Information, Warning & Intervention

Prev Next
This content is currently unavailable in English (UK). You are viewing the default (English) version.

Implications for Delivery

The effectiveness of many safety systems is very strongly dependent on their interaction with the driver. It is also clear that a proportion of drivers who do not understand current driver assistance systems and/or find them annoying. This could result in reduced take up where such systems are optional; turning them off or ignoring them where they are not optional; and reduced support for new developments.

When safety interventions are considered in isolation, an acoustic warning can seem an obvious and potentially highly effective solution. However, even if that particular system only activates in urgent and critical situations, it may not be effective if there is another system already on the vehicle that issues a similar alert in very frequent situations that are neither critical nor urgent.

As such, applying an assessment of the whole driving environment for the vehicle can be very important to effectiveness. These will often favour integrated OEM systems over a collection of aftermarket systems. Those purchasing vehicles or specifying safety equipment for them (original fit, dealer fit or aftermarket) should consider this wherever possible.

Fleets also have an opportunity through the use of telematics and camera systems now commonly employed to monitor driver acceptance and the cab environment. Such information could be extremely valuable to manufacturers, researchers and regulators in designing better systems and better regulations in this area.

Background

Within both Safe Driving and Crash avoidance, there are a range of systems that attempt to communicate with the driver in some way. Systems within crash protection do exist but there is no significant interaction with driver behaviour. This is because the duration of that phase is typically measured in milliseconds, so they are not considered here.

The way these systems communicate with the driver can be divided into Information, Warning, and Intervention (IWI):

  • Information – non-urgent information provided to the driver to help them drive safely

  • Warning – given in an emergency situation to stimulate the driver to take appropriate action, such as braking or steering to prevent a collision

  • Intervention – automatic vehicle intervention if the driver is unresponsive. May include braking or steering to prevent a collision

One vehicle may have multiple different assistance systems all trying to communicate with the driver. To ensure that communication is clear and effective so that the driver responds correctly, a good strategy is required across all systems. If poorly implemented (for example, if all information and warning signals use the same acoustic tonal alert), then it will be issued very frequently. The driver will have no context to interpret what the acoustic alert means or how urgent it is, and in this case, it becomes much more likely that the signal will annoy the driver which, where possible, could lead to turning systems off. This could undermine trust in the vehicle and its systems and can lead to systems being ignored or even into actively developing the wrong response from the driver.

What the Research Shows

Research has shown that warnings can have a balance of how effective versus how annoying they are. This balance depends on the type of warning, and its interface. In general, according to Baldwin & Lewis (2014):

  • Visual warnings with a simple colour or written message were least annoying but least alerting. At their best, they could be as alerting as tactile and audible warnings at the lower end of their range.

  • Flashing visual warnings can be more alerting. They can be substantially more annoying.

  • Audible warnings were among the most alerting. They can be the most annoying too.

  • Tactile warnings are different. The best versions can be as alerting as the best audible warnings but are less annoying.

Naujoks et al. (2016) indicated that driver response depends on the warning presentation. Combined audio-visual warnings get a quicker response than audible warning alone.

ISO standards have been developed which provide guidance on a wide range of ergonomic considerations of information, warning, and intervention systems. These include classifications of situations in terms of their urgency (in what time frame must the driver take action), and their criticality (how bad are the consequences if they fail to heed the information or warning). United Nations guidelines for regulators (produced in 2011 and cited in TfL research into the HGV safety permit), combined all of these concepts into a simple approach that audible (tonal) warnings should be reserved for situations where the driver needed to take action within around 2 seconds in order to avoid a collision. This is also the type of situation where emergency interventions could be considered. Situations where the driver only needed to respond with a time of more than about 10 seconds should be considered ‘information’ and typically be a visual only signal. Those situations in-between could be more urgent visual warnings (e.g. flashing, change of colours), or haptic warnings including, for example ,some interventions of lesser severity (e.g. automated brake jerks to wake a driver up, rather than a prolonged heavy application to stop the vehicle).

Sources

Baldwin, C. L., & Lewis, B. A. (2014). Perceived urgency mapping across modalities within a driving context. Applied ergonomics, 45(5), 1270-1277. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apergo.2013.05.002

European New Car Assessment Programme (Euro NCAP). (n.d.). Safety Assist. https://www.euroncap.com/en/car-safety/the-ratings-explained/safety-assist/

Knight et al, 2018, HGV safety permit for London. Apollo Vehicle Safety, Corston

ISO, 2004. Ergonomic aspects of transport information and control systems – procedures for determining priority of on-board messages presented to drivers: Technical specification 16951, Geneva: International Organisation for Standardisation.

ISO, 2005. Road Vehicles - Ergonomic aspects of in-vehicle presentation for transport information and control systems - warning systems: ISO technical report TR16352, Geneva: International Organisation for Standardisation

Naujoks, F., Kiesel, A., & Neukum, A. (2016). Cooperative warning systems: The impact of false and unnecessary alarms on drivers’ compliance. Accident Analysis & Prevention, 97, 162-175. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aap.2016.09.009


With thanks to Apollo Vehicle Safety for their contribution to this content.

Apollo Vehicle Safety logo