Vehicle Weight & Size

Prev Next
This content is currently unavailable in English (UK). You are viewing the default (English) version.

Implications for Delivery

Properly understanding cause, not just correlation, is essential to good policy in this area. In general, the safety performance of vehicles is complex and can’t be properly controlled with simplistic weight and dimension limits. Performance-based standards are more complex but much more likely to be effective. Key considerations for practitioners include:

  • Use the right vehicle for the job – efficiency is king - not too big, not too small

  • Focus on performance – how well it avoids key collisions, and how it protects occupants and partner vehicles in a collision is more important to safety than size and weight. Use safety ratings such as Euro NCAP, wherever they are available.

  • Always check statistics – correlation does not mean causation. Weights and dimensions can have complicated and unexpected effects. Challenge simplistic assumptions.

  • Design smart rules – weights and dimensions affects everything, not just safety. Consider all the impacts, focus on performance, and always think of the potential for unintended consequences. How people react to the new rules is critical, and not always as expected beforehand.

Background

Governments place limits on how big and heavy road vehicles can be, with the aim of ensuring safety, protecting roads and bridges, limiting pollution, and ensuring fair competition between different types of transport (like road and rail), and internationally between companies. Vehicle size and weight influence nearly all aspects of the transport system.

Transport efficiency and risk

Before looking specifically at the effects on safety of vehicle weight and size, it is important to understand that transport efficiency will also play a part in the risk calculations. Every vehicle on the road increases the chance of a crash happening. The more vehicles there are, and the more miles they drive, the more interaction with other road users there is and the greater the exposure to risk of a collision.

To make roads safer, it’s important to reduce both:

  • The risk of each journey (e.g. by making vehicles safer), and

  • The amount of driving needed (e.g. by making transport more efficient).

Commonly, this is simplified as:

Number of casualties = Risk (casualties per vehicle km) * Exposure to Risk (number of vehicle km)

How do size and weight affect safety?

The relationship between the size and weight of a vehicle and how safe it is isn’t as straightforward as people might think, for example:

  • Buses are much larger and heavier than cars but have fewer casualties per passenger km.  

  • Double decked buses are involved in more collisions per vehicle km than single deck buses, but substantially fewer per passenger km.  

  • Trains are even heavier — and are also among the safest forms of travel.

So, bigger and heavier doesn’t necessarily mean less safe. What matters is how well the vehicle is used and how safe it is by design.

For commercial vehicles (HGVs, buses and coaches), cost and profit will be big factors encouraging their efficient use. For example, where there is high demand, one double decked bus will be more efficient than running two single deck buses, and will reduce exposure to risk. But, if demand is lower, running one single deck bus will carry less risk than one double deck bus with the same number of passengers on. Similar examples could be used for goods vehicles carrying cargo. In these cases, the regulations limiting the vehicle’s size or weight will have a direct relationship to how many passengers or how much cargo they can carry. A bus on a busy route will want as much passenger capacity as possible, so the maximum length becomes a significant constraint on capacity, and the same is true for HGVs.

For cars it is very different, as they may be used for business, commuting, and leisure purposes and the choice of vehicle will be influenced by style, comfort, and social factors as well as cost and efficiency. Most cars will spend most of their time used well below their full capacity regardless of their size. The regulations limit cars to no more than eight seats (more than eight seats makes it a bus) and no more than 12m in length. So, in practice, car length is constrained by the number of seats it can have rather than how long it can be.

So, particularly for commercial vehicles, mass, length, and height often give a good indication of a vehicle’s capacity, which links to efficiency and risk exposure. But things get more complicated when economics are involved. If a vehicle is more efficient, it can be cheaper to run. Cheaper road transport may compete more with other modes like rail, and it might make it cost-effective to source materials from further away. Both factors can increase the amount of time vehicles spend on the road, and therefore the overall risk.

How does vehicle weight affect a crash?

Research clearly shows that, in a crash, the change in speed (delta-V’) is the factor that most strongly influences the severity of any injuries.

If two cars of the same weight crash head-on at the same speed, they both come to a stop: both vehicles see the same delta-V, and the people in both vehicles feel the same collision force.

But, if a small car collides with a heavier vehicle (like an SUV or a truck) at the same speed, that is no longer true:

  • A 1.5 tonne car hitting a 2.5 tonne SUV head-on, each at 50 km/h, the SUV will slow to 13 km/h (delta-V= 37 km/h), but the car will end up going backwards at 13 km/h (delta-V= 63 km/h)

  • If the SUV is replaced with an 18 tonne truck, the delta-V for the car is 92 km/h

  • If the car hits a 44 tonne truck, the delta-V for the car is 97 km/h

The maximum change of speed possible in this situation is 100 km/h. So, the risk to the occupant of the car is very sensitive to the weight of the other vehicle it hits when the other vehicle is also relatively small. However, as the weight difference increases, further increases become less important. The difference between 18 tonnes and 44 tonnes is a delta-V of 5 km/h and above 44 tonnes there is little remaining change.

This same principle works for collisions between vehicles and pedestrians. The same car at 50 km/h hitting an 80 kg pedestrian that is stationary will accelerate the pedestrian to 47 km/h; an SUV to 48 km/h; and a 44 tonne truck to 49.9 km/h. Because the weight of the pedestrian is so much smaller in proportion to any of the vehicles, the difference in delta-V experienced by the pedestrian is relatively small even though there is a very large difference in weight between the vehicles.

In the vehicle to vehicle situation, as the risk for the smaller car occupant goes up, the risk for the occupant of the other vehicle goes down because they see a smaller change in speed.

Of course, this is a simple analysis of one risk. If an HGV hits another HGV, or a queue of light vehicle traffic, or a bridge support, then further increases in weight can have an effect on injury severity. This is also just one risk of many that can relate to weight, length, and height. Braking performance, directional stability, roll stability, field of view, manoeuvrability, overtaking times, ability to maintain speeds on hills (avoidance of large speed differentials), junction clearance times, driver workload and others can potentially all be influenced.

‘Carbesity’ and the SUV

Over time, vehicles have got considerably heavier. The table below provides example comparisons of the Range Rover and Mini Cooper models from 1990, 2005, and 2025 (these examples are to illustrate the point, not for statistical proof).

Year

Range Rover weight

Mini Cooper weight

Weight ratio between Range Rover and Mini Cooper

1990

2000 kg

700 kg

2.9 : 1

2005

2450 kg

1075 kg

2.3 : 1

2025

2700 kg

1320 kg

2 : 1

In 2022, the VIAS institute in Belgium showed that in single vehicle collisions, SUV occupants had a 24% better chance of survival than passenger car occupants. In SUV to car collisions, there were 2.6 SUV occupant deaths per thousand collisions and 5.7 for passenger car occupants: a clear inequality of risk.

The popularity of SUVs has increased: they are bigger than standard cars, and the weight of all cars has increased over time. However, the compatibility issue between cars is not a new one. In 1995, the UK’s Transport Research Laboratory highlighted similar large discrepancies in the risk of casualties in lighter and heavier cars of the time. The study was repeated in 1999 and 2007 confirming similar effects. In 2007, it was found that drivers in the smallest types of car on the road at that time, were 4 times more likely to die than drivers of the largest cars.

As car sizes and weights have changed considerably over time, this can also introduce risk inequalities: with people that are able to afford large, new SUVs reducing their own risk but increasing the risk to people who can only afford (or choose to drive) older, smaller cars.

This presents a difficult challenge as the TRL study in 2007 found that collisions involving newer cars were substantially less severe than collisions involving older cars, and that improved crash protection systems in those vehicles were likely to be a major factor. The improved crash protection systems will have also contributed to their increased weight.

The research also shows it is not just a straightforward link between weight and risk. The TRL analysis in 1999 noted a slightly increased overall risk when the mass of both vehicles was added together. A model predicted that a 10% reduction in weight across the whole fleet would result in a 3-4% reduction in casualties. However, the VIAS Institute research showed that the severity of car-to-car collisions was slightly higher than SUV-to-SUV collisions.

Bonnet height

For pedestrian collisions, a 2025 study by the London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine highlighted that SUVs are associated with a much higher risk of death than traditional cars. This study (and other similar work) didn’t link it to the weight of the larger vehicles, but their geometry. In this case, correlation is generally considered to be related to the height of the bonnet for cars, but studies on trucks show the same phenomenon where there is no bonnet. The consensus appears to be that the problem is related to the movement of the pedestrian after the initial impact. The higher point of impact pushes the pedestrian down, rather than throwing them up over the bonnet, increasing the severity of impacts with the ground or the potential of being runover by the wheels. More work is needed in this area to understand the causes and help mitigate these types of injuries.

No Simple Solution

The effect of weight and size on risk is a complex issue and there are many instances where effects can be counterintuitive and engineering mitigations are often feasible and effective.

Simplistic constraints carry high risks of unintended consequences. The key is to look specifically at how the vehicle performs in situations where collisions are occurring, and to develop tests that measure that performance and set limits on it. This is known as performance-based standards. If the concern is pedestrian safety with large vehicles, then study what really does cause the problem (e.g. stiffness of vehicles, or the post impact kinematics) and develop tests that require or encourage improvements in that performance.

Performance-based standards should be the preferred route, despite being more complex to design at the start. Mass and geometry limits should be used sparingly, for the cases where good analysis has shown very clearly the simplified approach will be effective and that unintended consequences are unlikely.

Much evidence is available to support this, for example:

  • In 2019, the OECD showed wherever bigger heavier trucks were used, they proved safer in service than standard HGVs.

  • The European Commission highlighted that statistical comparisons could have weaknesses, but that no EU country that permitted use of 25.25m trucks or larger had experienced any increase in the number of fatalities from collisions involving HGVs after their introduction.

  • TfL data shows that obvious risks (falls on stairs, bridge strikes) associated with double decked buses did seem to lead to 8% more collisions per vehicle km than single deck buses, but the extra capacity and efficient use meant 56% fewer collisions per passenger km.


With thanks to Apollo Vehicle Safety for their contribution to this content.

Apollo Vehicle Safety logo