Vehicle Fleets

Prev Next
This content is currently unavailable in English (UK). You are viewing the default (English) version.

Implications for Delivery

Procurement systems are a powerful tool for increasing safety. This can be done by procuring vehicles with:

  • Better primary safety (features which prevent crashes occurring),

  • Better secondary safety (features which prevent or reduce the severity of injury when a crash does occur, to those inside and outside the vehicle), and

  • Better tertiary safety (mitigating the consequence of crashes after they have occurred, such as Multi-Collision Brake Assist (MCB), a safety feature in vehicles that automatically applies the brakes after a collision to reduce the severity of subsequent impacts. This can help to prevent or mitigate secondary collisions by slowing the vehicle down after the initial impact).

The business case to communicate to organisations is that specifying safer vehicles will:

  • Reduce the number of crashes, thereby reducing insurance and repair costs and minimising business disruption

  • Reduce injuries and severity of injury

  • Is an effective way to manage safety and reduce risk of prosecution (as it is reasonably practicable to procure safer vehicles)

  • Improves employee morale as it evidences that the organisation cares about their safety and that of the community.

Background

Vehicle fleets are a key part of managing road safety for any organisation. This applies not just to the safety standards that the vehicles meet, but also the number of vehicles available.

Too many vehicles in a car fleet and there may be increased pressure to use them instead of taking a safer mode of travel such as rail. Too few vehicles in a car fleet may increase the pressure for employees to use their own vehicles for some trips, which poses a higher risk with less management control over condition. Similarly, too few vehicles in a commercial fleet can lead to pressure to keep vehicles on the road even when they have faults which should lead to them being taken out of service for repairs.

Fleets where all the vehicles are of the same make and model can cause issues where a “one size fits all” approach leads to vehicles being unsuitable for some staff, and the risk that if there is a safety recall, the whole fleet might have to be taken out of service at the same time.

Setting a maximum age for vehicles within the fleet makes it more likely that vehicles will be fitted with more of the latest safety equipment and specifying safer vehicles can have a significant effect on the injury risk to employees and the public. EuroNCAP (the European New Car Assessment Programme) testing is now moving to rating vans and trucks as well as cars. Specifying that only vehicles which meet 5 stars in EuroNCAP testing can be procured offers significant safety benefits.

What the Research Shows

Technologies we now take for granted were once option – Electronic Stability control reduces single-vehicle fatal crashes by 40%-56% for example. New technology which is not yet mandatory such as Automated Emergency Braking, when combined with a warning, is effective at reducing rear-end crashes by 50 percent and injuries by 56 percent, according to the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, and the European Commission, a 5-star rated vehicle lowers the risk of fatal injury by 68% compared to a 2-star rated vehicle, and by an estimated 12% compared to 4-star rated vehicle.

BHP Billiton committed to 5-star ANCAP (the Australian New Car Assessment Programme) rating in 2012 and successfully influenced Toyota to upgrade the popular Hilux from 4 to 5-Star ANCAP and as a result lifted the safety standard of 40,000 light vehicles per year in Australia.

According to the Network of Employers for Traffic Safety in the USA, “In general, safety features available to raise vehicles to 5-stars cost around $500-1000 at point of sale. Applying a $750 average per new purchased 5-star vehicle means that [a fleet] could purchase 900 vehicles and still be financially covered by the avoided costs of crashes ($678k). (2015 prices)

The International Association of Oil and Gas producers has made it recommended practice for all member companies to use 5 Star vehicles.

Sources

Csere, C. (2025, June 17). How much safer do active safety systems make cars, really? Car & Driver. https://www.caranddriver.com/features/a64945529/cars-active-safety-systems-how-effective/

Edmonds, S., van Ratingen, M., Petit-Boulanger, C., Castaing, P., & Gentilleau, M. (n.d.). EURO NCAP RESCUE – Tertiary safety assessment (Paper No. 23-0258). On behalf of the Euro NCAP Rescue, Extrication and Safety Working Group. Euro NCAP. https://cdn.euroncap.com/media/77178/27esv-000258.pdf

Euro NCAP. (n.d.). Euro NCAP: The European New Car Assessment Programme. https://www.euroncap.com/en/

Euro NCAP. (n.d.). Truck & van safety (Safer Trucks). https://www.euroncap.com/en/truck-van-safety/

FIA Region I. (2024). Heavy goods vehicle safety in the spotlight as Euro NCAP launches brand-new TRUCK SAFE assessment programme. https://www.fiaregion1.com/heavy-goods-vehicle-safety-in-the-spotlight-as-euro-ncap-launches-brand-new-truck-safe-assessment-programme/

International Association of Oil & Gas Producers [IOGP]. (2018). The case for safer vehicles. https://www.iogp.org/workstreams/safety/safety/fivestar/

Network of Employers for Traffic Safety [NETS]. (2015). Cost of motor vehicle crashes to employers – 2015. https://trafficsafety.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/NETS-CostOfCrashes-Report-2015.pdf

Precey, M., & Fox, N. (2022, June 21). New East of England ambulances being obtained for ‘too tall’ staff. BBC News. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-cambridgeshire-61867298

Swedish Transport Administration. (2019). Saving lives beyond 2020: The next steps – Recommendations of the Academic Expert Group for the 3rd Global Ministerial Conference on Road Safety. https://www.roadsafetysweden.com/contentassets/c65bb9192abb44d5b26b633e70e0be2c/200113_final-report-single.pdf


With thanks to The Transafe Network for their contribution to this content.

Logo of the Trans Safe Network