Speed and Human Tolerance to Injury in Safe System

Prev Next
This content is currently unavailable in English (UK). You are viewing the default (English) version.

Implications for Delivery

A speed management policy should start with an understanding of human tolerance to injury. Use the sources listed here and others to help with that.

If you are setting speed limits, base them on human tolerance. They should align with:

  • The road environment and physical infrastructure

  • Potential Conflict types (for example side or frontal impacts)

  • Road users present (for example whether motor vehicles and vulnerable road users might interact)

Ensure that limits are credible by combining changes with other measures and public messaging.

Background

As outlined in the previous section, energy management is at the core of the Safe System. There is a limited amount of force we can be exposed to before death or serious injury occur. To achieve Vision Zero and eliminate road trauma, it is therefore necessary to:

  • Prevent crashes from occurring

  • Where crashes do occur, reduce the amount of force generated to a level humans can tolerate.  

Any speed management policy starts with understanding human tolerance to injury and how this relates to the road environment and vehicles present. Speed limits should be set according to potential conflict types and road infrastructure to ensure that humans are not subjected to intolerable forces.

This section is important for any stakeholders involved in setting speed limits, managing speeds or enforcement activities.

What the Research Shows

Speed is a crucial factor in determining the severity of a crash. There is a wealth of evidence on the relationship between speed and risk. Even small increases in travel speed have a significant impact, as indicated by the widely accepted ‘power law’ from Swedish researcher Nilsson. This states that a 1% increase in mean speed produces a 4% increase in fatal crash risk. Highly respected Norwegian researcher Elvik also uses an ‘exponential model’ to indicate that a 1kph increase in speed may lead to an 8% increase in fatalities.

‘Injury-risk curves’ show the mathematical link between speed and risk for different road user and vehicle types. Vulnerable road users, such as pedestrians and cyclists, are particularly at risk when involved in a crash. For example, research shows that adult pedestrians have a 90% chance of surviving a crash at speeds of 30km/h or lower, and this risk increases to 50-80% for speeds of 50km/h. Demographic factors such as age are also key predictors of crash risk, with those aged 60+ significantly more at risk of severe injury in a crash.

These curves can be used to inform maximum possible vehicle speeds within a safe system, where different conflict types are present. For example:

  • Locations with possible conflicts between cars and vulnerable road users: 30km/h

  • Locations where side impacts are possible: 50km/h

  • Locations where frontal impacts are possible: 70km/h

  • Locations where no side or frontal impacts are possible: 100km/h

Higher speeds are possible where the road environment allows. For example, adding a median barrier removes the possibility of frontal impacts which release greater forces. Separation of vulnerable road users and motor vehicles also facilitates higher speeds (such as by segregating cyclists and motor vehicles with dedicated lanes).  

Once the safe speed, according to human tolerance, has been determined, the next step is to ensure that the new limit is credible. Credible speed limits are limits that drivers feel meet their expectations. If the limit is not logical to the road user, they are less likely to be compliant. Typically, this will involve combining the limit change with other traffic calming measures and providing information to the public about the change. Traffic enforcement should be used as a complementary measure where drivers are still not compliant.

Sources

International Transport Forum (ITF/OECD). (2018). Speed and crash risk. https://www.itf-oecd.org/sites/default/files/docs/speed-crash-risk.pdf

SWOV Institute for Road Safety Research. (2021). Speed and speed management (Fact Sheet). The Hague: SWOV. https://swov.nl/en/facts-figures/factsheet/speed-and-speed-management/

Truong, J., Strandroth, J., Logan, D. B., Job, R. F. S., & Newstead, S. (2022). Utilising human crash tolerance to design an interim and ultimate safe system for road safety. Sustainability, 14(6), 3491. https://doi.org/10.3390/su14063491

World Health Organization. (2023). Speed management: A road safety manual for decision-makers and practitioners (2nd ed.). Geneva: WHO. https://cdn.who.int/media/docs/default-source/documents/health-topics/road-traffic-injuries/3146-wbk-speed-mgmt-2nd-edition-131023-electronic.pdf