Implications for Delivery
To reduce serious crashes linked to the fatal four, enforcement needs to be:
Visible: People are more likely to follow the rules when they see police on the roads.
Targeted: Focus on risky places and times.
Well-coordinated: Work together with awareness campaigns.
Technology-supported: Use tools like cameras and roadside tests to help spot unsafe behaviours.
Backed by law: Clear rules and reliable testing methods help make enforcement stronger.
Background
Driver behaviours are a significant contributory factor in the occurrence of road traffic crashes. However, some driving behaviours are more dangerous than others. In the UK, many fatal and serious crashes involve one or more of these four risky actions, known as the fatal four:
Drink or drug driving
Non-seatbelt wearing
Mobile handheld device use
Speeding
These behaviours are often not isolated and happen together. For example, a driver under the influence of alcohol may also be speeding and not wearing a seatbelt. This situation increases the severity of the crash and reduces the likelihood of survival.
Despite progress in vehicle safety and infrastructure, such unsafe driver behaviours continue to undermine road safety outcomes. A major contributing factor to this situation is the sharp decline in traffic police numbers. For example, since 2010, the number of dedicated roads officers in England and Wales has fallen by over 20% (Norbury, 2020). Only speeding is widely enforced now, mostly by cameras. Enforcement actions for the other ‘fatal four’ behaviours such as seatbelt non-use and drink driving have declined significantly, even as non-compliance persists.
Public perception also plays a role in the presence of such risky behaviours on the roads. Although many people support strict enforcement, many drivers believe they are unlikely to be caught for these offences. This weakens the impact of the rules. To save lives, we need more visible and regular enforcement of all four behaviours.
What the Research Shows
Drink or drug driving: Alcohol and drugs seriously affect driving skills like focus, reaction time, and coordination. Even a small amount of alcohol can increase the risk of a crash. Additionally, when blood alcohol content (BAC) is higher, the danger rises.
Drug impairment presents similar, and in some cases greater risks. Psychoactive substances (cannabis, sedatives, and especially stimulants-like amphetamines) disturb motor functions and attention.
In-depth research into fatal collisions in Scotland between 2015 and 2020 showed 14% of all fatal collisions had impairment by alcohol or drugs as a factor.
To reduce these risks, certain enforcement methods have been found effective, such as random breath testing; sobriety checkpoints; low BAC thresholds for novice and commercial drivers; alcohol interlocks in vehicles; and roadside drug testing.
Public education and awareness are important for preventing these risky driver behaviours, but they should also be supported by visible enforcement.
Non-seatbelt wearing: Seatbelts are one of the simplest and most effective ways to stay safe in a crash. They greatly lower the risk of death or serious injury. Still, not everyone wears them, and in recent years, fewer checks by police have led to more people ignoring seatbelt rules. Despite compliance with seatbelt wearing in Scotland being over 96%, in 2024, 23% of car fatalities were not wearing a seat belt. Just like with drink or drug driving behaviour, seatbelt usage rates can also increase through visible enforcement practices. Bringing back regular checks, especially alongside other controls like drink driving tests, can remind drivers that seatbelts save lives and must be worn every time.
Mobile handheld device use: Mobile phone use while driving distracts drivers both visually and cognitively. As a result, this risky behaviour significantly increases the likelihood of a crash. Even though it’s illegal in many places, drivers often still use mobile phones while driving because low enforcement levels have reduced public perception of risk. Combining manual police checks with automated technologies (e.g. smart cameras, automatic number plate recognition) can increase enforcement coverage.
Speeding: Speeding is still one of the biggest causes of serious crashes. The faster someone drives, the more likely a crash will cause serious injury or death. For this reason, even small speed reductions can save lives. This is discussed in more detail in the ‘It’s All About Energy’ and ‘Speed and Human Tolerance to Injury in Safe System’ sections. Speed cameras can help catch speeding drivers and have replaced some of the work done by traffic police. However, in areas with less camera coverage (e.g. rural roads, busy urban areas) enforcement remains weak. To keep people following speed limits, enforcement needs to be visible, consistent, and supported by clear messages and fair penalties.
Sources
Department for Transport (2024) Seatbelt wearing rates: England 2023 https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/seatbelt-and-mobile-phone-use-surveys-2023/seatbelt-wearing-rates-england-2023
Norbury, F. (2020). Roads policing and its contribution to road safety. Parliamentary Advisory Council for Transport Safety.
The UN Road Safety Collaboration (2022). Drinking and driving: a road safety manual for decision-makers and practitioners. Global Road Safety Partnership, International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies, Geneva.
World Health Organization (2016) Drug use and road safety: a policy brief. Geneva, Switzerland.