Urban Speeds - Accommodating Vulnerable Road Users

Prev Next
This content is currently unavailable in English (UK). You are viewing the default (English) version.

Implications for Delivery

When setting speed limits it is helpful to consider the following:

  • Identify the safe limit based on design, modal mix, and conflicts.

  • Check credibility so limits feel logical to users.

  • Provide clear signage and information.

  • Use traffic calming where needed.

  • Apply enforcement to support compliance.

  • Back changes with education and communication campaigns

Background

Managing speeds is critical to the effective implementation of the Safe System. In a system where the frailty of humans is acknowledged as a key risk factor, considering how speed limits can be used to help protect those most at risk from death or serious injury is particularly relevant.

Road users walking, wheeling or cycling are those most at risk due to their inherent vulnerability - they aren’t protected by a ‘metal box’ – and as a result can be subject to the most severe of injuries. Efforts to prevent the top 10% of MAIS3+ classified injuries, aligns with focusing efforts on protecting those who are walking, wheeling and cycling.

At 20mph a pedestrian is likely to survive an impact with a motor vehicle whereas at 30mph the pedestrian is significantly more likely to be killed.

Recognising that vulnerable road user numbers are highest in bult-up areas – towns and cities - speed limits in urban areas should be aligned with the maximum levels of energy tolerable by the human body to minimise the risk these road users are exposed to.

Where pedestrian and cycle movements are high is often also where the sense of ‘place’ is high and movement is considered a lesser function of the road network. Therefore considering road function is also a means of identifying where speed measures need to be aligned to the presence of VRUs.

UN Global plan calls on all Members states to set speed limits of 30km/h (20mph) in urban areas where there is a mix of different modes.

What the Research Shows

Wramborg (2005) published one of the first widely recognised fatality risk curves illustrating how pedestrian risk increases exponentially with speed.

More recent studies have put forward new injury risk curves that indicate a greater level of risk occurs at lower speeds than was previously indicated while others allow for much greater impact on wider system protections - around vehicle safety especially (Doecke, 2020; Rizzi, 2023; Truong, 2022; Lubbe, 2022 & Jurewicz, 2016).

The introduction of 20mph on restricted roads in Wales – roads where VRU movements are expected to be highest - has resulted in a 26% reduction in collisions Oct 2023 to Sept 2024 compared to the same period the year before.

The LUSTRE: Lower Urban Speed Limits in Europe report found that 20mph limits result in approximately 11% fewer casualties than before in the UK.

Guidance for Speed Limit Setting

SWOV guidance for speed management sets out concise steps for speed limit setting. While focused on implementation in the Netherlands, these provide a useful reference:

  • Step 1: Determine what speed limit is safe: This is the starting point based around road function and design, modal mix and conflict types. Safe limits cannot be retrofitted by themselves, changes require audits of what can and should support compliance.

  • Step 2: Behavioural and credibility check: limits should be considered logical and apparent to all users based on perception. Certain characteristics may make a safe limit credible.

  • Step 3: Provide information: Sufficient and appropriate information about the limit.

  • Step 4: Deploy physical traffic calming measures where necessary: Locations must be logical and align with the intended speeds on given roads.

  • Step 5: Deploy enforcement intervention to support compliance with the limit: A focus on both deterrence and prevention is necessary.

  • Step 6: Support with education and publicity campaigns: The main objectives are building risk awareness and acceptance of speed limits as part of wider speed management efforts.

Roads form a network of connected streets and speed limit setting should not be done in isolation. Aligning speed limits with the place vs movement model requires an understanding of a roads function, and categorising the network into clear road types against which appropriate speed limits may be set.

Potential increase in journey times as a result of lower speed limits. Evaluation of the Wales default 20mph limit reported an increase in journey times, but generally not by more than 2 minutes.

Improvements in journey time reliability; as a result of slower speeds journey times are subject to less congestion. Wales reported journey time variability decreased by more than 20% on over half of all monitoring routes in the initial 12-month monitoring period.

A key lesson learnt from the Wales 20mph legislative change is how the proposed changes are communicated to the public. A robust communication plan should support the introduction of 20mph speed limits to ensure all road users understand why the speed limits are being changed and the intended outcomes.

Sources

Doecke, S. D., Baldock, M. R. J., Kloeden, C. N., & Dutschke, J. K. (2020). Impact speed and the risk of serious injury in vehicle crashes. Accident Analysis & Prevention, 144, 105629. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aap.2020.105629

Jurewicz, C., Sobhani, A., Woolley, J., Dutschke, J., & Corben, B. (2016). Exploration of vehicle impact speed–injury severity relationships for application in safer road design. Transportation Research Procedia, 14, 4247–4256. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.trpro.2016.05.396

Lubbe, N., Wu, Y., & Jeppsson, H. (2022). Safe speeds: Fatality and injury risks of pedestrians, cyclists, motorcyclists, and car drivers impacting the front of another passenger car as a function of closing speed and age. Traffic Safety Research, 2, Article 000006. https://doi.org/10.55329/vfma7555

Rizzi, M., Boström, O., Fredriksson, R., Kullgren, A., Lubbe, N., Strandroth, J., & Tingvall, C. (2023). Proposed speed limits for the 2030 motor vehicle (Paper No. 23-0166). The 27th International Technical Conference on the Enhanced Safety of Vehicles (ESV), Yokohama. Available at: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/369905901_Proposed_Speed_Limits_for_the_2030_Motor_Vehicle.

SWOV Institute for Road Safety Research. (2021). Speed and speed management (Fact Sheet). The Hague: SWOV. https://swov.nl/en/fact-sheet/speed-and-speed-management

Truong, J., Strandroth, J., Logan, D. B., Job, R. F. S., & Newstead, S. (2022). Utilising human crash tolerance to design an interim and ultimate safe system for road safety. Sustainability, 14(6), 3491. https://doi.org/10.3390/su14063491