Implications for Delivery
Purchasing is a powerful mechanism for change, making fleet procurement a valuable tool in implementing and encouraging the adoption of vehicle safety interventions. Ways practitioners can support this include:
Integrating safety into procurement decisions – Build vehicle safety criteria (e.g., Euro NCAP ratings for cars, vans, and HGVs) into purchasing policies and require a minimum star rating. For vehicles without a rating system (e.g., buses, motorcycles), use recognised safety standards such as Transport for London’s Bus Safety Standard, where possible. Ensure buyers have the knowledge and authority to specify the safest configurations, especially in modular or bespoke vehicle builds.
Avoiding regulatory loopholes and safety downgrades – Around major regulation update dates, confirm that purchased stock meets expected safety requirements, as “end of life” models and pre-registered vehicles may lack new mandatory systems.
Using retrofit strategically – Retrofit safety technologies where full fleet renewal is slow, prioritising warning systems that are easier to install. Weigh the benefits of quicker deployment against possible lower performance and higher installation costs compared with factory-fitted systems.
Background
As mentioned in Methods of Implementation, purchasing can be a powerful mechanism for change. However, to achieve this in practice, an environment is needed where it is easy for buyers under pressure to achieve financial, operational, and environmental criteria. Cutting edge safety systems may represent an additional cost and an operational risk (what if it proves unreliable in service and costs a lot in repair? And who wants to be the first mover?).
Procurement of vehicles, whether buying or leasing, is complex. It can lead to much time spent reading brochures and price lists and negotiating with salespeople. Time spent on specifying safer vehicles will help to reduce the risk of collisions and casualties. It will also help to keep vehicles operational for greater periods and reduce downtime due to repairs.
The information available about new vehicles can vary depending on the vehicle type. Cars tend to have detailed sales brochures and price lists. It is only possible to purchase vehicles that are available in these price lists, with some variations depending on trim level and options.
However, larger vehicles (such as trucks and buses) are not so structured when it comes to makes, models, and specifications. In procurement, it is possible to produce nearly bespoke vehicles. Scania trucks are an extreme example, but their manufacturing process is completely modular. They market 5 different ‘models’ but in reality, the basic cab structure is the same for each and all the components are common. In effect, they have one truck with a huge number of possible variants, that for marketing purposes they brand as a series of models.
Safety standards are just one of the many objectives fleet purchasing staff will be aiming to satisfy. In commercial vehicles particularly, it may not be top of the priority list. Margins are very tight and operational capability, fuel efficiency, uptime, and maintenance support are mission critical. Historically, there has been little if any information available that helps buyers choose the safer vehicles. Regulation guarantees they are ‘safe’ (at least to a certain level) and all manufacturers will tell buyers their vehicles are the safest available and that their optional extras are worth the money. How does the buyer tell what is really effective, and what is really worth the money?
What the Research Shows
There has been very little research conducted in this area, particularly in relation to fleet purchasing and larger vehicles. However, a recent project looked specifically at the uptake and use of Intelligent Speed Assistance (ISA). The project produced a leaflet and animation designed to encourage the uptake and use of ISA by individual drivers. It also recommended making ISA as widely available as possible and promoting it to the driving public. This demonstrates the need to ensure drivers are appropriately informed of, and trained to use, the technology on their vehicles and understand the reason it has been specified in the fleet.
Euro NCAP Ratings and Other Systems
One key element in delivering in this area is to keep things as simple as possible. In passenger cars, the Euro NCAP rating is extremely helpful in this regard. High ratings can only be achieved either where all the equipment needed for the rating is fitted as standard across Europe, or where it is available in a single ‘safety pack’ that can be specified very easily as optional equipment.
Actions to encourage fleet buyers to use Euro NCAP ratings are still needed because many fleets do not yet use them. However, once committed to using it, implementation is a very simple requirement for a minimum 4-star, or even 5-star, vehicle.
Euro NCAP ratings are now available for vans and for long haul tractor units in the HGV market. Ratings for other sectors of the HGV market will be added over the coming three years. However, reflecting the more varied nature of the commercial vehicle market and the relative immaturity of the rating system and manufacturers’ familiarity with it, these schemes rate the best available safety specification. It remains up to the fleet buyer and the manufacturer’s sales team to ensure that all the right option boxes are ticked. As such, efforts are needed here to ensure buyers and management teams are aware of ratings and are motivated to use them to buy the safest vehicles. However, efforts may also be required to ensure that the buyers are familiar enough with the systems and the rating scheme to ensure that the right specification is set.
For vehicles such as buses, motorcycles, and new modes of vehicle (e.g. micromobility, automated pods), no simplified ratings are yet available. As such, ensuring the safest vehicles are bought is very difficult and requires considerable expertise. Transport for London (TfL) has invested extremely heavily in developing its bus safety standard, which is implemented through the franchising arrangement for contracting bus operators. It is proving a very powerful influence, at least on the smaller manufacturers that mainly supply London’s buses. However, it is unique in the UK and comparable systems elsewhere in the world are not thought to be nearly so comprehensive.
Harmonisation of such standards across large regions greatly increase buying power. Euro NCAP are also considering adding buses to the rating, but it is likely to take several years of development before first implementation and there are many technical challenges. In the meantime, greater use of London’s standard and ongoing development of it, is likely to offer additional benefits.
Although in principle, even without all of the above, Regulations such as the recently implemented revision of the General Safety Regulation (GSR2) in Europe will guarantee a certain level of safety, there are aspects to be careful of in purchasing. The headline was that all new registrations from July 2024 must be compliant. However, the regulations have some exceptions for ‘end of life’ models and the reality is that dealerships will have stock to sell off, and they may even pre-register them. As such, buyers need to be aware that if buying stock around these key update dates, that it is still important to specify and check that the safety systems expected will actually be fitted.
Retrofit or aftermarket sales
Retrofit is the fitment of systems after initial sale of the vehicle; it can also be called aftermarket sales. Retrofit of some, but not all, safety systems is feasible. It depends on the type of system, particularly the hardware (such as sensors) that has to be installed. In general, retrofit of warning systems is more likely than intervention systems. Safety systems that intervene and take action on behalf of the driver will generally require greater integration into the vehicle, which is less feasible in retrofit. Although there are exceptions, generally aftermarket retrofit technologies have lesser performance than equivalent systems properly integrated by the Original Equipment Manufacturer (OEM). Retrofit campaigns also incur significant costs in terms of vehicle downtime and the fact that installations are undertaken in a workshop environment, not on a robotised production line. Although the product cost may not be more expensive than an OEM option, the total cost can be considerably higher. The advantage of retrofit is that the safety effect reaches its maximum potential more quickly because you do not have to wait years to renew a whole fleet of vehicles. However, with potentially reduced performance and increased costs, the relative effectiveness compared with a new vehicles approach needs careful consideration.
Sources
Road Safety Trust. (2025). UK drivers encouraged to use Intelligent Speed Assistance (ISA) in vehicles. Road Safety Trust. https://www.roadsafetytrust.org.uk/news/uk-drivers-encouraged-to-use-intelligent-speed-assistance-isa-in-vehicles
With thanks to Apollo Vehicle Safety for their contribution to this content.
