Implications for Delivery
Ideally the use of Grey Fleet should be discouraged as it poses a higher risk than company owned or hire vehicles. However, practitioners must recognise that it will not be convenient for all organisations to do away with the use of Grey Fleet, and that to do so might be an unwelcome move among staff who receive mileage payments. Therefore, any changes need to be carefully managed and communicated.
Where Grey Fleet is used, emphasise the following ways risks can be managed:
Setting a minimum safety specification (ideally based on EuroNCAP scores)
Setting a maximum age of vehicle (because newer vehicles will have better safety than older versions).
Checking vehicle condition (for example through spot checks on tyres or requiring additional vehicle inspections)
Checking the vehicle is properly insured for business use
Background
Traditionally, vehicles owned and operated by an organisation are referred to as “White Fleet” (vehicles like pool cars, company cars, vans and lorries). Vehicles owned by employees but driven for work (mostly cars, but also some vans and motorcycles) are referred to as “Grey Fleet” which not only marks them apart but is a good indication of the slightly murky grey area which often surrounds their use.
Health and Safety obligations apply just as much to someone driving their own vehicle to work as they do to someone driving a vehicle which belongs to the organisation. That means that the vehicle should not place them or others at greater risk than if they were driving a vehicle owned by the organisation.
However, many organisations don’t realise the responsibility they have for Grey Fleet, seeing it as the employees own business what vehicle they drive. Some organisations don’t even check that the vehicle has a current MOT (if required) or business use insurance. The most diligent organisations and industries set minimum safety standards for vehicles, and if they do not meet these then they cannot be used for work journeys.
Grey Fleet vehicles present a higher risk because:
The organisation has no direct control over how the vehicle is maintained (e.g. replacing tyres at above the legal minimum)
Grey Fleet vehicles tend to be older than White Fleet (an average of 8 years old vs an average of 2 years old) and so are less likely to have the latest safety features.
Grey Fleet vehicles may have a greater environmental impact for the business, as they tend to be older and be less well maintained.
What the Research Shows
There are an estimated 14 million grey fleet vehicles on UK roads. The distance driven in a Grey Fleet vehicle in the public sector is estimated to be 1.5 billion miles per year with the Grey Fleet in the private sector driving an estimated 11 billion miles per year.
The British Vehicle Rental & Leasing Association (BVRLA) claim that the average grey fleet vehicle is 6.1 years older than a leased car and emits another 24g/km. By contrast, a company car is an average of less than 3 years old and a rental car is an average of 0.7 years old.
Older BVRLA data showed that only 37% of Grey Fleet cars achieved Five Stars in EuroNCAP testing, versus 88% of White Fleet cars. By contrast, as of July 2025 64% of the most recently tested cars achieved Five Stars. Because the requirements of EuroNCAP change over time and become more challenging to achieve, a new Five Star car will provide significantly more safety than a vehicle tested under a previous version of the tests.
The safety and environmental case for avoiding the use of Grey Fleet is clear, but there can be cost benefits to the organisation and staff member, as well as operational simplicity in allowing the use of Grey Fleet. However, 62% of companies do not have any form of Grey Fleet policy in place and only 16% have what they describe as a “comprehensive” policy on the subject.
Sources
British Vehicle Rental & Leasing Association. (2025). Grey fleet. BVRLA. https://www.bvrla.co.uk/industry-campaigns/air-quality/grey-fleet.html#:~:text=A%20grey%20fleet%20vehicle%20is,towards%20achieving%20CO%E2%82%82%20reduction%20targets
Carfrae, J. (2024). Grey fleet: The thin grey line. https://www.businesscar.co.uk/analysis/grey-fleet-the-thin-grey-line/
Fleet News. (2025). Fleet car and van SMR: average age of fleet vehicle entering workshop. http://fleetnews.co.uk/fleet-car-and-van-smr-average-age-of-fleet-vehicle-entering-workshop
Road Safety GB. (2025). How safe is the new car you’ve just bought? https://roadsafetygb.org.uk/news/how-safe-is-the-new-car-youve-just-bought/
Roberts, G. (2023). Majority of employers have no grey fleet policy. Fleet News. https://www.fleetnews.co.uk/news/majority-of-employers-have-no-grey-fleet-policy
Swedish Transport Administration. (2019). Saving Lives Beyond 2020: The next steps — Recommendations of the Academic Expert Group for the 3rd Global Ministerial Conference on Road Safety [PDF]. https://www.roadsafetysweden.com/contentassets/c65bb9192abb44d5b26b633e70e0be2c/200113_final-report-single.pdf
Turner, S. (2022). Do you have an unseen problem with grey fleet? Driving for Better Business. https://www.drivingforbetterbusiness.com/articles/do-you-have-an-unseen-problem-with-grey-fleet/
With thanks to The Transafe Network for their contribution to this content.
