Knowledge Sharing

Prev
This content is currently unavailable in English (UK). You are viewing the default (English) version.

Implications for Delivery

  • Centralised reporting enhances learning: Sharing fatal collision investigation findings through a centralised reporting process enables broader learning and intervention beyond local areas. This approach allows identification of cross-regional patterns that individual investigations may miss.

  • Fatal collision review boards improve accountability: Local review boards help coordinate multi-agency learning and track actions to prevent recurrence of similar incidents. There is potential for greater impact if learning is shared across regions.

  • Thematic and comparative analysis adds value: The Road Collision Investigation Project shows how comparing findings across multiple regions uncovers patterns and safety issues (e.g. with motorcycle clothing) that may appear isolated in single investigations.

  • Public findings support transparency and learning: Fatal Accident Inquiries and similar recommendation processes offer valuable lessons. However, inconsistency in their use limits effectiveness, suggesting a need for standardisation and more systematic application.

  • Safety advice notices are effective tools: Issuing notices based on cross-case insights helps disseminate safety lessons to a wider practitioner audience, supporting targeted interventions and policy development.

Background

Fatal and serious collisions are usually investigated individually and, because they are dispersed across the road network, they tend to be analysed at a local highway or police force level. The fact that these types of collisions are, statistically speaking, quite rare means that similar cases may not be identified. This limits the opportunity for thematic investigation and, therefore, the learning that can be taken from these tragedies.

What the Research Shows

Research projects have shown the benefits of sharing and linking investigation findings to increase the opportunity for learning. Some examples are outlined below:

Post collision fatal reporting

Operating over 4,300 miles of motorway and trunk road, National Highways road network is split into six regions and is covered by 38 police forces. To support better central knowledge and analysis of fatal collisions across the network a reporting process was established to notify one, central team of each fatal collision that happens on the network and the results of any local investigation. This has enabled an investigation process to be managed centrally and used to inform interventions across the network rather than just in the region local to the collision.

Fatal collision review boards

At the road authority level, some areas have established Fatal Collision Review Boards which meet regularly to review the fatal collisions that have occurred within the road authority area and keep track of actions partners have committed to in reducing the opportunity for similar collisions to happen in future. These are improving learning at a local level but there is work being explored to see how these boards could learn from each other and share information so wider patterns could be analysed.

Fatal accident inquiries

The determinations and any resulting recommendations from Fatal Accident Inquiries are published on the Scottish Courts and Tribunals Service website. In England and Wales the equivalent reports to Prevent Future Deaths issued by a Coroner have been analysed in a 2024 PACTS report. While this highlighted the inconsistency in their use, this type of information has the potential to be a powerful mechanism for learning.

Road Collision Investigation Project - Safety advice notices

The Road Collision Investigation Project is an example of thematic investigation that took place across Dorset, Devon & Cornwall, Humberside, and West Midlands police force areas. Comparing investigation findings across these areas allowed patterns to be identified that could otherwise have been missed, or dismissed as one-off events. The project also issued safety advice notices relating to motorcycle helmets and motorcycle jackets based on the combined findings. The use of safety advice notices is a key opportunity for sharing learning gained from investigations with a wider professional audience.