Justice for Victims

Prev Next
This content is currently unavailable in English (UK). You are viewing the default (English) version.

Implications for Delivery

To help support road crash victims, practitioners need to:

  • Understand and support victims through the justice process: Road deaths in Scotland are investigated by Police Scotland and COPFS, with processes such as post-mortems, police investigations, and possible prosecutions or Fatal Accident Inquiries (FAIs). Practitioners should be prepared to guide or signpost families through these often lengthy and complex stages, ensuring they are informed, supported, and treated with empathy throughout.

  • Facilitate access to emotional and practical support: Victims and families affected by fatal or serious road collisions often need both emotional and practical assistance. Practitioners should proactively refer victims to specialist services like Brake’s National Road Victim Service and ensure they know their rights under the Victims’ Code for Scotland, including access to information and help navigating legal and support systems.

  • Be aware of victim rights and advocacy opportunities: Victims have rights to review prosecution decisions, submit victim statements, and receive updates through the VIA service. Practitioners can play a key role in advocating for these rights and ensuring victims’ voices are heard during legal proceedings and wider system reforms, such as the Road Victims’ Charter and the Victim-Centred Approach workstreams.

Background

When someone is killed in a road collision in Scotland, the death is investigated by Police Scotland on behalf of the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service (COPFS).

What is COPFS?

COPFS is the agency responsible for prosecuting criminal cases that have been investigated by the police in Scotland. It reports to the Lord Advocate, the senior Scottish Law Officer who is responsible for criminal prosecution and the investigation of deaths in Scotland.

COPFS employs lawyers called Procurators Fiscal to investigate all sudden deaths. The Procurator Fiscal is responsible for:

  • Instructing a post-mortem

  • Overseeing the police investigation

  • Deciding whether someone should be charged with committing a criminal offence

  • Deciding whether a Fatal Accident Inquiry should happen.

The specialist team that deals with road deaths within COPFS is called the Scottish Fatalities Investigation Unit (SFIU).

For more information about COPFS, including how a death is investigated in Scotland, go to www.copfs.gov.uk/about-copfs.

Post-mortems

After a road death there is usually a post-mortem. This is a medical examination of the body to help find out the cause of death. It includes examination of body organs, tissues and fluids, and is carried out on behalf of the Procurator Fiscal by a specialist doctor called a pathologist. Once all the tests have been carried out, the pathologist will send the Procurator Fiscal a report. This forms part of the evidence that the Procurator Fiscal will consider as part of their investigation to determine whether there will be a criminal prosecution.

The police investigation

Police Scotland attend all fatal road traffic collisions in Scotland and investigate what has happened. This investigation includes gathering evidence from people, vehicles and the scene.

People involved in the collision can be tested for alcohol, drugs and have their eyesight checked. The police may take statements from different people who were involved in the collision, saw the collision, or saw vehicles before or after the collision. Police may also take a statement from other family members who were not involved in the collision to find out more about their movements that day.

Collison investigation officers may remove and examine vehicles to find out if they are mechanically defective and / or get more information about what happened, by studying vehicle damage or vehicle electronic data, for example a vehicle’s speed and braking, or how long it was driven for.

They may also photograph, video and measure the collision location, at the time of the collision and sometimes later too. They record things like vehicle positions, skid marks on the road, and damage to objects, such as bollards. They also analyse any available footage from street cameras (CCTV).

If the collision involved someone driving for work, the police or other agencies may need to investigate their employer, to find out if there was any failure by the employer to ensure a vehicle was safe or driven safely. They may need to interview people or seize paperwork.

The police investigation may take several months. If the police investigation finds evidence that suggests a crime may have been committed, this evidence is compiled into a confidential report that is sent to the Procurator Fiscal. This forms part of the evidence they consider as part of their investigation to determine whether there will be a criminal prosecution.

When someone is seriously injured in a road collision, Police Scotland will investigate the cause of the collision in the same way – dependant on the level of injuries caused.

The decision to prosecute

The purpose of a criminal prosecution is to find out if a person, or in some cases a company, has broken the law and to punish an offender or offenders. Whether or not a criminal prosecution happens depends on the circumstances of the collision and whether there is enough evidence to support a criminal charge.

The Procurator Fiscal will consider the law, the evidence and whether it is in the public interest for someone to be charged with committing a crime. The crime must be recognised in Scottish law and there must also be enough reliable and credible evidence that the crime was committed by someone. Sometimes several charges are brought. Sometimes no charges are brought.

There are different offences that someone can be charged with after a collision, depending on the evidence collected. Some offences mention that a death or serious injury have occurred, but others do not. Sometimes a person, or more than one person, is charged with committing more than one offence.

Victims Right to Review (VRR)

If the Procurator Fiscal decides not to bring charges against someone, the family may have the right to request a review of that decision. This is known as Victims’ Right to Review. The scheme was designed to help victims understand more about the case and recognises that victims are often unfamiliar with the judicial process. This feeling of unfamiliarity can be made worse if someone is bereaved and / or suffering the impact of trauma.

For more information, go to www.copfs.gov.uk and click on `Services for victims and witnesses'.

Victim statements

If it is decided that someone will be prosecuted for a crime, the family may be eligible to make a victim statement that explains how the crime has affected theirs and others’ lives, for example physically, emotionally or financially.

A victim statement is an important document because it becomes part of the case papers and will be given to the court. The judge or sheriff will consider all the circumstances of the case and the victim statement and decide what weight should be given to it. The victim statement will not always have an effect on the sentence.

The following can provide support if writing a victim statement:

  • The investigating officer from Police Scotland

  • The Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service

  • The charity Victim Support Scotland

  • A Brake caseworker, is being supported by Brake’s National Road Victim Service.

Sentencing at court

Maximum penalties are fixed by law and are different for different offences, sometimes significantly. Courts often impose penalties lower than the maximum.

When sentencing, various things may be taken into account, including any ‘pleas in mitigation’, victim statements, whether the offender pleaded guilty or not, guidelines on sentencing and the level of sentences in similar cases in the past (‘case law’).

The maximum sentence that can be imposed will vary depending on the offence and the type of court it is prosecuted in. A court will rarely impose the maximum penalty and sometimes imposes a much lower penalty.

Fatal Accident Inquiries

A Fatal Accident Inquiry (FAI) is a public court hearing to find out what caused a sudden, unexplained or suspicious death and to consider how to prevent future deaths or injuries in similar circumstances. An FAI must take place if someone dies in an accident at work or dies when they are in legal custody. An FAI may also be held if a road death raises concerns about public safety, for example, if poor road layout or road signage contributed to a collision.

An FAI cannot apportion criminal blame, nor decide if someone should be punished or receive compensation. These things are decided through criminal and civil proceedings.

If enough evidence has been provided at a criminal trial to show why a death occurred, an FAI may not be necessary.

For more information on how FAIs can contribute to learning from collisions see Fatal Accident Inquiries.

Support during the criminal justice process

After a fatal or catastrophic injury collision, many road victims need access to specialist support, such as the support provided by the charity Brake through its National Road Victim Service. This is discussed in more detail in Post crash support services.

Many road victims need specialist emotional support to help them cope with their grief.

Others need specialist practical support to help them deal with complex, unfamiliar processes that often follow a fatal or serious injury collision. For example, to help them understand what happens during a police investigation, a post-mortem, a Fatal Accident Inquiry or a court case.

Brake’s National Road Victim Service works in partnership with the Victim Information and Advice (VIA) service which is provided in Scotland by COPFS. After a fatal road collision, bereaved road victims are assigned a VIA officer who will provide information about the criminal justice system and the progress of a case, including dates of hearings and decisions about bail, verdicts and sentences. The VIA officer can also arrange a court visit before the trial.

For more information on VIA, go to www.copfs.gov.uk and click on 'Victims'.

Road victims’ right to support

The police, prosecution agencies, and courts are required to meet certain standards that aim to help victims of crime. These standards are written into a government document called ‘The Victims’ Code for Scotland’.

The Victims’ Code for Scotland says that as a victim of crime you have the right to:

  • have fair and equal access to services offered by criminal justice agencies

  • be offered help in a professional manner, without discrimination of any kind

  • be offered additional help if needed so that you and your family can access information and support services.

You also have the right to be able to obtain information about what is happening in the investigation or proceedings, where it is appropriate and relevant.

Support for road victims includes being referred (or you can self-refer) to Brake’s National Road Victim Service in Scotland. You will be allocated a caseworker who will support you throughout the investigation.

For more information about support for victims of crime, go to www.mygov.scot/victim-witness-support.

Road Victims’ Charter

In November 2025, Brake launched a new Road Victims’ Charter demanding essential actions to ensure that everyone affected by road crashes receives the respect, support and justice they deserve.

The Road Victims’ Charter was written by Brake in collaboration with representatives from the road victim community, support services, NHS, police and representatives from across the criminal justice sector.

To find out more and pledge support for the Road Victim’s Charter, go to the Brake website at www.brake.org.uk/roadvictimscharter.

Victim centred approach review

In 2023, the Victims Taskforce began a work stream with the Victim Centred Approach team in Scotland which aims to make improvements to the justice journey of victims in Scotland.

Brake’s National Road Victim Service took part in this workstream to ensure road victims who are bereaved or injured in Scotland were represented. Information on this work is available at https://www.gov.scot/groups/victims-taskforce/.

Sources

Justice Directorate. (2018). Thematic report on victims’ right to review, complaints handling & feedback follow-up. Scottish Government. https://www.gov.scot/publications/thematic-report-victims-right-review-complaints-handling-feedback-follow-up/

Justice Directorate. (2025). Workstream 1: Victim-centred approach update. In Victims Taskforce papers, June 2024. Scottish Government. https://www.gov.scot/publications/victims-taskforce-papers-june-2024/pages/workstream-1-victim-centred-approach-update/

Justice Directorate. (2025). Workstream 2: Trauma-informed workforce update. In Victims Taskforce papers, June 2024. Scottish Government. https://www.gov.scot/publications/victims-taskforce-papers-june-2024/pages/workstream-2-trauma-informed-workforce-update/

MyGov Scotland. (2018). Standards of service for victims and witnesses [Webpage]. https://www.mygov.scot/victim-witness-rights/standards-of-service-for-victims-and-witnesses


With thanks to Brake - the road safety charity for their contribution to this content.

Brake logo