Implications for Delivery
Encourage organisations to consider the road environment and the effect of it on the choices they make about their operations.
Issues to consider include:
Which roads will provide the safest routes? Encourage them to use freely available risk mapping, but also to consider getting their drivers to report which roads and junctions they find difficult. Journey planning should be encouraged for all journeys, with detailed route plans for regular journeys such as delivery routes.
Is their driver’s training preparing them for the roads on which they will drive? Driver training on A roads is of less use if the drivers’ main exposure is on narrow single track lanes, or urban roads for example.
Are the vehicles their organisation is using the most suitable for the roads on which they are travelling? Are the vehicles an appropriate size and specification? Smaller delivery vehicles for local roads for example, or four wheel drive if operating in areas with a lot of roads which are not gritted in winter.
Are they equipping their vehicles to prepare them for the conditions they will encounter (e.g. Winter Tyres)?
Background
Different road environments present different risks for different types of drivers – and this has implications for driver assessment and training, vehicle specifications and journey planning.
Motorways and dual carriageways, rural single carriageway roads and urban roads all bring different levels of safety and different challenges.
For example, a lorry which spends a lot of time in urban areas should be selected on the principles of the Direct Vision Standard, which assists the driver in avoiding collisions with pedestrians, cyclist and motorcyclists by providing better vision – however a lorry which is mostly doing longer trips up and down the country may get minimal safety benefit from such a specification.
A delivery van which is only operating in an urban area in which the roads are gritted in cold conditions will get less benefit from the fitting of winter tyres, but a van operating in more remote areas where gritting doesn’t take place might find that having winter tyres is essential to keeping operational all year.
A driver undertaking long journeys on featureless motorways may become more fatigued than a driver covering the same distance on a rural road – however if the driver crashes, the motorway is an environment in which they are less likely to kill or be killed than a rural road, due to the presence of more safety features such as crash barriers.
What the Research Shows
Risk Mapping of roads can look at risk in different ways, such as crashes per 100km of road, or crashes per billion vehicle kilometres travelled. For example, Scotland’s local A roads are 14% of Great Britain’s road network but only have around 6% of fatal and serious crashes.
Understanding the relative risk of the road types on which an organisation’s vehicles are being driven is important in terms of knowing what will be relevant driver training to deliver, and also how to equip vehicles – home delivery company Ocado managed to grow their business by fitting winter tyres on their delivery fleet as they were then able to deliver when their competitors were having to cancel.
Routing vehicles onto the safer road types, or safer roads within a particular classification of road can help organisations to reduce the level of risk they are exposed to, even when travelling the same mileage. Training drivers for the road types they will encounter most can also improve safety.
Direct Vision Standard lorries have been shown to be much safer in urban areas – for example a research programme found a traditional cab resulted in 23% more pedestrian collisions than a low entry, direct vision cab.
Sources
IRAP. (2023). Road safety performance and investment opportunities: Britain’s motorways and A-roads crash risk mapping results 2023. https://irap.org/2023/12/road-safety-performance-and-investment-opportunities-britains-motorways-and-a-roads-crash-risk-mapping-results-2023/
Loughborough University. (n.d.). Direct Vision Standard [Project page]. Loughborough University—School of Design and Creative Arts. https://www.lboro.ac.uk/schools/design-creative-arts/research-innovation/projects/direct-vision-standard/
Road Safety Foundation. (2024). Crash risk mapping results 2024 [Interactive map]. Agilysis. http://rsfmaps.agilysis.co.uk/
Swedish Transport Administration. (2019). Saving Lives Beyond 2020: The next steps — Recommendations of the Academic Expert Group for the 3rd Global Ministerial Conference on Road Safety. https://www.roadsafetysweden.com/contentassets/c65bb9192abb44d5b26b633e70e0be2c/200113_final-report-single.pdf
Transport for London. (2015). Direct Vision in heavy goods vehicles. Delivering safely. https://tfl.gov.uk/info-for/deliveries-in-london/delivering-safely/direct-vision-in-heavy-goods-vehicles
Transport for London. (2016). Road safety benefits of direct vs indirect vision in HGV cabs: Summary. https://content.tfl.gov.uk/road-safety-benefits-of-direct-vs-indirect-vision-in-hgv-cabs-summary.pdf
Waller, P. (2011). Snow tyres help Ocado beat weather. Express. https://www.express.co.uk/finance/city/222428/Snow-tyres-help-Ocado-beat-weather
With thanks to The Transafe Network for their contribution to this content.
