Injury-Based Reporting

Prev Next
This content is currently unavailable in English (UK). You are viewing the default (English) version.

Implications for Delivery

  • In analyses performed exclusively with data collected under an injury-based reporting system, use the additional severity categories to report on collisions resulting in severe injury and death, which is more in line with Safe System definitions.

  • When comparing or analysing data, ensure adjusted and non-adjusted data are used in the correct contexts.

  • Ensure it is clear which data is being used and why.

  • Ensure Police Officers, Analysts and decision-makers all understand the implications of injury-based reporting and the importance of accurate data collection, analysis and interpretation.

  • Even if adjusted data is used, when talking about casualties publicly it is important to round to whole numbers.

Background

The number of people killed or injured in road traffic collisions in Great Britain has been recorded since 1926. The national data set is known as STATS19. The data in STATS19 is recorded by the Police, usually by an officer who attended the collision scene. Each record is generally completed within 30 days of a collision; finalised records for all reported injury collisions must be submitted annually. In STATS19 a road casualty is described as slightly injured, seriously injured or killed.

Before injury-based reporting, a Police Officer recorded the severity of each casualty – killed, serious or slight – using their judgement (based on Department for Transport guidance - STATS20). In an injury-based reporting system, the casualty’s injuries are recorded by the Police Officer from a set list. This automatically populates the severity using the most severe injury suffered by each casualty. A list of the injuries and how they map to different severities is shown below:

Injury

Detailed severity

Severity classification

Deceased

Killed

Killed

Broken neck or back

Very Serious

Serious

Severe head injury, unconscious

Very Serious

Serious

Severe chest injury, any difficulty breathing

Very Serious

Serious

Internal injuries

Very Serious

Serious

Multiple severe injuries, unconscious

Very Serious

Serious

Loss of arm or leg (or part)

Moderately Serious

Serious

Fractured pelvis or upper leg

Moderately Serious

Serious

Other chest injury (not bruising)

Moderately Serious

Serious

Deep penetrating wound

Moderately Serious

Serious

Multiple severe injuries, conscious

Moderately Serious

Serious

Fractured lower leg or ankle or foot

Less Serious

Serious

Fractured arm or collarbone or hand

Less Serious

Serious

Deep cuts or lacerations

Less Serious

Serious

Other head injury

Less Serious

Serious

Whiplash or neck pain

Slight

Slight

Shallow cuts or lacerations or abrasions

Slight

Slight

Sprains and strains

Slight

Slight

Bruising

Slight

Slight

Shock

Slight

Slight

Under both systems, the severity of a collision is always defined as the worst single severity of all resulting casualties.

One weakness in STATS19 is that “serious injury” is a very broad category. A serious injury can range from death more than 30 days after the collision (the cut-off point for recording a casualty as killed) to a fractured finger. This does not correspond to medical definitions of serious or severe injury. The injury-based reporting method allows for more detailed severity to be recorded and splits serious injury into three categories: very serious; moderately serious; and less serious.

This can help with analysing more severe collisions as it is more in line with the Safe System. For example, some authorities are using killed, very serious and moderately serious to describe “severe collisions” or “life changing injuries” compared to more traditional use of “fatal and serious” collisions (FSC) or “killed and seriously injured” casualties (KSI).

Injury-based reporting was first trialled in Surrey in 2012 with the introduction of the Collision Recording and Sharing (CRaSH) system. Around half of all English police forces moved to using CRaSH in 2015 or 2016. The Metropolitan Police introduced their own injury-based reporting system called Case Overview Preparation Application (COPA) in 2015.

Police Scotland adopted the CRaSH system in April 2019 to report all road traffic collisions. By 2026, all Police Forces in Great Britain should be using injury-based reporting.

One of the challenges of moving to injury-based reporting is it appears to have led to a change in reported severity of road casualties. Some casualties that previously would have been recorded as ‘slight’, based on the Police Officer’s judgement, are being recorded as ‘serious’ using injury-based reporting. The Department for Transport estimates that moving to injury-based reporting systems added between 5% and 15% to the overall total of ‘serious’ injuries in Great Britain.

In 2018, the Department for Transport (DfT) began publishing severity adjustments, at individual casualty and collision record level, based on a methodology agreed between DfT and the Office for National Statistics derived from statistical analysis of national data. The methodology accounts for the difference in reporting between injury-based and non-injury-based methods to enable direct comparisons to be made. No adjustment is required for killed casualties or fatal collisions, as the definition of deceased did not change between the two systems.

Each adjustment is expressed as a percentage probability that each casualty and collision reported as “slight” based on the officer’s judgement would have been recorded as “serious”, if injury-based reporting had been in effect. Each year since 2018, DfT have published a new series of adjustments as additional data becomes available.

What this means

The introduction of adjusted figures means it is important to understand which figures to use when you are doing any analysis. Historic data is adjusted back to 2004 to allow for comparison to baselines, and a new set of adjustments is published annually. However, this means that historic data is subject to small changes each year if it is being compared to injury-based data. This can cause some confusion for decision-makers as the baseline reference point (if set before injury-based reporting was adopted) is subject to minor changes year on year, when the most recent set of adjustments available is applied. This will continue to change each year until the Department for Transport no longer publishes annual adjustment factors. This will occur once all forces are using injury-based reporting.

The following types of analysis/reporting should be unaffected:

  • Reporting fatalities and total number of casualties/collisions (i.e. not separating serious and slight)

  • Analysing data time series where all the data was collected using a non-injury-based reporting system, and no comparison is made to data collected using injury-based reporting

  • Analysing data time series where all the data was collected using an injury-based reporting system

  • Analysing individual or small numbers of collisions e.g. at junctions or on a route as part of collision investigation, safety audit or scheme development work

NOTE:

Care may be needed with collision investigation or route analysis work with larger datasets and where multiple years or more than one police force’s data are being used.

All other data analysis is likely to be affected and will need to be undertaken using the adjusted data. As a guide, the following question should be your starting point:

Have the police force(s) used the same reporting method (injury-based or non-injury-based) for the whole time period to be analysed?

If the answer is no, then adjusted data will be necessary within the analysis.

One thing to bear in mind with adjusted data is that it will result in fractions of a casualty or collision to make the whole dataset statistically correct. However, when using the data for public purposes it is important to present it rounded to the nearest whole number, as it is not possible to have a fraction of a casualty in reality.

Sources

Braunholtz, D., & Elliott, D. (2019). Estimating and adjusting for changes in the method of severity reporting for road accidents and casualty data: Final report. Office for National Statistics. https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/5d38703240f0b604df1f83fb/severity-reporting-methodology-final-report.odt

Department for Transport. (2024). Guide to severity adjustments for reported road casualties, Great Britain. GOV.UK. https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/guide-to-severity-adjustments-for-reported-road-casualty-statistics/guide-to-severity-adjustments-for-reported-road-casualties-great-britain