Implications for Delivery
Roadside barriers are the primary Safe System treatment for run-off-road risks. Clear Zones are a supporting measure – helpful where barriers are not feasible but unlikely to be sufficient in isolation.
Design Requirements for Clear Zones
Must be free of fixed hazards, with width based on speed, traffic volume, and road geometry.
Slopes should be traversable/recoverable (1:5 or 1:6 gradient).
Frangible/shear-base poles and traversable culvert headwalls may be acceptable.
Effectiveness
Clear Zones reduce run-off-road crash severity by 10–30%, but barriers deliver greater risk reduction.
More effective on rural roads with wide verges and lower volumes.
Flexible barriers often outperform Clear Zones in reducing injuries.
Limitations & Risks
Require significant space – often impractical in constrained or urban environments.
Do not eliminate risk – vehicles may roll over or exceed cleared area.
Less cost-effective than barrier systems.
Implications for Practice
Use Clear Zones as run-out areas where barriers are not feasible.
Apply a risk management process to balance safety, cost, and site constraints.
Prioritise barriers for high-risk or constrained locations, and integrate Clear Zones only as part of a broader Safe System approach.
Background
Transport Scotland’s Road Safety Framework to 2030 identifies infrastructure design as a key element in reducing road casualties. The framework supports the principle of forgiving roadsides, which includes the removal of roadside hazards and the provision of recovery space for errant vehicles. Providing Clear Zones is one example of a forgiving roadside.
Clear Zones are areas beyond the edge of the carriageway that provide space for vehicles to safely recover if they leave the sealed surface. Clear zones are defined by several key characteristics:
They must be free of fixed hazards, with the required width determined by traffic speed, volume, and road alignment.
The slope within the zone should be traversable or recoverable, typically at gradients of 1:5 or 1:6.
Certain roadside assets, such as shear-base or frangible poles, may be permitted within the zone.
Culvert headwalls should be designed with traversable profiles.
While Clear Zones reduce the likelihood of collisions with fixed objects, they do not eliminate risk entirely. Vehicles may still rollover or travel beyond the cleared area, particularly at higher speeds or on uneven terrain.
Evidence shows that continuous flexible roadside barriers can result in fewer injuries compared to clear zones alone. Therefore, Clear Zones should be considered in the following context:
They are a supporting safety treatment and should not be relied upon to deliver Safe System outcomes in isolation.
Where continuous barriers cannot be installed, some level of Clear zone is preferable to none.
Clear Zones themselves can pose risks, such as rollover incidents, and should be assessed with the same level of scrutiny as barriers.
Clear Zones should be viewed as run-out areas, designed to allow safe vehicle departures without exposing occupants to non-survivable impacts or rollover hazards.
What the Research Shows
Across the UK, the concept of clear zones is embedded in design guidance such as the Design Manual for Roads and Bridges (DMRB), which recommends hazard-free recovery areas based on speed, traffic volume, and road geometry. Although specific crash reduction figures for clear zones are limited in UK literature, international studies - particularly from Australia and the United States - demonstrate that clear zones can reduce run-off-road crash severity and improve overall road safety.
US and Australasian crash data shows that clear zones represent a 10 to 30% reduction in run off road crashes.
These figures support the use of clear zones as an effective countermeasure for reducing the severity and frequency of run-off-road incidents. However, both regions emphasise that clear zones should be part of a broader Safe System approach and not used in isolation.
Key Considerations
An appropriate risk management process is essential when determining the most suitable roadside safety treatment. This process should align with Safe System principles and consider the specific context of each road environment.
1. Roadside Barriers as the Primary Safe System Treatment
Safe roadside barriers are the preferred treatment for managing run-off-road crash risk. They provide a physical means of preventing vehicles from striking hazardous roadside features and are particularly effective in high-risk or constrained environments.
2. Clear Zones as a Supporting Treatment
Clear zones serve as a supporting Safe System treatment where barriers are not feasible. These areas provide space for errant vehicles to recover safely without collision. Their effectiveness depends on several factors:
The required width is determined by traffic speed, volume, and horizontal alignment.
Clear zones are most effective on rural roads with lower traffic volumes and wide verges, where vehicles can decelerate or regain control.
Design Requirements for Clear Zones:
Must be free from fixed hazards over a width appropriate to the road context.
Should have a traversable or recoverable slope (typically 1:5 or 1:6).
May include shear-base or frangible roadside assets.
Culvert headwalls should be designed with traversable profiles.
Advantages:
Allows vehicle recovery without impact.
Reduces the severity of run-off-road crashes.
Requires minimal maintenance once established.
Limitations:
Requires significant space, which may not be available in constrained or urban environments.
May still present rollover risks or allow vehicles to travel beyond the cleared area.
While clear zones contribute to improved safety, their cost-effectiveness is generally lower compared to barrier systems. They should be considered as a complementary measure rather than a standalone solution. Roadside barriers remain the treatment most closely aligned with Safe System outcomes.
Sources
Federal Highway Administration. (2023). Clear zones. U.S. Department of Transportation. Retrieved from https://highways.dot.gov/safety/rwd/provide-safe-recovery/clear-zones/clear-zones
Crash Modification Factors Clearinghouse. (2025). Crash modification factors database. U.S. Department of Transportation, Federal Highway Administration. Retrieved from https://cmfclearinghouse.fhwa.dot.gov/
FHWA Office of Safety. (2013). Using CMFs to quantify the safety performance of design decisions and exceptions. U.S. Department of Transportation. Retrieved from https://highways.fhwa.dot.gov/sites/fhwa.dot.gov/files/Using_cmfs_to_quantify_the_safety_performance_of_design_decisions_and_exceptions.pdf
With thanks to Safe System Solutions for their contribution to this content.
