Implications for Delivery
It is important that we learn from fatal crashes.
Fatal Accident Inquiries publish public information on causes of road crashes. Road safety professionals should make use of them for research or analysis.
The process could be improved if the people involved have a better understanding of Safe System principles and by involving Safe System experts.
Policy Advisors, Police, Analysts, COPFS and other professionals need to work together to learn more from fatal crashes.
Background
In Scotland, all fatal road traffic collisions are reported to the Scottish Fatalities Investigation Unit (SFIU) in the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service (COPFS). COPFS investigates all sudden, suspicious, accidental and unexplained deaths. COPFS acts on behalf of the Lord Advocate. The Road Traffic Fatalities Investigation Unit within SFIU carries out the investigation.
COPFS decides if a prosecution and/or Fatal Accident Inquiry is required in relation to the death(s).
A Fatal Accident Inquiry must take place if someone dies in an accident at work or dies when they are in legal custody. So, a fatal collision investigation will need to determine if anyone involved was driving for work at the time. COPFS may also decide at the end of their investigation that a Fatal Accident Inquiry is in the public interest, for example, if poor road layout or road signage contributed to a collision.
A Fatal Accident Inquiry is held before a Sheriff. They will hear evidence about how the person or people died. This may include a range of evidence from experts and witnesses. At the end of a Fatal Accident Inquiry, the Sheriff will publish a Determination. This must include:
when and where the death occurred
when and where any accident resulting in the death occurred
the cause or causes of death
the cause or causes of any accident resulting in the death
any precautions which could have been taken to avoid the death
any defects in any system of working which contributed to the death or any accident resulting in the death
any other facts which are relevant to the circumstances of the death.
The Sheriff may make recommendations in the Determination which can be directed at any organisation. These organisations have to say what they are going to do in response or explain why they will not follow the recommendation. The Determination and any responses are published on the Scottish Courts and Tribunals Service website.
Fatal Accident Inquiries are a rich source of public information about the fatal collision and any system defects that contributed.
What the Research Shows
The system for investigating deaths is different in England and Wales where it is a Coroner who is responsible. Following their investigation, Coroners are expected to publish a Prevention of Future Death report (PFD) if they identify a matter of concern. A PFD is sent to individuals or organisations who have the power to act in relation to the matter(s) of concern. These individuals or organisations must respond to say what action they will take or explain why they will not act.
Research has shown PFDs are a useful tool to encourage road safety action. However, they are not used consistently for road traffic collisions. There are opportunities to improve road safety through better engagement and information for Coroners. Recommendations from the research include:
training coroners in Safe System principles
routine involvement of Safe System experts in inquests
revisiting how the functions performed by investigation branches in other modes can be delivered for road transport
enhancing the capture and dissemination of lessons learned from fatal crashes.
These recommendations can equally be applied to COPFS and the Fatal Accident Inquiries in Scotland.
Sources
PACTS. (2024). Learning from road fatalities to save lives. https://www.pacts.org.uk/new-pacts-report-learning-from-road-fatalities-to-save-lives/
Scottish Courts and Tribunals Service. (n.d.). Fatal accident inquiries and determinations. https://www.scotcourts.gov.uk/fatal-accident-inquiries/fatal-accident-inquiries-and-determinations/