is supported by information. Communication with road users should:

  • Emphasise that safety is the goal of the enforcement activities

  • Explain and how and why the offending behaviour leads to more and higher severity collisions

  • Explain the enforcement method and procedures

  • Preferably illustrate that the revenues from fines are used for the benefit of local road safety

  • Provide feedback on the interim and final results of the enforcement activity, either in terms of traffic behaviour or safety (European Commission, 2018).

Enforcement strategies can depend on the behaviour change theory behind the intervention. Two very different approaches were adopted in Victoria, Australia in 1991 and Sweden in 2006 and were reviewed in 2010, as shown in the table below (Belin et al., 2010).

Components of the programme theory

Victoria 1991

Sweden 2006

What main problem does the speed camera programme try to solve?

The problem is that a large proportion of drivers are continuously exceeding the speed limit and thereby creating road safety problems

The main problem is that on a large proportion of the road network speed exceeds the speed level which the roads are designed for from a safety point of view

What is the programme trying to achieve?

The main purpose is to create a feeling among drivers that speeding can be detected at any time and in any place across the whole road system

The main purpose is to support and create a new social norm among drivers that it is easier and better to follow the speed limit

What does the intervention mechanism look like?

It aims to catch a large proportion of those drivers who exceed the speed limit so that they experience the consequences and avoid re- offending and, in their turn, discourage other drivers from offending

It informs (through signs and open cameras) drivers that a large proportion of the traffic network (large proportion of the traffic) is covered by cameras

How is the programme intended to achieve road safety effects?

A large number of drivers will be deterred from speeding. Excessive speeds and the average speed will decrease and the number of fatalities and injuries will decrease in the whole system

It will prevent most drivers from speeding. The average speed will decrease, as too will the number of fatalities and injuries

As explained by Belin et al.(2010), the approach in Victoria is the idea that speeding is a deliberate offence where rational individuals choose to drive as fast as possible and calculate the costs and benefits of doing so. The aim in Victoria was to increase the perceived costs of committing an offence and decreasing the perceived benefits. The idea is to encourage offenders who have had actual experience of being caught not to re-offend. There is also a general deterrence effect by letting others know that enforcement is happening and what the consequences of offending are (European Commission, 2018).

The Swedish philosophy is based on a belief that road safety is a priority for all and that one of the reasons for speeding is due to a lack of information. The cameras themselves are placed to increase the level of information available for road users to make safe speed choices and change their behaviour (European Commission, 2018).

Sources

Norbury, F. (2020) Roads Policing and its contribution to road safety, PACTS. https://www.pacts.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/Roads-Policing-Report-FinalV1-merged-1.pdf

European Commission, 2018. Speed Enforcement, Brussels: European Commission, Directorate General for Transport. https://road-safety.transport.ec.europa.eu/system/files/2021-07/ersosynthesis2018-speedenforcement.pdf

Allsop, R. (2010). The effectiveness of speed cameras. A review of evidence. RAC Foundation. https://www.racfoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/efficacy_of_speed_cameras_allsop_181110.pdf

Belin, M-Å, Tillgren, P., Vedung, E., Cameron, M., & C. Tingvall (2010) Speed cameras in Sweden and Victoria, Australia—A case study. Accident Analysis and Prevention, 42, pp. 2165–2170. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aap.2010.07.010